• Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 374
  • Last Modified:

Pop3 works but SMTP doesn't

I'm aware they're both different.

Where do i begin to check what the smtp settings are for the exchange server in my building?
I should add all incoming emails are scanned for viruses/spam by a third party before being released to our server.
0
Antonio King
Asked:
Antonio King
  • 10
  • 10
  • +1
1 Solution
 
DizzybroCommented:
Whos your ISP?
0
 
Antonio KingIT ManagerAuthor Commented:
Company called Vodat provide our leased line.
0
 
aleghartCommented:
Are you talking about SMTP outbound or SMTP inbound to you?
Also, are you the mail server admin, or the end user?
What, exactly, is not working?
0
What does it mean to be "Always On"?

Is your cloud always on? With an Always On cloud you won't have to worry about downtime for maintenance or software application code updates, ensuring that your bottom line isn't affected.

 
Antonio KingIT ManagerAuthor Commented:
Sorry I havn't really provided much information.

I am the mail server administrator, although not highly experienced.
I'm trying to setup access for people to connect to our exchange server from outside the office.

I.e from their home pc's.

Although i've successfully got webmail working, i'd like to add the option of a "permanent" connection using Outlook Express and the like by connecting to pop3 and smtp.

pop3 (incoming emails) works, but smtp just won't connect, and to start off with, i'm not sure what the smtp address to use would be?
0
 
Antonio KingIT ManagerAuthor Commented:
I've tried the same address for the pop3 section in the smtp section of Windows Mail.

I receive this message when doing send and receive
The connection to the server has failed. Subject 'Read: Maintenance Call Update', Account: *************, Server: 'mail.************', Protocol: SMTP, Port: 25, Secure(SSL): No, Socket Error: 10061, Error Number: 0x800CCC0E

I've also tried smtp.************ with the same response as above.
0
 
JamesonJendreasCommented:
One issue I have found is that often times an ISP will block traffic on port 25 - the port that SMTP uses to send emails.  This is done to reduce the chance of a user pushing spam through an ISP's system.  We solved this issue by deploying a quick PPTP VPN  (I use RAS on a Win 2k3 server) for outside users to connect to when sending emails.
0
 
Antonio KingIT ManagerAuthor Commented:
Please note the exchange server is in our building, we provide our own email system. I might be completely way off the mark here, but our emails have nothing to do with our ISP.
0
 
JamesonJendreasCommented:
PS - I am referring to the ISP of the HOME user - we ALWAYS have this issue with the AT&T networks (bellsouth, att, yahoo etc) among others.  If you do use SSL, it will not use port 25, but the ISP may also block the ssl port (587 I think is the SSL or maybe that's TLS)
0
 
JamesonJendreasCommented:
"Please note the exchange server is in our building, we provide our own email system. I might be completely way off the mark here, but our emails have nothing to do with our ISP."

As mentioned above, it would be the HOME users ISP that would block an SMTP send, if they connect via a VPN to your office before sending an email, then the email will first go through the VPN to your office ISP, which I assume does not block SMTP.

From Wikipedia:

"Port 25 blocking

Firewalls and routers can be programmed to not allow SMTP traffic (TCP port 25) from machines that are not supposed to run Mail Transfer Agents or send e-mail.[4] This practice is somewhat controversial when ISPs block home users, especially if the ISPs do not allow the blocking to be turned off upon request. E-mail can still be sent from these computers to designated smart hosts via port 25 and to other smart hosts via the e-mail submission port 587."
0
 
Antonio KingIT ManagerAuthor Commented:
Ah I see!

Ok I've successfully connected my home pc via a vpn to my work network.

I've setup windows mail to point to the exchange server.
This is the error I received, once again receiving emails are fine but sending is not.

The message could not be sent. The authentication setting might not be correct for your outgoing e-mail [SMTP] server. For help solving this problem, go to Help, search for "Troubleshoot Windows Mail", and read the "I'm having problems sending e-mail" section. If you need help determining the proper server settings, please contact your e-mail service provider.

The rejected e-mail address was '*********@****.***'. Subject 'Read: Maintenance Call Update', Account: '************' Server: '***.***.***.***', Protocol: SMTP, Server Response: '550 5.7.1 Unable to relay for '*********@****.***', Port: 25, Secure(SSL): No, Server Error: 550, Error Number: 0x800CCC79
0
 
JamesonJendreasCommented:
Make sure you have "My SMTP server requires authentication" and tell it to use the POP login creds.  
0
 
Antonio KingIT ManagerAuthor Commented:
ok, that message above popped up because of an email sitting in the outbox. I deleted this and tried sending a test email to myself.

It appears to have sent but i havn't received it yet.
0
 
JamesonJendreasCommented:
also, if you continue to get the 550 5.7.1 error, this is regarding a relay issue

http://www.experts-exchange.com/Networking/Email_Groupware/Exchange_Server/Q_20799097.html 

0
 
Antonio KingIT ManagerAuthor Commented:
You've been very helpful JamesonJendreas.

Looks like connecting the machine through a vpn solves the problem, I've checked with my isp and port 25 is blocked.

Theroetically I could change the SMTP port on the exchange server and what I have setup here.

What implications would there be to this? Is it advisable?

Only reason I would like to do this is to make it easier for my colleagues to setup their emails, without having to create a vpn connection.
0
 
JamesonJendreasCommented:
This is something that I have though about myself, as the VPN is an extra step - In general there isn't any reason I can think of to not change the port - other than 25 is always selected by default, and that if you do choose another port, you'll have to make sure it is not used by any other service.
0
 
JamesonJendreasCommented:
and an MS KB on the issue

http://support.microsoft.com/kb/274842 
0
 
Antonio KingIT ManagerAuthor Commented:
Ok, thanks for your help!

I've tried changing the port to numerous different types but it's still not connecting.
Even after changing the port on the exchange server, leaving windows mail on my home pc as 25 and trying to connect using the vpn actually works. Which to me says i'm not changing the right setting.

However I followed the KB article you suggested.
Any suggestions?
0
 
JamesonJendreasCommented:
Do you have just one exchange server?  What version are you using?
0
 
Antonio KingIT ManagerAuthor Commented:
Oh now that is something I should've probably disclosed!

We have 3 exchange servers, all Exchange 2003.
0
 
JamesonJendreasCommented:
All three will need to be pointing to whatever port you choose.  Like I said I haven't actually tried to run SMTP on another port, so I'm not too sure.  On each server, I believe you'll need to do the following (although you may have already tried this)

Open System Manager
Go to "administrative groups"-->first administrative group-->servers--> 'servername'-->protocols-->SMTP-->Defualt Virtual SMTP server.  Right click on the Virtual SMTP server and click "properties".  Hit the "delivery" tab, then the "outgoing connections button.  Change the TCP port.  Repeat this for all servers in all admin groups.

Next in Outlook you'll need to specify the port for SMTP to use.

Hopefully that'll help, but if you tried that then there may need to be some more research to be done.
0
 
Antonio KingIT ManagerAuthor Commented:
Yea I had already tried that.

My other thoughts are either firewalls either end or outgoing emails are going out some other way.
As even with all the exchange servers smtp ports changed connecting via vpn and leaving the smtp setting as the default I can still send emails fine!

I've accepted your solution to my original question, Thanks for your help on that JamesonJandreas!
0

Featured Post

Concerto's Cloud Advisory Services

Want to avoid the missteps to gaining all the benefits of the cloud? Learn more about the different assessment options from our Cloud Advisory team.

  • 10
  • 10
  • +1
Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now