Solved

Some MX or DNS issue - we cannot send or receive mail to/from schools.nyc.gov

Posted on 2008-10-22
4
3,537 Views
Last Modified: 2013-11-10
We have a major client schools.nyc.gov and all of the sudden we cannot send or receive email with them.  It started this weekend and I received reports from my users on my domain saying that email TO schools.nyc.gov were bouncing.  (I am new here and still figuring out the systems)

I thought that this problem was our FirstClass email server so I called tech support and he told me that the log below shows that it's on the schools.nyc.gov side.

Anyway please read the rest but I need some clue as to where to look and what to do.   I have called the schools.nyc.gov helpdesk and they brushed me off.  They finally put in a ticket but I feel like they aren't taking it seriously and they think it's on my side.  I'm not even sure at this point.

I investigated this and got this log out of our POS mail server FirstClass:

[2008/10/21 08:07:18] SMTPMsg-34: Processing message 10/475
[2008/10/21 08:07:19] SMTPMsg-34: Relay smtp1.nycenet.edu (0xa59b6865) serves domain schools.nyc.gov
[2008/10/21 08:07:19] SMTPMsg-34: Delivering message to schools.nyc.gov (0xa59b6865)
[2008/10/21 08:07:35] SMTPMsg-34: Rcv: 220 op0iron01.schools.nyc.gov ESMTP
[2008/10/21 08:07:35] SMTPMsg-34: Snd: EHLO mbeabbs.mathsolutions.com
[2008/10/21 08:07:35] SMTPMsg-34: Rcv: 250-op0iron01.schools.nyc.gov
[2008/10/21 08:07:35] SMTPMsg-34: Rcv: 250-8BITMIME
[2008/10/21 08:07:35] SMTPMsg-34: Rcv: 250 SIZE 10485760
[2008/10/21 08:07:35] SMTPMsg-34: Snd: MAIL FROM:<[ mailto:cchambers@mathsolutions.com ]cchambers@mathsolutions.com> SIZE=3070
[2008/10/21 08:07:50] SMTPMsg-34: Rcv: 451 #4.1.8 Domain of sender address <[ mailto:cchambers@mathsolutions.com ]cchambers@mathsolutions.com> does not resolve
[2008/10/21 08:07:50] SMTPMsg-34: Snd: QUIT
[2008/10/21 08:07:50] SMTPMsg-34: Looking for additional mail exchangers
[2008/10/21 08:07:50] SMTPMsg-34: Found relay smtpout.nycenet.edu (0xa59b69fe) for domain schools.nyc.gov
[2008/10/21 08:07:50] SMTPMsg-34: Delivering message to schools.nyc.gov (0xa59b69fe)
[2008/10/21 08:08:06] SMTPMsg-34: Rcv: 220 op0iron02.schools.nyc.gov ESMTP
[2008/10/21 08:08:06] SMTPMsg-34: Snd: EHLO mbeabbs.mathsolutions.com
[2008/10/21 08:08:06] SMTPMsg-34: Rcv: 250-op0iron02.schools.nyc.gov
[2008/10/21 08:08:06] SMTPMsg-34: Rcv: 250-8BITMIME
[2008/10/21 08:08:06] SMTPMsg-34: Rcv: 250 SIZE 10485760
[2008/10/21 08:08:06] SMTPMsg-34: Snd: MAIL FROM:<[ mailto:cchambers@mathsolutions.com ]cchambers@mathsolutions.com> SIZE=3070
[2008/10/21 08:08:21] SMTPMsg-34: Rcv: 451 #4.1.8 Domain of sender address <[ mailto:cchambers@mathsolutions.com ]cchambers@mathsolutions.com> does not resolve
[2008/10/21 08:08:21] SMTPMsg-34: Snd: QUIT
[2008/10/21 08:08:21] SMTPMsg-34: Looking for additional mail exchangers
[2008/10/21 08:08:21] SMTPMsg-34: No additional mail exchangers found, delaying recipients
[2008/10/21 08:08:21] SMTPMsg-34: Delaying recipient "JHugule@schools.nyc.gov"
[2008/10/21 08:08:21] SMTPMsg-34: Updating message history Who="JHugule@schools.nyc.gov" When=-987545995 What=22
[2008/10/21 08:08:21] SMTPMsg-34: Done processing message

So it looks like to me that they are looking up our domain and saying it's not resolving correctly.

