How to get aournd undefined column error in MySQL without added another column

What I am trying to do is pretty simple (or so I thought).  I may get an account name to look up either of the form "a" or "a@b". In the former case I want to compare against one column, in the later two columns concatenated.

Below shows what I have tried and the results.  I realize that the easy answer is to just add another column in the table for email but that seems like a duplication of information.  Another possibility is that it may work keeping all names in one column and then splitting them out into two parts if there is an "@" symbol but I like having two columns as it makes for easy sorting by either column when looking at the table directly.

I'm not sure yet whether the system I am setting will be able to insert into multiple tables so I currently trying to keep this as a one table solution.

However, I also realize that the answer may be "you can't do what you are trying to do", which is fine but I thought I would ask just in case there is a way.


#
# In both cases below consider all instances of "a@b" to also sometimes be of the form "a"
#
 
#
# Case 1: Does not return row in case of "a@b", does work in case of "a"
#
SELECT 
	`pwd` 
FROM `accts` 
WHERE  
	IF (
		INSTR('@', 'a@b') != 0, 
		`user` = 'a@b' AND `realm` IS NULL, 
		CONCAT_WS('@', `user`, `realm`) = 'a@b'
	)
 
#
# Case 2: Gives undefined column error
#
SELECT 
	`pwd`, 
	CONCAT_WS('@', `user`, `realm`) AS email
FROM `accts` 
WHERE  
	IF (
		INSTR('@', 'a@b') != 0, 
		`user` = 'a@b' AND `realm` IS NULL, 
		`email` = 'a@b'
	)

Open in new window

LVL 1
RegProctorAsked:
Who is Participating?
I wear a lot of hats...

"The solutions and answers provided on Experts Exchange have been extremely helpful to me over the last few years. I wear a lot of hats - Developer, Database Administrator, Help Desk, etc., so I know a lot of things but not a lot about one thing. Experts Exchange gives me answers from people who do know a lot about one thing, in a easy to use platform." -Todd S.

RegProctorAuthor Commented:
Made a mistake copying the code over. Here it is fixed (although not working so not sure I should say "fixed").

The only difference is "!=" changed to "=".
#
# In both cases below consider all instances of "a@b" to also sometimes be of the form "a"
#
 
#
# Case 1: Does not return row in case of "a@b", does work in case of "a"
#
SELECT 
	`pwd` 
FROM `accts` 
WHERE  
	IF (
		INSTR('@', 'a@b') = 0, 
		`user` = 'a@b' AND `realm` IS NULL, 
		CONCAT_WS('@', `user`, `realm`) = 'a@b'
	);
 
#
# Case 2: Gives undefined column error
#
SELECT 
	`pwd`, 
	CONCAT_WS('@', `user`, `realm`) AS email
FROM `accts` 
WHERE  
	IF (
		INSTR('@', 'a@b') = 0, 
		`user` = 'a@b' AND `realm` IS NULL, 
		`email` = 'a@b'
	);

Open in new window

0
Terry WoodsIT GuruCommented:
Try this:
SELECT 
        `pwd`, 
        CONCAT_WS('@', `user`, `realm`) AS email
FROM `accts` 
WHERE  
        IF (
                INSTR('@', 'a@b') = 0, 
                `user` = 'a@b' AND `realm` IS NULL, 
                CONCAT_WS('@', `user`, `realm`) = 'a@b'
        );

Open in new window

0
snoyes_jwCommented:
You can't refer to an aliased column in the WHERE clause. You have three choices:

- Repeat the expression in the WHERE clause, like TerryAtOpus shows
- Use a HAVING clause instead of a WHERE clause to refer to filter those expressions
- Make the expression part of a subquery, as in SELECT email FROM (SELECT CONCAT_WS('@', `user`, `realm`) AS email FROM accts) AS dt WHERE email = blah...

The approach given by TerryAtOpus is probably best.
0
10 Tips to Protect Your Business from Ransomware

Did you know that ransomware is the most widespread, destructive malware in the world today? It accounts for 39% of all security breaches, with ransomware gangsters projected to make $11.5B in profits from online extortion by 2019.

RegProctorAuthor Commented:
As given by Terry still the same problem, shown below:
Given the data:
 
user  realm  pwd
 a      b     c
 a     NULL   d
 
In the case of:
WHERE  
        IF (
                INSTR('@', 'a@b') = 0, 
                `user` = 'a@b' AND `realm` IS NULL, 
                CONCAT_WS('@', `user`, `realm`) = 'a@b'
        );
 
returns: 0 rows (should be 1 row)
 
And in the case of:
WHERE  
        IF (
                INSTR('@', 'a') = 0, 
                `user` = 'a' AND `realm` IS NULL, 
                CONCAT_WS('@', `user`, `realm`) = 'a'
        );
 
returns: 1 row (just as it should.)

Open in new window

0
Terry WoodsIT GuruCommented:
I think you've got the logic mixed up for the if condition in the first case. It should be:
WHERE  
        IF (
                INSTR('@', 'a@b'),
                `user` = 'a@b' AND `realm` IS NULL,
                CONCAT_WS('@', `user`, `realm`) = 'a@b'
        );
 
And the second case just doesn't make sense, given the data you've got. If your realm is NULL then shouldn't the user be "a@b" otherwise neither of your options in the "if" will return true?
0
RegProctorAuthor Commented:
       IF (
                INSTR('@', 'a') = 0,
                `user` = 'a' AND `realm` IS NULL,
                CONCAT_WS('@', `user`, `realm`) = 'a'
        );

Replacing 'a' with the placeholder 'ToFind':
        IF (
                INSTR('@', 'ToFind') = 0,
                `user` = 'ToFind' AND `realm` IS NULL,
                CONCAT_WS('@', `user`, `realm`) = 'ToFind'
        );

 In pseudo code:
        IF (
                'ToFind' does not have an '@' symbol then do this (assume that the realm is NULL):
                                `user` = 'ToFind' AND `realm` IS NULL,
                otherwise, do this (assume that the realm is NOT NULL but a value we want to match):
                                CONCAT_WS('@', `user`, `realm`) = 'ToFind'
        );

I just don't see a problem with this.
0
Terry WoodsIT GuruCommented:
You're right - it's ok. Your problem is the order of the parameters passed to instr. This works for me on some test data:
       IF (
                INSTR('a@b','@') = 0,
                `user` = 'a' AND `realm` IS NULL,
                CONCAT_WS('@', `user`, `realm`) = 'a@b'
        )

Open in new window

0

Experts Exchange Solution brought to you by

Your issues matter to us.

Facing a tech roadblock? Get the help and guidance you need from experienced professionals who care. Ask your question anytime, anywhere, with no hassle.

Start your 7-day free trial
RegProctorAuthor Commented:
Duh! I can't believe I didn't see that!

Thanks.
0
It's more than this solution.Get answers and train to solve all your tech problems - anytime, anywhere.Try it for free Edge Out The Competitionfor your dream job with proven skills and certifications.Get started today Stand Outas the employee with proven skills.Start learning today for free Move Your Career Forwardwith certification training in the latest technologies.Start your trial today
MySQL Server

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.