asked on

SQL Server Enterprise manager changing my query.

Good day

I have the following query that works perfectly in ASP and give me results:

SELECT COUNT(Tree.ChildUserID) AS Level1, Users_1.[Transaction Status] AS Status1, COUNT(Tree_1.ChildUserID) AS Level2, Users_2.[Transaction Status] AS Status2, COUNT(Tree_2.ChildUserID) AS Level3, Users_3.[Transaction Status] AS Status3, COUNT(Tree_3.ChildUserID) AS Level4, Users_4.[Transaction Status] AS Status4, COUNT(Tree_4.ChildUserID) AS Level5, Users_5.[Transaction Status] AS Status5, COUNT(Tree_5.ChildUserID) AS Level6, Users_6.[Transaction Status] AS Status6, COUNT(Tree_6.ChildUserID) AS Level7, Users_7.[Transaction Status] AS Status7 FROM Tree Tree_6 LEFT OUTER JOIN ProductSubscriptions ProductSubscriptions_7 ON Tree_6.ChildUserID = ProductSubscriptions_7.UserID LEFT OUTER JOIN Users Users_7 ON Tree_6.ChildUserID = Users_7.ID RIGHT OUTER JOIN Users Users_6 ON Tree_6.ParentUserID = Users_6.ID RIGHT OUTER JOIN Tree Tree_5 LEFT OUTER JOIN ProductSubscriptions ProductSubscriptions_6 ON Tree_5.ChildUserID = ProductSubscriptions_6.UserID ON Users_6.ID = Tree_5.ChildUserID RIGHT OUTER JOIN Users Users_5 ON Tree_5.ParentUserID = Users_5.ID RIGHT OUTER JOIN Tree Tree_4 LEFT OUTER JOIN ProductSubscriptions ProductSubscriptions_5 ON Tree_4.ChildUserID = ProductSubscriptions_5.UserID ON Users_5.ID = Tree_4.ChildUserID RIGHT OUTER JOIN Users Users_4 ON Tree_4.ParentUserID = Users_4.ID RIGHT OUTER JOIN Tree Tree_3 LEFT OUTER JOIN ProductSubscriptions ProductSubscriptions_4 ON Tree_3.ChildUserID = ProductSubscriptions_4.UserID ON Users_4.ID = Tree_3.ChildUserID RIGHT OUTER JOIN Users Users_3 ON Tree_3.ParentUserID = Users_3.ID RIGHT OUTER JOIN Tree Tree_2 RIGHT OUTER JOIN Users Users_2 ON Tree_2.ParentUserID = Users_2.ID LEFT OUTER JOIN ProductSubscriptions ProductSubscriptions_3 ON Tree_2.ChildUserID = ProductSubscriptions_3.UserID ON Users_3.ID = Tree_2.ChildUserID RIGHT OUTER JOIN Tree Tree_1 RIGHT OUTER JOIN Users Users_1 ON Tree_1.ParentUserID = Users_1.ID LEFT OUTER JOIN ProductSubscriptions ProductSubscriptions_2 ON Tree_1.ChildUserID = ProductSubscriptions_2.UserID ON Users_2.ID = Tree_1.ChildUserID RIGHT OUTER JOIN ProductSubscriptions INNER JOIN Users ON ProductSubscriptions.UserID = Users.ID INNER JOIN Tree ON Users.ID = Tree.ParentUserID LEFT OUTER JOIN ProductSubscriptions ProductSubscriptions_1 ON Tree.ChildUserID = ProductSubscriptions_1.UserID ON Users_1.ID = Tree.ChildUserID WHERE (ProductSubscriptions.ProductID = 1) AND (Users.Active = 1) AND (Users.ID = 47) AND (ProductSubscriptions_1.ProductID = 1 OR ProductSubscriptions_1.ProductID IS NULL) AND (Users_1.Active = 1) AND (ProductSubscriptions_2.ProductID = 1 OR ProductSubscriptions_2.ProductID IS NULL) AND (Users_2.Active = 1 OR Users_2.Active IS NULL) AND (ProductSubscriptions_3.ProductID = 1 OR ProductSubscriptions_3.ProductID IS NULL) AND (Users_3.Active = 1 OR Users_3.Active IS NULL) AND (ProductSubscriptions_4.ProductID = 1 OR ProductSubscriptions_4.ProductID IS NULL) AND (Users_4.Active = 1 OR Users_4.Active IS NULL) AND (ProductSubscriptions_5.ProductID = 1 OR ProductSubscriptions_5.ProductID IS NULL) AND (Users_5.Active = 1 OR Users_5.Active IS NULL) AND (ProductSubscriptions_6.ProductID = 1 OR ProductSubscriptions_6.ProductID IS NULL) AND (Users_6.Active = 1 OR Users_6.Active IS NULL) AND (ProductSubscriptions_7.ProductID = 1 OR ProductSubscriptions_7.ProductID IS NULL) AND (Users_7.Active = 1 OR Users_7.Active IS NULL) GROUP BY Users_1.[Transaction Status], Users_2.[Transaction Status], Users_3.[Transaction Status], Users_4.[Transaction Status], Users_5.[Transaction Status], Users_6.[Transaction Status], Users_7.[Transaction Status] HAVING (Users_1.[Transaction Status] <= 1 OR Users_1.[Transaction Status] IS NULL) AND (Users_2.[Transaction Status] <= 1 OR Users_2.[Transaction Status] IS NULL) AND (Users_3.[Transaction Status] <= 1 OR Users_3.[Transaction Status] IS NULL) AND (Users_4.[Transaction Status] <= 1 OR Users_4.[Transaction Status] IS NULL) AND (Users_5.[Transaction Status] <= 1 OR Users_5.[Transaction Status] IS NULL) AND (Users_6.[Transaction Status] <= 1 OR Users_6.[Transaction Status] IS NULL) AND (Users_7.[Transaction Status] <= 1 OR Users_7.[Transaction Status] IS NULL);

