Not sure how to resolve error: ""Collection was modified; enumeration operation may not execute."

Hi

As mentioned above, I get the error:
"Collection was modified; enumeration operation may not execute."

The code that is causing this is below.

I checked up on previous thread with the same issue and understand that it is when you do a foreach loop through a collection, and then try to modify the contents of that collection within the loop.

But in my code, as seen below, nothing is modifying the messageOutDictionary Collection.
The only bit of code that touches it is:
Regex MyRE = new Regex(messageOutDictionary[tKeyInDictionary]);

This is not modifying the collection as far as I know, so what could be causing the issue??

Thanks
Paolo
private String SetMessageOut(String template, Dictionary<String, String> messageOutDictionary)
		{
			String message_OUT = template;
			String tSearchValue;
			String tKeyInDictionary;
			String tKeyNew;
			String[] tSearchDuplicateKeyName = new String[1];
						
			foreach (String key in messageOutDictionary.Keys)
			{
				tKeyInDictionary = key;
				tKeyNew = key;
				
				//Handle Duplicates
				tSearchDuplicateKeyName = key.ToString().Split('|');
				if (tSearchDuplicateKeyName.Length > 1)
				{
					tKeyNew = tSearchDuplicateKeyName[0];
				}
 
				//Value to Replace
				tSearchValue = "{" + tKeyNew.ToString() + "}";
				
				//Replacement
				Regex MyRE = new Regex(messageOutDictionary[tKeyInDictionary]);
				string res = MyRE.Replace(message_OUT, tKeyNew, 1);
			}
 
			return message_OUT;
		}

Open in new window

djcheekyAsked:
Who is Participating?
 
p_davisConnect With a Mentor Commented:
you can't modify records in a foreach loop -- you will have to do something like a regular for loop
0
 
djcheekyAuthor Commented:
A regular for loop is not possible as the keys aren't sequential. They are text keys.
0
 
djcheekyAuthor Commented:
Plus, there are no "records" so to speak. It's just norma lvalues.
0
Cloud Class® Course: Microsoft Azure 2017

Azure has a changed a lot since it was originally introduce by adding new services and features. Do you know everything you need to about Azure? This course will teach you about the Azure App Service, monitoring and application insights, DevOps, and Team Services.

 
p_davisCommented:
why does it matter if they are sequential -- if they aren't, they wouldn't be in a foreach loop either -

what are you trying to do. -- it looks like you are trying to replace key values -- the comment says handle duplicates but duplicate keys aren't allowed in dictionaries, so i am a little confused.
0
 
djcheekyAuthor Commented:
Hi,

No - it's not duplicates in the Dictionary, don't worry about that code.
The issue remains that I get the error? You can see that the dictionary data (be it values or keys) isn't modified.

Thanks

0
 
p_davisCommented:
sorry about that i didn't read you question closely enough -- specifically, what line does it error out on?
0
 
djcheekyAuthor Commented:
foreach (String keyOUT in DictionaryOUT.Keys)

0
 
p_davisCommented:
what about trying
foreach(KeyValuePair<String,String> pair in DictionaryOUt)
{

}
0
 
Fernando SotoRetiredCommented:
Hi djcheeky;

I looked at the code and could not see why you are getting the error. I then tested your code and it ran without issue. Can you give some test data for the collection  messageOutDictionary so that I can test with like data as you.

Fernando
0
 
Anurag ThakurTechnical ManagerCommented:
tried your code and it compiles and runs perfectly
the collection is not modified at all.
can you please provide us with some test data as requested by Fernando too, it migt be helpful to us to try to debug and find the solution to the exception thats coming
0
 
djcheekyAuthor Commented:
Hi all and thanks for the response.

>>Fernando / Ragi

You are both in fact correct. After actually trapping the error down further it seems that error is happening with the code below.

This in fact DOES modify records in a Dictionary, so I will attempt to work around this, change the code, and see what happens and get back to you.

