comcast cable vs T1

Posted on 2009-05-15
Medium Priority
Last Modified: 2012-05-07
We have 14 cubicles at our new location.  Could we use comcast cable for voip or is T1 necessary?
Question by:al4629740
  • 3
LVL 101

Expert Comment

ID: 24398758
T1 is synchronous (same speed up as down), but basic T1 is about 1.5 mbits/sec and usually expensive. Cable is likely to be 5 or more mbits/sec down and 600 kbits/sec up. I would be inclined to try cable, but I would be equally inclined not to take a long term contract in the event the service was not to your liking. ... Thinkpads_User

Expert Comment

ID: 24403349
I would say it depends on a few things.  How many user will be making calls or receiving calls at the same time?   From how the question is worded I would assume you are getting a voip provider on the internet.  For this to work properly the packets from the call must have a minimum amount of latency or delay.  Within your network you can prioritize your traffic using qos, but once the traffic leaves your network you do not have control over it.  The service provider is under no obligation to prioritize your traffic and in many cases will ignore or remove qos markings.  If you are using the t1 to directly get voip from the provider this will give you a certain level of performance not assured by the comcast route.  

Author Comment

ID: 24403386
Will prioritized traffic be that big of an issue?  What does that mean for phone calls?

Expert Comment

ID: 24403515
Priority is important any time congestion occurs.  Voip traffic is much different than most traffic.  It is negatively effected by other traffic.  For instance if were downloading a large file over the same link with no priority you would most likely experience issues with voice quality.  Prioritizing traffic using qos makes it so the voice traffic is not negatively effected in this case.  Phone call was referring to any voip call.

Accepted Solution

table9 earned 2000 total points
ID: 24403792
Some other thoughts on making the decision.  First is what is the business and how much revenue is lost when an outage occurs.  The cost differences are significant between the two.  So you may want to bring to person  making the decision the pro and cons.  Comcast - cost is much lower, risk of poor quality calls is greater. Shared media (think of a hub you share the amount of bandwidth with other customers)   T1 - higher cost lost and lower risk of poor voice quality if provided directly from T1 provider.  Dedicated service (think of a switch port)
You also have a speed difference depending on what you purchase through Comcast.  The T1 will be 1.5 mb  the Comcast will be faster but as described above shared.

Featured Post

Train for your Pen Testing Engineer Certification

Enroll today in this bundle of courses to gain experience in the logistics of pen testing, Linux fundamentals, vulnerability assessments, detecting live systems, and more! This series, valued at $3,000, is free for Premium members, Team Accounts, and Qualified Experts.

Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

Join & Write a Comment

Although VoiceOver IP has been around for a while, internet connections have only recently become fast enough to provide good call quality. Now, VoIP has become a real option for businesses looking at ways to improve their business model. In this ar…
If you try to migrate from Elastix to Issabel, you will face a lot of issues. These problems are inevitable but fortunately, you can fix them. In the guide below, I will explain how I performed the migration while keeping all data and successfully t…
Free Data Recovery software is an advanced solution from Kernel Tools to recover data and files such as documents, emails, database, media and pictures, etc. It supports recovery from physical & logical drive after a hard disk crash, accidental/inte…
Watch the video to know the simple way to remove or recover or reset lost or forgotten passwords of Outlook PST file. With Kernel Outlook Password Recovery tool such operation is very easy to perform. It is a freeware with limitation to use with 500…

587 members asked questions and received personalized solutions in the past 7 days.

Join the community of 500,000 technology professionals and ask your questions.

Join & Ask a Question