But when I copy and paste it into SQL Enterprise manager it changed something in the query and there are suddenly no records to return
This is the changed query:

SELECT COUNT(Tree_6.ChildUserID) AS Level1, Users_1.[Transaction Status] AS Status1, COUNT(Tree_1.ChildUserID) AS Level2,
Users_2.[Transaction Status] AS Status2, COUNT(Tree_2.ChildUserID) AS Level3, Users_3.[Transaction Status] AS Status3, COUNT(Tree_3.ChildUserID)
AS Level4, Users_4.[Transaction Status] AS Status4, COUNT(Tree_4.ChildUserID) AS Level5, Users_5.[Transaction Status] AS Status5,
COUNT(Tree_5.ChildUserID) AS Level6, Users_6.[Transaction Status] AS Status6, COUNT(Tree_6.ChildUserID) AS Level7,
Users_7.[Transaction Status] AS Status7
FROM Tree Tree_6 LEFT OUTER JOIN
ProductSubscriptions ProductSubscriptions_7 ON Tree_6.ChildUserID = ProductSubscriptions_7.UserID LEFT OUTER JOIN
Users Users_7 ON Tree_6.ChildUserID = Users_7.ID RIGHT OUTER JOIN
Users Users_6 ON Tree_6.ParentUserID = Users_6.ID RIGHT OUTER JOIN
Tree Tree_5 LEFT OUTER JOIN
ProductSubscriptions ProductSubscriptions_6 ON Tree_5.ChildUserID = ProductSubscriptions_6.UserID ON
Users_6.ID = Tree_5.ChildUserID RIGHT OUTER JOIN
Users Users_5 ON Tree_5.ParentUserID = Users_5.ID RIGHT OUTER JOIN
Tree Tree_4 LEFT OUTER JOIN
ProductSubscriptions ProductSubscriptions_5 ON Tree_4.ChildUserID = ProductSubscriptions_5.UserID ON
Users_5.ID = Tree_4.ChildUserID RIGHT OUTER JOIN
Users Users_4 ON Tree_4.ParentUserID = Users_4.ID RIGHT OUTER JOIN
Tree Tree_3 LEFT OUTER JOIN
ProductSubscriptions ProductSubscriptions_4 ON Tree_3.ChildUserID = ProductSubscriptions_4.UserID ON
Users_4.ID = Tree_3.ChildUserID RIGHT OUTER JOIN
Users Users_3 ON Tree_3.ParentUserID = Users_3.ID RIGHT OUTER JOIN
Tree Tree_2 RIGHT OUTER JOIN
Users Users_2 ON Tree_2.ParentUserID = Users_2.ID LEFT OUTER JOIN
ProductSubscriptions ProductSubscriptions_3 ON Tree_2.ChildUserID = ProductSubscriptions_3.UserID ON
Users_3.ID = Tree_2.ChildUserID RIGHT OUTER JOIN
Tree Tree_1 RIGHT OUTER JOIN
Users Users_1 ON Tree_1.ParentUserID = Users_1.ID LEFT OUTER JOIN
ProductSubscriptions ProductSubscriptions_2 ON Tree_1.ChildUserID = ProductSubscriptions_2.UserID ON
Users_2.ID = Tree_1.ChildUserID RIGHT OUTER JOIN
ProductSubscriptions ProductSubscriptions_8 INNER JOIN
Users Users_8 ON ProductSubscriptions_8.UserID = Users_8.ID INNER JOIN
Tree Tree_7 ON Users_8.ID = Tree_7.ParentUserID LEFT OUTER JOIN
ProductSubscriptions ProductSubscriptions_1 ON Tree_7.ChildUserID = ProductSubscriptions_1.UserID ON Users_1.ID = Tree_7.ChildUserID
WHERE (ProductSubscriptions_7.ProductID = 1) AND (Users_7.Active = 1) AND (Users_7.ID = 47) AND (ProductSubscriptions_1.ProductID = 1 OR
ProductSubscriptions_1.ProductID IS NULL) AND (Users_1.Active = 1) AND (ProductSubscriptions_2.ProductID = 1 OR
ProductSubscriptions_2.ProductID IS NULL) AND (Users_2.Active = 1 OR
Users_2.Active IS NULL) AND (ProductSubscriptions_3.ProductID = 1 OR
ProductSubscriptions_3.ProductID IS NULL) AND (Users_3.Active = 1 OR
Users_3.Active IS NULL) AND (ProductSubscriptions_4.ProductID = 1 OR
ProductSubscriptions_4.ProductID IS NULL) AND (Users_4.Active = 1 OR
Users_4.Active IS NULL) AND (ProductSubscriptions_5.ProductID = 1 OR
ProductSubscriptions_5.ProductID IS NULL) AND (Users_5.Active = 1 OR
Users_5.Active IS NULL) AND (ProductSubscriptions_6.ProductID = 1 OR
ProductSubscriptions_6.ProductID IS NULL) AND (Users_6.Active = 1 OR
Users_6.Active IS NULL) AND (ProductSubscriptions_7.ProductID = 1 OR
ProductSubscriptions_7.ProductID IS NULL) AND (Users_7.Active = 1 OR
Users_7.Active IS NULL)
GROUP BY Users_1.[Transaction Status], Users_2.[Transaction Status], Users_3.[Transaction Status], Users_4.[Transaction Status],
Users_5.[Transaction Status], Users_6.[Transaction Status], Users_7.[Transaction Status]
HAVING (Users_1.[Transaction Status] <= 1 OR
Users_1.[Transaction Status] IS NULL) AND (Users_2.[Transaction Status] <= 1 OR
Users_2.[Transaction Status] IS NULL) AND (Users_3.[Transaction Status] <= 1 OR
Users_3.[Transaction Status] IS NULL) AND (Users_4.[Transaction Status] <= 1 OR
Users_4.[Transaction Status] IS NULL) AND (Users_5.[Transaction Status] <= 1 OR
Users_5.[Transaction Status] IS NULL) AND (Users_6.[Transaction Status] <= 1 OR
Users_6.[Transaction Status] IS NULL) AND (Users_7.[Transaction Status] <= 1 OR
Users_7.[Transaction Status] IS NULL)

