MySQL Query problem on join

I have a simple query running against MySQL through PHP.  I want to insert into a table all values that are in another table but not in that table.  This is the query I have:

INSERT Into DataNew (CollectorCode,CollectGross)
SELECT DISTINCT DataHistory.CollectorCode, 0
FROM DataHistory
LEFT OUTER JOIN DataNew ON DataNew.CollectorCode = DataHistory.CollectorCode
WHERE DataHistory.CodeType =1
AND DataHistory.CollectorCode NOT LIKE '%-b'
AND DataNew.CollectorCode IS NULL

The trouble is that the select query returns 602 rows whether I fileter by the DataNew.CollectorCode is Null or not.  How can I go about insertings into DataNew all Collectorcodes from DataHistory which are not already present?
LVL 10
GeoffSuttonAsked:
Who is Participating?
 
pivarConnect With a Mentor Commented:
Just so I understand, CollectorCode is unique?

Can you show us the tabledefinition and some sampledata?

If you would like to trim the CollectorCode try

SELECT DISTINCT dh.CollectorCode, 0
FROM DataHistory dh
WHERE NOT EXISTS (SELECT 1 FROM DataNew dn WHERE TRIM(dn.CollectorCode)=TRIM(dh.CollectorCode)) AND
dh.CodeType=1
0
 
pivarCommented:
Hi,

I would do like this (if CollectorCode is unique)

INSERT Into DataNew (CollectorCode,CollectGross)
SELECT DISTINCT dh.CollectorCode, 0
FROM DataHistory dh
WHERE NOT EXISTS (SELECT 1 FROM DataNew dn WHERE dn.CollectorCode = dh.CollectorCode)

/peter
0
 
GeoffSuttonAuthor Commented:
Unfortunately that does not work.  You query:
SELECT DISTINCT dh.CollectorCode, 0
FROM DataHistory dh
WHERE NOT EXISTS (SELECT 1 FROM DataNew dn WHERE dn.CollectorCode = dh.CollectorCode) AND
dh.CodeType=1
Returns the exact same results as
SELECT DISTINCT dh.CollectorCode, 0
FROM DataHistory dh
WHERE dh.CodeType=1

 They both show 602 rows, and datanew has 149 distinct codes entered.  I was reasonably sure that the SQL and the logic were good.  But being unfamiliar with MySQL I am wondering if the comparisons pay attention to potential trailing spaces and hidden characters?  I know that the collation is case insensitive.
Thanks for the quick response.  Hopefully we can resolve this right away.
Geoff
 
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.