C# increment and decrement operators

I'm just starting to read a C# book.  I would like to find out why running a program gave me the results it did.

/* This is a program that I'm writing
   to see if I can figure out */

class TryThis
{

  public static void Main()
  {

    // postfix increment
    int length = 3;
    int newLength = length++;
    System.Console.WriteLine("Postfix increment example");
    System.Console.WriteLine("length = " + length);
    System.Console.WriteLine("newLength = " + newLength);

    // prefix increment
    length = 3;
    newLength = ++length;
    System.Console.WriteLine("Prefix increment example");
    System.Console.WriteLine("length = " + length);
    System.Console.WriteLine("newLength = " + newLength);

    // postfix decrement
    length = 3;
    newLength = length--;
    System.Console.WriteLine("Postfix decrement example");
    System.Console.WriteLine("length = " + length);
    System.Console.WriteLine("newLength = " + newLength);

    // prefix decrement
    length = 3;
    newLength = --length;
    System.Console.WriteLine("Prefix decrement example");
    System.Console.WriteLine("length = " + length);
    System.Console.WriteLine("newLength = " + newLength);

  }

}

This is the result:


C:\Documents and Settings>trythis
Postfix increment example
length = 4
newLength = 3
Prefix increment example
length = 4
newLength = 4
Postfix decrement example
length = 2
newLength = 3
Prefix decrement example
length = 2
newLength = 2

C:\Documents and Settings>

William RichardsonAsked:
Who is Participating?
 
käµfm³d 👽Commented:
Think of prefix notation like: I want to increase/decrease the current value before I use it.

Think of postfix notation like: I want to use the current value, then increase/decrease it
0
 
geowrianCommented:
Postfix can be rewritten like this:
int length = 3;
int newLength = length;
length = length + 1;

Prefix can be rewritten like this:
length = 3;
length = length + 1;
newLength = length;

basically, anywhere you see a prefixed ++, you can perform that operation on a new line above it. Anywhere you see a postfixed ++, you can perform that operation immediately after it.
0
 
käµfm³d 👽Commented:
Prefix notation (++variable/--variable) means that you increment a variable before you use it in the statement. Postfix notation (variable++/variable--) means that you use the variable, then you increment it.
int x = 1;
 
Console.WriteLine(++x);  // outputs 2 -- increment before use
Console.WriteLine(x++);  // outputs 2 -- use, then increment
Console.WriteLine(++x);  // outputs 3 -- increment before use
 
Console.WriteLine(x--);  // outputs 3 -- use, then decrement
Console.WriteLine(--x);  // outputs 1 -- decrement, then use

Open in new window

0
Free Tool: Path Explorer

An intuitive utility to help find the CSS path to UI elements on a webpage. These paths are used frequently in a variety of front-end development and QA automation tasks.

One of a set of tools we're offering as a way of saying thank you for being a part of the community.

 
tcullerCommented:
Post/pre-fix inc/decrement operators are one of the most common sources of confusion for new programmers. The difference is extremely minimal, but the results can be catastrophic. For example, if I say the following:

int someNum1 = 50;
int someNum2 = someNum1++;

You would expect a call to
Console.WriteLine(someNum2);
to print out 51, correct? Actually, it will print out 50; however, if you print out someNum1 after that assignment, you'll find that it now holds 51.

The two main differences are as follows:
Pre-Inc/Decrement will evaluate the expression FIRST, and THEN assign the values. The operation
someNum2 = ++someNum1;
says add "1" to the variable called "someNum1", then takes it value, and copy it over to the variable called someNum2.

Post-Inc/Decrement will evaluate the expression AFTER the assigning the values. The operation
someNum2 = someNum1++;
says copy the value of the variable called someNum1 to the variable called someNum2. Then, AFTER this is done, add 1 to the value of the variable called someNum1.

However, this gets even more tricky. All this stuff just comes back to "operator precedence". The post-inc/decrement operators have a very low precedence, meaning that they are evaluated very late. Their precedence is so low, they are evaluated even AFTER the assignment has taken place! However, remember that parentheses () will force evaluation of their containing expression. So, contrary to what you'd expect, the following series of statements:

int someNum1 = 50;
int someNum2 = (someNum1++);
Console.WriteLine(someNum2.ToString());

Will actually display 51 to the screen. This is because the parentheses on the second line forces the evaluation of someNum1 BEFORE assigning its value.

This isn't as scary as it sounds, hang in there :)
Hope I helped,
Nate
0
 
William RichardsonAuthor Commented:
length = 3;
    newLength = ++length;

Prefix increment example
length = 4
newLength = 4

On the expression newLength = ++length; is length getting a new value assigned to it with the prefix increment?  And when you have the a prefix increment/decrement is the precedence just taking place with the prefix first because there are two operators next to each other?  And with postfix increment/decrement is it just taking the value over the assignment operator before it assigns the incremented/decremented value to length?

0
 
käµfm³d 👽Commented:
Don't think of postfix/prefix notation as two operators--it is one operator. In your most recent example, because you are using prefix notation (++ before the variable), the variable "length" will be incremented, then assigned to the variable "newLength."
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.