Solved

Does NAT break IPSec?

Posted on 2009-04-08
3
391 Views
Last Modified: 2012-05-06
I am trying to find a way to securely handle Microsoft Active Directory replication as well as other Microsoft networking traffic between 2 Windows Server 2003 systems.  Ordinarily I would set up a site to site VPN using SonicWall or NetGear devices.  However, I can't in this situation because one of my servers is a virtual server that is hosted at Triple8 networks.  Thus, I have no way of deploying my own hardware based VPN.

I thought the best way to do this would be to set up IPSec Rules and Security Associations to handle all traffic between the 2 systems.  When the policies and rules are disabled, I can successfully ping back and forth between the 2 systems which tells me that I have successfully set up the firewall rules on the side that I can control.

When I enable the policies and launch ping from the command prompt, I just see the message NEGOTIATING SECURITY over and over.  When I examine the logs on both sides, I see several 541, 542, and 543 messages indicating successful starting and ending of security associations.  I have actually tried numerous systems including Windows XP with different firewalls and networks and observed similar results.

The only system with its own direct public ip address is my virtual server at Triple 8.  The other systems that I have tried are all behind firewalls and are NAT'd.

Any thoughts as to why I cannot get this to actually work? Is there a better way to accomplish my goal?

Thank you,

Angela
0
Comment
Question by:amozart
3 Comments
 
LVL 4

Accepted Solution

by:
dj_relentless earned 125 total points
ID: 24104530
It can work from behind nat but not all nat's are equal. I've seen to work and not work depending on the hardware.
So in your situation you could put a test server on the dmz of your network and test it. Then at least you will know which side is causing the problem.
0
 
LVL 4

Assisted Solution

by:StefanKittel
StefanKittel earned 125 total points
ID: 24104630
Hello,

in general NAT modifies the destination and/or source of the packet so IPSec throws the packet away because it is modified.
Many NAT-router have a IPSEC-passthrough. But not all and not for all situations.

Because you can't remove or modify the NAT-Router your possibilites are limited.

May be you can use a different vpn software to connect. maybe openvpn.

Stefan
0

Featured Post

Best Practices: Disaster Recovery Testing

Besides backup, any IT division should have a disaster recovery plan. You will find a few tips below relating to the development of such a plan and to what issues one should pay special attention in the course of backup planning.

Question has a verified solution.

If you are experiencing a similar issue, please ask a related question

Can I legally transfer my OEM version of Windows to another PC?  (AKA - Can I put a new systemboard in my OEM PC?) Few of us are both IT and legal experts but we all have our own views of Microsoft's licensing rules and how they apply.  There are…
Today, still in the boom of Apple, PC's and products, nearly 50% of the computer users use Windows as graphical operating systems. If you are among those users who love windows, but are grappling to keep the system's hard drive optimized, then you s…
Windows 10 is mostly good. However the one thing that annoys me is how many clicks you have to do to dial a VPN connection. You have to go to settings from the start menu, (2 clicks), Network and Internet (1 click), Click VPN (another click) then fi…
In this video I am going to show you how to back up and restore Office 365 mailboxes using CodeTwo Backup for Office 365. Learn more about the tool used in this video here: http://www.codetwo.com/backup-for-office-365/ (http://www.codetwo.com/ba…

864 members asked questions and received personalized solutions in the past 7 days.

Join the community of 500,000 technology professionals and ask your questions.

Join & Ask a Question

Need Help in Real-Time?

Connect with top rated Experts

19 Experts available now in Live!

Get 1:1 Help Now