IIS SMTP Setup with 2 IP Addresses


I have a web server which has 2 ip addresses ...194 and ...196  Each of these ip addresses is used for separate websites.   Each of these websites send out email (order confirms to customers, error reporting etc).  

Some email sent to customers (aol mainly) ends up in junk.  In order to reduce this, we have set a reverse dns on each each ip address.  

However I discovered today that we are still sending out emails for both websites from the first ip address (194).  I tried to change this today by setting the ip address in the Default SMTP Virtual server to All Unassigned.  However, when I then configured the web application to send email via the second ip address, the email did not get sent out.

Do I need to set up a second virtual server to make this all work?

Any good resources?

Who is Participating?
rgc6789Connect With a Mentor Commented:
I have dozens of IP's and hundreds of URL's on some of my servers. What I do is create one reverse dns for the main IP and then add the domain / IP to each domains mx records. Additionally I add the domain to the spf record.

If I'm not mistaken, AOL looks at the reverse dns of the IP the mail is coming from and checks it against the list in the mx records for that domain. Hotmail, I believe, checks the spf record also. I'm hesitant to be exact because I haven't checked the rules in about 6 months and they may have changed.
wolfman007Connect With a Mentor Commented:
The IIS Virtual SMTP server will only send out emails on the IP address of the default NIC.

See the following website

Thread: Changing the Outgoing IP Address in SMTP
WingYipAuthor Commented:
Looking in the headers of the emails sent out, this is indeed the case although it seems to route from the default ip to the virtual server ip and then out.

Have not tested with aol yet but hopefully this will suffice.

Thanks all

Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.