Network Problems

I have a customer who is unabe to ping an IP address thru VPN tunnel  The VPN tunnel is up and running and shows traffic flowing between the two sites.  I have captured some packets with tcpdump on the internal interface of the FW.  I notice that there are arp reply error messages.  Does this seem to be a Layer 2 issue?

tcpdump: listening on eth1
10:49:14.330460 arcagent-adams > icmp: arcagent-adams udp port syslog unreachable [tos 0xc0]
10:49:15.339944 arp reply is-at 0:c:76:1b:b8:20
10:49:19.630313 arp reply is-at 0:1b:d3:18:98:be
10:49:20.137804 arp who-has tell
10:49:20.739895 arp reply is-at 0:11:25:e8:6f:d9
10:49:25.170102 arp reply is-at 0:d:56:f2:a4:14
10:49:26.580106 arp reply is-at 0:d:61:5e:a2:5f
10:49:29.142056 arp who-has tell
10:49:29.143180 arp who-has tell
10:49:32.140139 arp reply is-at 0:8:54:3:a3:1d
10:49:35.330048 arp reply is-at 0:d:61:80:1a:7b
10:49:37.590327 arp reply is-at 0:11:11:99:c4:64
10:49:39.580428 arp reply is-at 0:1d:92:bc:7:be
10:49:39.780125 arp reply is-at 0:c:f1:86:e5:2f
10:49:41.142391 arp who-has tell
10:49:41.145515 arp who-has tell
10:49:42.920047 arp reply is-at 0:c:f1:b6:cd:97

17 packets received by filter
0 packets dropped by kernel
Who is Participating?
From what I see you are actually saying that is not an issue in a single machine but multiple machines.  If this is the case, we already know it's not hardware because you can actually connect to the VPN.  It's not routing because those machines with the problem are able to connect to other services on the server.  If all machines are on the same network and some of then can ping the server I would suggest checking your firewall rules just in case you are not blocking ping for some machines, sometimes a lot of changes have been done on the FW and one forgets to remove things like that which drive you crazy later on.

If that is not the case, it sounds to me that you have some other FW blocking ping.  Check the server and make sure it does not has a FW and if it does disable it and test.  If the server is OK you may want to disable the FW on the machine just to test it; I really don't think the FW on the machine will do a different because the ping request is originated from that machine.

Just in case, to enable ping on your firewall you must allow this:


This allows only the required status messages to traverse the FW, others may be malicious:

Check this info for the ASA/PIX CISCO FW:
It certainly due to a route problem. Could you tell me more about the entiere ip configurations
hotrod_952Author Commented:
Customer mention they can access the internet but can't access a particular server through the VPN tunnel.  Other machines within the network can access the server thru VPN tunnel.  Rules are setup to allow all subnet access thru VPN tunnel.  I notice the machines that show "arp-whois" are the machines that having the issue.  I can ping the machines except from the FW.  Should I add a route on the machine or FW?
Increase Security & Decrease Risk with NSPM Tools

Analyst firm, Enterprise Management Associates (EMA) reveals significant benefits to enterprises when using Network Security Policy Management (NSPM) solutions, while organizations without, experienced issues including non standard security policies and failed cloud migrations

what is and did you mean arp who-has?

It looks like you may have some arp caching issues either on a router / firewall or other intermediate device, or on the local host.

machine a - can ping IP address of remote server
machine b - cannot ping IP address of remote server
machine b - is on the same subnet as machine a
machine b - has unique but same ip configuration for local network interface

is this a fair characterization of your problem?  

I am going to be out of pocket for a few hours, hopefully louis can help you but if not I will look at it when I return.

Can the particular server ping the client thru vpn ?

have you tried the tracert or traceroute command from this particular server to vpn client ?
hotrod_952Author Commented:
Also, the customer mention that they are trying to download files from an internal site at a remote location thru their VPN tunnel.  All other VPN tunnel traffic is working great.  I ran the tcpdump from the internal interface of the FW.  This is where I see the arp-who is messages.  Whenever I ran the tcpdump on the external interface of FW there where no arp-who is messages.  Any suggestions are needed.
hotrod_952Author Commented:
This happen to be a DNS-related issue.  The DNS server needed an entry added.
hotrod_952Author Commented:
DNS issue
HR... glad you got it worked out... internal DNS?  

hotrod_952Author Commented:
hotrod_952Author Commented:
DNS issue
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.