Static IPs behind multiple routers

Unable to access internet from server (xxx.xxx.xxx.5) or from PCs with DHCP IP assigned from Router 2.  See below for details:

Internet-> Modem ->Router1 => Server and Router2

Modem xxx.xxx.65.1
Modem Gateway xxx.xxx.65.0

Router1 WAN xxx.xxx.65.2
Router1 Gateway xxx.xxx.65.1
Router1 LAN xxx.xxx.65.3

Server xxx.xxx.65.5
Server Gateway xxx.xxx.65.3

Router2 WAN xxx.xxx.65.4
Router2 Gateway xxx.xxx.65.3
Router2 LAN DHCP (192.168.0.1)
----------------
When I set Router1 LAN to DHCP and server to dynamic, it sees the internet.  Router1 Gateway stays the same xxx.xxx.xxx.1 and the actual changes are to Server and PC IPs when dynamically assigned, as well as the gateway that is also dynamically assigned (192.168.0.1)
----------------
But what I need is to simply have static IPs on the modem, router1, server, and WAN of router2 and all is good.  What am I missing?  (port forwarding not an option I'm considering unless what I am doing is breaking some cardinal rule that makes absolutely no sense)

Could it be related to the subnet mask?

Thanks for your input.
LVL 1
internethotspotAsked:
Who is Participating?
I wear a lot of hats...

"The solutions and answers provided on Experts Exchange have been extremely helpful to me over the last few years. I wear a lot of hats - Developer, Database Administrator, Help Desk, etc., so I know a lot of things but not a lot about one thing. Experts Exchange gives me answers from people who do know a lot about one thing, in a easy to use platform." -Todd S.

kirklandltdukCommented:
Hi, if the server picks up the gateway address correctly via DHCP from the router then maybe all you need to do is to add the DNS server details of your ISP either on the router or specifically on the TCP-IP properties of the Server LAN card.  That should then show it that the Internet is not local and is outside of your local LAN so therefore the gateway comes into play.

I hope this helps and I have understood ypur question.
0
internethotspotAuthor Commented:
I'm not totally clear.  Could you provide the TCP/IP details for the server in this scenario?

Modem xxx.xxx.65.1
Modem Gateway xxx.xxx.65.0

Router1 WAN xxx.xxx.65.2
Router1 Gateway xxx.xxx.65.1
Router1 LAN xxx.xxx.65.3

Do I need to set the Router1 LAN to DHCP?
What would the server settings be in this case?

Thank you
0
kirklandltdukCommented:
OK,
TCP-IP settings referred to are simply the addresses you are using i.e. Gateway address etc.
If the Router is setup to be the DHCP server then all the other machines should be set to get their details dynamically.
The router may or may not have the option of specifying the the DNS server details that your network would use to find any web pages that users on the LAN request but you can type the addresses in manually if required on each machine by going to: Network Settings, Propteries of you LAN connection, TCP-IP settings, DNS Server addresses.
If you want more of a walkthrough I will need to know what Opeating System you are using.
0
Determine the Perfect Price for Your IT Services

Do you wonder if your IT business is truly profitable or if you should raise your prices? Learn how to calculate your overhead burden with our free interactive tool and use it to determine the right price for your IT services. Download your free eBook now!

internethotspotAuthor Commented:
Further to initial post, each device (server/router) with static IP has primary and secondary DNS entered in manually.  EG. 67.55.0.11

It would be easiest to only look at the server, behind the router rather then to worry about the other router and PCs.

Internet-> Modem ->Router1 => Server and Router2

Modem xxx.xxx.65.1
Modem Gateway xxx.xxx.65.0

Router1 WAN xxx.xxx.65.2
Router1 Gateway xxx.xxx.65.1
Server Primary DNS 67.55.0.11
Server Secondary DNS 66.49.220.95
Router1 LAN xxx.xxx.65.3

Server xxx.xxx.65.5
Server Gateway xxx.xxx.65.3
Server Primary DNS 67.55.0.11
Server Secondary DNS 66.49.220.95

I don't know if I'm helping or not.  Basically I'm not intending to use DHCP so wanted to remove it from consideration.

From this, am I missing any information?  If not, what is the problem preventing the server from seeing the internet?
0
DCMBSCommented:
Yes it absolutely lookd like the sub net mask.  A router routes between networks. It looks like you have the same network on both interfaces of the router.  The router cannot work like this
0
internethotspotAuthor Commented:
I see what you mean.  The Modem is xxx.xxx.65.xxx as is the router1 WAN IP, therefore the router1 LAN IP must be different (router must translate).

Instead of a router, can a switch be used? Any other simple hardware solution that would enable me to have multiple static IPs sharing a single modem?  Eg. that would allow static IPs on a server and router on the LAN side.

I was originally thinking that by turning off DHCP that the wan and lan sides of the router would basically be passing data from one to the other, not taking into consideration that it has to translate.  Short-sighted design imho but that's just me lol.

0
DCMBSCommented:
Can you not just give each device the modem as it's default gateway ?
0
DCMBSCommented:
Tes I see what you mean.  A switch should suffice here.
0

Experts Exchange Solution brought to you by

Your issues matter to us.

Facing a tech roadblock? Get the help and guidance you need from experienced professionals who care. Ask your question anytime, anywhere, with no hassle.

Start your 7-day free trial
DCMBSCommented:
Is the modem a modem router with a firewall.  If not you should be thinking about a firewall?
0
internethotspotAuthor Commented:
I will try a switch attached to the modem instead of Router1, then connect Router2 and the server to the switch, using the modem gateway (rather then a router gateway).  Will have to wait till tonight to give this a try.  Thanks for the support :)
0
DCMBSCommented:
No Worries, I'll be in the land of nod by then.
0
internethotspotAuthor Commented:
Thank you for confirming the solution - use a switch.  Sometimes I get a lapse in memory and it has to be jogged.  Once I realized NAT was the problem (using a router), a switch came to mind, and your confirmation was a great assist.
0
It's more than this solution.Get answers and train to solve all your tech problems - anytime, anywhere.Try it for free Edge Out The Competitionfor your dream job with proven skills and certifications.Get started today Stand Outas the employee with proven skills.Start learning today for free Move Your Career Forwardwith certification training in the latest technologies.Start your trial today
Network Architecture

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.