Any idea why this is happening?

James Murrell

does the new code work in Query Analyser?

As far as I know EM may add junk to your queries.

Personally i try to only use QA

it article may help http://databases.aspfaq.com/database/which-tool-should-i-use-enterprise-manager-or-query-analyzer.html

ASKER CERTIFIED SOLUTION

momi_sabag

membership

This solution is only available to members.

To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.

Start Free Trial

RiteshShah

well, EM may add some additional information in your T-SQL but not add something which make your code erroneous. You have to make sure that your query is working fine in Query Analyzer and not working in EM. than let us know both the query.

thiyaguk

Please run this query in Query analyser. EM might change the Query slightly....

koossa

ASKER

Yes, the top one is working in QA, but when I copy it to EM it change something.
When I copied the changed code to QA, it does not work either.

RiteshShah

can you post both version (EM and QA) of query here?

James Murrell

they are in question RiteshShah

koossa

ASKER

The query at the top is the QA one and the 2nd one is the EM one.

I have figure out what the problem is:
I have used some of the tables more than once where a underscore and number is put after the table. (table_1)
But my original table did not have an alias.
After changing the original table to table_0 it's working.

Thank you

RiteshShah

If you will observe part of your query

RIGHT OUTER JOIN Tree Tree_5

LEFT OUTER JOIN ProductSubscriptions ProductSubscriptions_6

ON Tree_5.ChildUserID = ProductSubscriptions_6.UserID

ON Users_6.ID = Tree_5.ChildUserID

there is no ON between RIght OUTER and Left OUTER join, instead, both ON comes after Right and Left outer. this kind of junk is happening which is haulting your query from run.