Thanks
private Dictionary<String, String> SetMessageOutDictionaryValues(Dictionary<String, String> DictionaryIN, Dictionary<String, String> DictionaryOUT)
		{
			foreach (String keyOUT in DictionaryOUT.Keys)
			{
				if (DictionaryIN.ContainsKey(keyOUT))
				{
					DictionaryOUT[keyOUT] = DictionaryIN[keyOUT];
				}
				else
				{
					DictionaryOUT[keyOUT] = "";
				}
			}
			return DictionaryOUT;
		}

Open in new window

0
 
djcheekyAuthor Commented:
Hmmm.... OK, now I'm a bit stumped.

I have modified the method so that the Dictionary Collection in the "foreach" loop is not modified, yet I still get the error. The code is attached below.

As you can see - I am looping through the DictionaryOUT dictionary, but modifying the messageOutDictionaryValues dictionary, yet still get the error??

The Data in the Dictionary I am using is (and please note that the value null illustrated is actually a String, not the null operator):

[MessageReferenceNumber][null]
[MessageType][null]
[MessageVersionNumber][null]
[MessageReleaseNumber][null]
[ControllingAgency][null]
[AssociationAssignedCode][null]
[DocumentMessageName][null]
[DocumentMessageId][null]
[DateTimePeriodQualifier][null]
[DateTimePeriod][null]
[DateTimePeriodFormatQualifier][null]
[PlaceLocationQualifier][null]
[PlaceLocationIdentification][null]
[CodeListQualifier][null]
[CodeListResponsibleAgency][null]
[ProcessingIndicator][null]
[CodeListQualifier_1][null]
[CodeListResponsibleAgency_1][null]
[PartyQualifier][null]
[PartyIdentificationDetails][null]
[DateTimePeriodQualifier_1][null]
[DateTimePeriod_1][null]
[DateTimePeriodFormatQualifier_1][null]

Thanks
Paolo
private Dictionary<String, String> SetMessageOutDictionaryValues(Dictionary<String, String> DictionaryIN, Dictionary<String, String> DictionaryOUT)
		{
			Dictionary<String, String> messageOutDictionaryValues = new Dictionary<String, String>();
			messageOutDictionaryValues = DictionaryOUT;
 
			foreach (String keyOUT in DictionaryOUT.Keys)
			{
				if (DictionaryIN.ContainsKey(keyOUT))
				{
					messageOutDictionaryValues[keyOUT] = DictionaryIN[keyOUT];
				}
				else
				{
					messageOutDictionaryValues[keyOUT] = "";
				}
			}
			return messageOutDictionaryValues;
		}

Open in new window

0
 
Anurag ThakurConnect With a Mentor Technical ManagerCommented:
if the requirement is to modify the key value in the dictionary then use a for loop instead of the for each loop.
if you need to remove objects from the dictionary then do the reverse loop (loop from top (count) to bottom (0))
0
 
djcheekyAuthor Commented:
Hi - Ok, I managed to find a way to get around it, using a normal for loop.

What was required for this example to work though was also creating an array of the keys, which I could then reference using the for loops index.

Thanks

private Dictionary<String, String> SetMessageOutDictionaryValues(Dictionary<String, String> DictionaryIN, Dictionary<String, String> DictionaryOUT)
		{
			String[] tKeyValues = new String[DictionaryOUT.Keys.Count];
			int j = 0;
			foreach (String keyOUT in DictionaryOUT.Keys)
			{
				tKeyValues[j] = keyOUT;
				j++;
			}
			for (int i = 0; i < tKeyValues.Length; i++)
			{
				if (DictionaryIN.ContainsKey(tKeyValues[i]))
				{
					DictionaryOUT[tKeyValues[i]] = DictionaryIN[tKeyValues[i]];
				}
				else
				{
					DictionaryOUT[tKeyValues[i]] = "no match";
				}
			}
			/*
			foreach (String keyOUT in DictionaryOUT.Keys)
			{
				if (DictionaryIN.ContainsKey(keyOUT))
				{
					DictionaryOUT[keyOUT] = DictionaryIN[keyOUT];
				}
				else
				{
					DictionaryOUT[keyOUT] = "";
				}
			}
			 */ 
			return DictionaryOUT;
		}

Open in new window

0
 
p_davisCommented:
The first comment i made suggested using a regular for loop.
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.