Link to home
Start Free TrialLog in
Avatar of rmmarsh
rmmarshFlag for United States of America

asked on

Why does Thunderbird download attachments multiple times?

Can someone please tell me why Thunderbird downloads attachments each time I click on a message with them?  Seems to me it should recognize it has already downloaded the attachments and not do it over and over again (really a waste of time with large attachments).

Is there a way to control this (read "fix")?
Avatar of Tolomir
Tolomir
Flag of Germany image

Seems to me like you have some kind of download manager installed checking each each text for links.

Can you confirm this? Thunderbird will never offer an automatic download by itself.

Tolomir
Avatar of rmmarsh

ASKER

No, I don't have any download manager that I am aware of...  what's happening is:  I get an email with attachments, some quite large.  I have Thunderbird set to download anything under 50K; unless I indicate "save", the next time I look at that message, the attachments are downloaded again.  Is there some way to have Thunderbird download and save attachments for messages I click on?
Avatar of rmmarsh

ASKER

Oh... one more thing... when I say "save all", it downloads the attachments all over again!  What a friggen waste of time!
Avatar of rmmarsh

ASKER

Anybody?
rmmarsh,

Where is it downloading to?  Are they being saved in that location?
Have you tried changing Tools-Options-Attachments->Download folder to Ask Every time? There you could Cancel out and it shouldn't be downloaded.
Perhaps you need an Attachment Extractor like
https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/thunderbird/addon/556

Avatar of rmmarsh

ASKER

I tried the Attachment Extractor, but, still, everytime I click on the email, it starts to download the attachments again.

Is there some setting to prevent this?
Where is it downloading to?
Avatar of rmmarsh

ASKER

I dunno... when I save them, they go to a folder on the HD... I have no idea where they are temporarily saved when I open the email.
could you just for a test disable that 50k limit to download all messages.

and check if the problem still exists?
Avatar of rmmarsh

ASKER

It's already unchecked...
you could check with filemon from Microsoft where your emails go on your HD and which program is downloading your attachments.

http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/sysinternals/bb896642.aspx
ASKER CERTIFIED SOLUTION
Avatar of Marc Z
Marc Z
Flag of United States of America image

Link to home
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
Start Free Trial
Avatar of rmmarsh

ASKER

mtzlof4:  how can I tell?  because it takes forever to download these particular files...   Options say "save attachments to this folder", which only occurs when I click on "save"... prior to that, I have to wait for the files to download, then click "save" then have to wait for them to download again to the folder.  Seems to be a bug or poor design, in my opinion.
SOLUTION
Link to home
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
Start Free Trial
Avatar of rmmarsh

ASKER

Well, I don't know what the problem is now... on my machine at work it works as it should... I'll have to wait until I get home tonight to check it out there.

Thanks everybody for your assistance... will post the results.
rmmarsh,

What internet connection speeds do you have at home and at work?

How much memory installed in each machine? Or is it the same machine?

I also don't notice any issues with downloads, but I have never set mine to only download smaller then 50KB.  Everything comes at once, for me.
Avatar of rmmarsh

ASKER

The problem went away.. must have been the direction the wind was blowing that day... thanks to both of you for your help...