Link to home
Start Free TrialLog in
Avatar of atlas_shuddered
atlas_shudderedFlag for United States of America

asked on

Active Directory domain with no sign of DNS?

I am trying to help a friend of mine work on a non-profit's W2K3 DC.  Attempting to load AVG to clients via AD, however load fails.  Client reports inability to authenticate against DC.  Upon reviewing DC, AD is loaded and running as best as can be told, users seem to be authenticating against it as server also is used as file server for office and clients able to access authoritatively.  Here is the catch, no sign of DNS running on this server at all.  Have checked under:

1.  Services - only client service is displayed and running
2.  Server Manager - Only Domain Controller and File Server are displayed as rolls
3.  Event Viewer - no DNS log
4.  Add/Remove Components : DNS not checked or otherwise indicated as installed

First, how is this possible - has anyone else seen similar?  Second, how to bring DNS online, potential concerns, mitigations and expectations?
Avatar of dathho
dathho

You've got to have DNS somewhere for AD to work.  What are the DNS entries set to on the server? (ipconfig /all) What is the response from nslookup commands on the server and clients?  Have you tried troubleshootinfg with dnslint?
ASKER CERTIFIED SOLUTION
Avatar of Chris Dent
Chris Dent
Flag of United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland image

Link to home
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
Start Free Trial
If your AD is not relying on external DNS or other 3rd party DNS like unix, then you can try remove DNS and reinstall DNS services.
If your DNS, you must have a Host, Name Server, and SOA  record of your domain controller.
You should be able to run NSLOOKUP the domain name as well as the domain controller server name to get the IP of your domain and vice versa. Just make sure your IP configuration for your DC is pointing to itself as the preferred DNS.
Avatar of atlas_shuddered

ASKER

dathho

I'm going to try and answer all three of you here.  Sorry for the delayed response.

ipconfig/all - The server is referencing the DG as its DNS server.  That being said, it would be referencing an ISP indirectly for DNS.  Clients, I have been told, are definitely referencing ISP DNS.

nslookup - returns same basic information

dnslint - going to hold on this for the time being

Chris-Dent

I was thinking the same thing may be happening - possibly pulling from cached DNS to keep AD running?  

The clients would have to be authenticating against AD in order to still access the files on the DC yes?

Regarding your directions.  Sounds straightforward, however I am unfamiliar with this type of situation so would like to clarify a couple of points -

First, these directions will install DNS and then link it back to AD after it is up and in a stable state (i.e. created as a primary DNS server, forward lookup zone to AD is established, etc.)?

Second, what is the likelihood that AD and therefore the server itself will crash during this procedure?

Third, in the event of a crash, is it possible to rebuild the box, re-install DNS and configure and then overlay or restore AD to the box?

Americom -
DNS isn't running on the box at all.  Only service registered anywhere on the machine as DNS is the DNS Client service itself.

Thanks for the input so far guys.

> I was thinking the same thing may be happening - possibly pulling from cached DNS to keep AD running?  

Only works if there's a server answering authoritatively for the zone which doesn't appear to be the case :)

> The clients would have to be authenticating against AD in order to still access the files on the DC yes?

Yes, using NTLM and server level authentication rather than Kerberos and domain level authentication.

> First, these directions will install DNS and then link it back to AD after it is up and in a stable state
> (i.e. created as a primary DNS server, forward lookup zone to AD is established, etc.)?

Yes, although the instructions have you test and verify a number of times to verify it is behaving after each major step.

> Second, what is the likelihood that AD and therefore the server itself will crash during this procedure?

In my opinion, none at all. We're not doing anything remotely destructive, only adding in missing services.

> Third, in the event of a crash, is it possible to rebuild the box, re-install DNS and configure
> and then overlay or restore AD to the box?

You need a backup of the System State. That will include DNS in it's current state (including service state). The best we could do is drop back to that in the event of total failure. I do advise you take a backup regardless of my opinion on the risk level above. Better safe than sorry and all that :)

Chris
Chris

Thanks for the reply.  We've already got a backup, just wanted to verify those points prior to trying.

Wish us luck.

Cheers

J
Cheers and thanks again for the input.

Good luck :) You know where we are if it doesn't play the game :)

Chris