I then looked up our MX records and they are correct :

0      mbeabbs.mathsolutions.com      216.31.244.162            
15      groups.mathsolutions.com      216.31.244.162                  
20      caseyjones.dundee.net      216.234.106.37                  
30      caseyjones.dundee.net      216.234.106.37            
40      mail.mathsolutions.com      64.151.115.12      

Our mail comes into Spamassassin then Postfix and then into FirstClass.  

Then the plot thickens because I get a call from a user on the schools.nyc.gov network and they are trying to send us email and it's bouncing as well.  I asked her to forward me the bounce messages and this is what she is getting:

From:   System Administrator
Sent:   Tuesday, October 21, 2008 8:37 PM
To:     nrizzo@mathsolutions.com
Subject:        Undeliverable: Summer Geometry course

Your message did not reach some or all of the intended recipients.

      Subject:  Summer Geometry course
      Sent:     10/19/2008 8:07 PM

The following recipient(s) could not be reached:

      nrizzo@mathsolutions.com on 10/21/2008 8:37 PM
            The e-mail system was unable to deliver the message, but did not report a specific reason.  Check the address and try again.  If it still fails, contact your system administrator.

            < schools.nyc.gov #5.0.0 smtp; 5.4.7 - Delivery expired (message too old) 'DNS Soft Error looking up mathsolutions.com (MX) while asking recursive_nameserver0.parent. Error was: unable to reach nameserver on any valid IP' (delivery attempts: 0)>
0
Comment
Question by:norcalty
  • 2
  • 2
4 Comments
 
LVL 31

Expert Comment

by:rid
ID: 22778807
MX records may be OK, but does rDNS work for "mathsolutions.com "?

The second part of your post seems to indicate a general DNS problem with mathsolutions.com; does mail from other parties go OK in both directions?
/RID
0
 
LVL 4

Author Comment

by:norcalty
ID: 22779044
I can send and receive email from my gmail account to mathsolutions.com so it seems like it works.
0
 
LVL 31

Accepted Solution

by:
rid earned 500 total points
ID: 22779070
OK, so schools.nyc.gov fails in doing rDNS lookups for incoming and in resolving mathsolutions.com for outgoing messages. How is DNS handled for schools.nyc.gov?
/RID
0
 
LVL 4

Author Comment

by:norcalty
ID: 22781657
It ended up being that for some reason the nyc.gov system is blocking a huge portion of the internet on the West Coast.
0

Featured Post

Free Tool: IP Lookup

Get more info about an IP address or domain name, such as organization, abuse contacts and geolocation.

One of a set of tools we are providing to everyone as a way of saying thank you for being a part of the community.

Question has a verified solution.

If you are experiencing a similar issue, please ask a related question

Suggested Solutions

Title # Comments Views Activity
check if a sub domain uses a CNAME or A RECORD? 1 50
Exchange 2016 DAG Witness Server 3 44
Powershell command 2 37
Delayed Email Deliveries 5 22
Automapping, a wonderful feature with Exchange 2010 (SP2 onwards I believe), allows additional/Shared mailboxes that a user has access to be automatically mapped on Outlook client, simplifying the process by adding them while Outlook launches. Ho…
As cyber crime continues to grow in both numbers and sophistication, a troubling trend of optimization has emerged over the last year.
Familiarize people with the process of utilizing SQL Server views from within Microsoft Access. Microsoft Access is a very powerful client/server development tool. One of the SQL Server objects that you can interact with from within Microsoft Access…
In this video we show how to create a Shared Mailbox in Exchange 2013. We show this process by using the Exchange Admin Center. Log into Exchange Admin Center.: First we need to log into the Exchange Admin Center. Navigate to the Recipients >> Sha…

840 members asked questions and received personalized solutions in the past 7 days.

Join the community of 500,000 technology professionals and ask your questions.

Join & Ask a Question