Conflict between Windows Server 2003 SBS Folder Redirection, and roaming profiles

I have Server-A (Windows 2003 SBS, file and print server and Domain Controller for the network

With 28 workstations, A-1 to A-28. Each A-user has its own workstation, with local profile, with My Documents and Desktop redirected to the user share on the server through a GPO redirection. These users (Group-A) are set up as domain power users.

I then add 6 workstations, B-1 to B-6.

Similar setup, but for 10 B-Users, who have ROAMING profiles. Otherwise, same setup, My Documents and Desktop redirected to the user share on the server through a GPO redirection.

A-users don't have any problems, all is good.

B-users shows some unusual behavior: if User-B1 deletes a file from his account, the file disappears as it should. Then User-B1 logs off, logs back on, and the deleted file is back in his account! This happens to all deleted files.


     It turns out, when B-user James logs in, his profile (including documents and desktop) are copied locally.
     Then when James deletes my_doc_1.doc from what he sees as "My documents", he actually deletes
 \\ServerA\UserFiles\James\My Documents\my_doc_1.doc
     And then when James logs off, his local copy of the profile is copied back to the server, INCLUDING my_doc_1.doc. Thus, when he logs back on, he sees the file back in place - he is never able to delete files!
     Very frustrating!


     I was told to to move folder redirections to a location outside of the roaming profile. So I took the folder redirection GPO (which points to "\\ServerA\UserFiles\%username%\"), and I changed the scope from "Domain users" to "A-group".
     Then I created another redirection GPO, applied it to "B-group" only, and set the redirection to "\\ServerA\UserFiles-B\%username%\".


     Did gpupdate /force, restarts, multiple logon / logoff, cycles. To no avail. Every time I login as James, I still get sent to  \\ServerA\UserFiles\James\My Documents\ (the old redirection folder).
     
     When I tried rsop.msc, it even told me that the redirection policy is
my documents > \\ServerA\UserFiles\James\My Documents.
     But it didn't  tell me which GPO was causing that (GPO = '           ')

     How can I change this mapping?

RoninoAsked:
Who is Participating?
 
Henrik JohanssonConnect With a Mentor Systems engineerCommented:
Sounds like the issue that when using folder redirection to move data and original folder contains files, folder redirection policy will fail/rollback if target folder/share doesn't have correct permissions.
User shall have full control on both share and NTFS.

http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/cc775853.aspx
0
 
RoninoAuthor Commented:
This question was posted in conjunction with

http://www.experts-exchange.com/OS/Microsoft_Operating_Systems/Server/2003_Server/Q_23807085.html

Thank you for your help, henjoh09, it was a permissions problem indeed.

It also turns out the redirection GPO takes quite a while (hours) to propagate, despite several system reboots and gpudate / force
0
 
RoninoAuthor Commented:
Thank you - that was it.
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.