• Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 391
  • Last Modified:

DTD validation problems

I'm using the DTD editor which is integrated in Eclipse 3.4.1 and I stumbled over a DTD in our system which Eclipse doesn't accept (But which seems to work in the system where it is used). I'm not very familar with DTDs and now I wonder if there are really DTD problems (which are ignored for some reason when it is used on the production system) or if the validator in Eclipse is buggy. So can you please check a few lines. Please note: I'm trying to validate the DTD, not the XML files.

Problem 1:

<!ELEMENT parent (child1?, child2?, #PCDATA)>
<!ELEMENT child1 (#PCDATA)>
<!ELEMENT child2 (#PCDATA)>

It should allow an XML document like this:

<parent>
  <child1>data<child1>
  <child2>data<child2>
  Some text data
</parent>

Validator doesn't like the #PCDATA in the first line (Error message: A '(' character or an element type is required in the declaration of element type "parent".). So first question: Is this not allowed in a DTD? Or is this a false alarm in Eclipse? Or can I write this in a different way which may be accepted by Eclipse?


Problem 2:

<!ATTLIST mail contentType  (text/plain | text/html) "text/plain" >

This should allow a "mail" element with an optional contentType attribute which can have the values "text/plain" and "text/html". But Eclipse doesn't like the slash in the values (Error message: "The enumerated type list must end with ')' in the "contentType" attribute declaration."). Again: Is this not allowed in a DTD or is it an Eclipse bug? Or can I solve this in a different way which makes Eclipse happy and still works?
0
kayahr
Asked:
kayahr
  • 3
1 Solution
 
Geert BormansInformation ArchitectCommented:
I am afraid that eclipse is right

Problem 1:
To avoid ambiguity in mixed content elements, this is the only way that is allowed to define mixed content
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<!ELEMENT parent ( #PCDATA  | child1 | child2)*>
<!ELEMENT child1 (#PCDATA)>
<!ELEMENT child2 (#PCDATA)>
Note that this is more relaxed than what you originally had, but this is the only way

It would also allow
<parent>bla bla <child2/> blabla <child1/> bla bla <child2/> blabla ...
not exactly what you want,
but there is no other way
If you really need to use DTD and limit to your example you will have to add an extra validation layer, eg. using XSLT
0
 
Geert BormansInformation ArchitectCommented:
Problem 2
if you have an enumerated list of attribute values, there are limitations to the characters that are allowed (should be NMTOKEN I believe) A '/' is not an allowed character in such a list
If you really need that value, I suggest that you use XML Schema instead of DTD

I don't know which parser you have been using before, but it is obviously not a good one
0
 
kayahrAuthor Commented:
I digged a little bit deeper and found out that this DTD is not used at all. It's only "parsed" by humans... Oh I hate my job sometimes. I have renamed the file into a txt file and added a comment that someone may want to convert it into a XML schema and then start to really use it...

Thanks for the help. I'm happy that it's really a buggy DTD and not an Eclipse bug (Because I like to keep using Eclipse for validation).
0
 
Geert BormansInformation ArchitectCommented:
welcome
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

Join & Write a Comment

Featured Post

What Kind of Coding Program is Right for You?

There are many ways to learn to code these days. From coding bootcamps like Flatiron School to online courses to totally free beginner resources. The best way to learn to code depends on many factors, but the most important one is you. See what course is best for you.

  • 3
Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now