kfstout
asked on
Distributed storage space across multiple computers
Ok, so I have like 42 windows XP machines that have at least a 250gb primary hard drive, these machines basically just sit there and process information and send it back to the network, so all there is ever going to be on those 250gb drives is Windows XP. So each of these computers has about 230gb of free space, when you total that up its like 9.6TB of wasted space.
Is there a way to somehow utilize this storage capacity in a meaningful way without having to use each drive as a separate shared storage drive? It would be awesome to somehow tie all this free space together across all these systems and create some type of virtural drive that any system on the network can use.
Is there a way to somehow utilize this storage capacity in a meaningful way without having to use each drive as a separate shared storage drive? It would be awesome to somehow tie all this free space together across all these systems and create some type of virtural drive that any system on the network can use.
ASKER CERTIFIED SOLUTION
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
SOLUTION
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
SOLUTION
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
SANMelody from DataCore will do exactly what you want: http://www.datacore.com/products/prod_SANmelody.asp
Thats not quite what he wants meyersd.
The datacore site quotes "A much more cost-effective solution is available from DataCore. Our SANmelody" shrink-wrap package turns a general-purpose server into an expansion "disk server" from which other systems can draw capacity."
He's not talking about using a general purpose server, he's talking about attempting to use surplus desktop storage capacity. I certainly wouldn't want to farm out critical data from my servers out on to the rest of the network! That product appears to be more about storage consolidation where as kfstout is effectively asking for the opposite of that.
Feel free to correct me if there is a feature that I've missed, but that product seems to be aiming in a slightly different direction.
The datacore site quotes "A much more cost-effective solution is available from DataCore. Our SANmelody" shrink-wrap package turns a general-purpose server into an expansion "disk server" from which other systems can draw capacity."
He's not talking about using a general purpose server, he's talking about attempting to use surplus desktop storage capacity. I certainly wouldn't want to farm out critical data from my servers out on to the rest of the network! That product appears to be more about storage consolidation where as kfstout is effectively asking for the opposite of that.
Feel free to correct me if there is a feature that I've missed, but that product seems to be aiming in a slightly different direction.
The "general purpose disk server" draws its storage from the disks in other systems - not just disk that is directly attached to the storage server. Datacore used to pitch their product (a couple of years ago) as being able to use spare space from desktop PCs and although they no longer use that sort of marketing, the principle remains the same. It's a nifty idea.
Having said that, their website is a cherishable exercise in obfuscation and bewilderment... :-)
Having said that, their website is a cherishable exercise in obfuscation and bewilderment... :-)
Yes nice idea, we have quite a few terabytes of unused storage on desktop PCs here but I wouldn't want to risk that data being compromised/lost or risk a large impact on network performance from that kind of solution.
I can see the benefit of the main examples they use on the site and I've just found the following on there!
"Also, please download the White Paper entitled, 'SANmelody Software Converts PCs into Powerful Network Disk Servers'"
The other thing I would consider is the cost of that software compared to the cost of a nice 4TB (or more) NAS. How much dedicated storage could you purchase for the same cost as that software? And how much space do you expect to gain from the PCs around the network? Take into account that the useable space will drop from the total amount "available" as you will need some kind of fault tolerance.
Answering those questions should get you a good idea of whether it is worth pursuing this idea or whether it would be better to spend time and money on dedicated storage.
I can see the benefit of the main examples they use on the site and I've just found the following on there!
"Also, please download the White Paper entitled, 'SANmelody Software Converts PCs into Powerful Network Disk Servers'"
The other thing I would consider is the cost of that software compared to the cost of a nice 4TB (or more) NAS. How much dedicated storage could you purchase for the same cost as that software? And how much space do you expect to gain from the PCs around the network? Take into account that the useable space will drop from the total amount "available" as you will need some kind of fault tolerance.
Answering those questions should get you a good idea of whether it is worth pursuing this idea or whether it would be better to spend time and money on dedicated storage.
ASKER
I already have multiple RAID 5 arrays, just thought I'd see if there were any practical ways to utilize "wasted" space like that. I'll check out that link.