Is it safe to open each C#.Net WinForm in a separate thread?

The real problem I am trying to solve is that I would like all modal dialog boxes to be modal only to their parent form.  In C#.Net, however, all modal dialog boxes (using ShowDialog) are modal to the entire thread.  There are, therefore two possible solutions to this problem: 1) mimic ShowDialog() by using Show() and disabling the parent a different way, or 2) open each WinForm in a separate thread so that any modal dialog boxes only lock that one form.

Option #1 was explored in question #23378010, but I'd like to explore the other option (one thread per form) with this question.  It will take some work to make our application thread-safe, so I'd like to know first if this is even a viable option.

Initial testing of this option seems to work ok, except that I will occasionally get a 'System.OutOfMemoryException Error creating window handle at System.Windows.Forms.NativeWindow.CreateHandle' exception when I try to open several windows in rapid succession ( I do not get the same exception if I open the same number of windows slowly).

We are using C# and .Net 1.1

Does anyone have experience with opening different forms in different threads?
Who is Participating?
tjw_bldConnect With a Mentor Author Commented:
When searching the internet, you will come across several posts that indicate the you cannot do this.  For example "Only the main thread can access the user interface (forms, etc).  This prevents many race conditions" from

jaime_olivares' post above seems to indicate that you can do this.  Plus, just the fact that .Net provides a method Application.ExitThread seems to indicate that you should be able to do this.

However, when I try it in my code, I get various exceptions if multiple windows are opened at roughly the same time, although this may be due to some third-party libraries we are using.

As my original question indicates, I have also been exploring the option of mimicing the ShowDialog method in question #23378010.  In fact, I have finally gotten that solution to work and I will post the code in that question shortly.
Jaime OlivaresSoftware ArchitectCommented:
I have never tryed, but you can try to lauch the dialog with:

tjw_bldAuthor Commented:
Actaully,that is the version of ShowDialog that we currently use.  Calling yourForm.ShowDialog(theRealParent) will set the owner of the dialog box to be theRealParent, but all forms for the current thread will still be locked, not just theRealParent.  Both versions of ShowDialog work the same as far as locking all forms of the current thread.
Jaime OlivaresConnect With a Mentor Software ArchitectCommented:
a thread can manage just 1 modal dialog, indeed can manage just 1 dialog of any kind at a time
so, using differente threads will allow you to handle them virtually simultaneously.
Jaime OlivaresSoftware ArchitectCommented:
no objection
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.