Link to home
Start Free TrialLog in
Avatar of hsitner
hsitner

asked on

Configure my wireless (Belkin) router to work with Remote desktop and a comcast fixed IP?

Hi -
I am getting desperate!  I have comcast cable with a fixed ip.  
I have an XP Pro box that I need to remote desktop into (it has to be RDP, not logmein, etc.).
On the comcast router I have port 3389 forwarded to the ip address of the XP box.  
in that configuration it all works like a dream.  I can remote in no problem.
now, when I plug in my belkin wireless, it still works fine.
but, when any computer connects to the beklin and gets a dynamic address, the remote desktop no longer works.  I can remove the computers from the belin and then RDP starts working again no problem.  
something is going on...

anyone have any ideas?

thanks!
Avatar of Jon Brelie
Jon Brelie
Flag of United States of America image

did you exclude the static IP you setup for your pc from the DHCP on the belkin?  or did you disable DHCP on the belkin and just use the comcast router?  Make sure there aren't duplicate dhcp servers.
Avatar of hsitner
hsitner

ASKER

thanks!
I disabled DHCP on the comcast, but I still have the same issues.
Basically, if I disconnect all the computers in the house from the belkin (but it is still on) I can hop on my ATT network and remote in.  As soon as another computer gets online via the belkin, I can no longer remote in on the ATT connection.

the comcast router doesn't have wireless, that's why I have the belkin.

any ideas?

From your posts, I am making the following assumtions:

 - The computer you want to RDP to is not connected to the Belkin
 - You only have one dhcp server enabled on your network.

Does your belkin have your RDPbox's IP excluded from it's dhcp range?  You aren't getting any IP conflict messages are you?

Are you certain you forwarded port 3389 from your comcast router directly to the RDPbox?  Does RDP work when you have the belkin turned off?
Avatar of hsitner

ASKER

Thanks!
Yes - the XP Pro box is hardwired into the comcast router
and yes, the only enabled DHCP is on the belkin.

I'm getting no conflicts.  the RDP box has the internal IP address 10.1.10.21, I use port forwarding (3389) to forward from the IP to that box.

RDP works fine when the belkin is on or off.  it only stops working when another computer hops onto it.

it's quite perplexing to me.
are your systems on the belkin on a different network than your RDPbox?  IE, different subnet?
Avatar of hsitner

ASKER

slightly over my head - subnets.  the subent masks on both of them are the same (255.255.255.0)
the IP addresses are different though (10.1.10.1 for the comcast) and 192.168.2.1 for the belkin.

Okay.  When you have systems connected to the Belkin router, is it only rdp to the other system that doesn't work?  It can still access the internet just fine?

Is sounds like you have a combination Comcast Modem+Router (CRM), and then are connecting another Belkin Wireless Router (BWR) down the line.  I'll use RDP to refer to the RDP XP Box.
(1) Cable -> CRM -> RDP (works)
(2) Cable -> CRM -> BWR -> RDP (doesn't work)
(3) Cable -> CRM -> BWR -> (other wireless computers)
                            +----> RDP (wired via CRM)
 
Now, do you have config (2) or config (3) as the config with the Belkin involved?  If you're trying config (2), then you'll have to ensure the CRM forwards port 3389 to the BWR, and then the BWR forwards that port the the RDP.  
Another way to handle this config that is (IMHO) easier, is to connect the BWR to the CRM via the LAB side of the BWR.  Disable DHCP on the BWR, and it will just serve as an access point and switch (not a router). This would remove one router hop complication.
If this doesn't help, post the model number of the CRM as well as more specifics on how you have the RDP box wired in each case.  It will let the rest of us more easily diagnose the problem (since we can't see your wiring).
Avatar of hsitner

ASKER

Thanks.
let's see if I can give back some data for you.
(1) does work (I read this as:  cable line goes into the SRC brand CRM, RDP is connected to CRM, I can RDP in)
(2) does work (I read this as the above, but now the BWR is plugged into the CRM)
(3) does not work (I read this as the (2) but now there are computers getting dynamic addresses from the BWR)

Both 2 and 3 have the BWR.  the configuration works fine (port forwarding, etc.) until another computer attaches to the BWR.

What is the "LAB side of the BWR"?  I don't think I can do this as I want the DHCP on the BWR - I have several computers in the house that need to access the wireless connection.

the CRM is an SMC not sure of the model #, I can get that later.
on the RDP box, it's network adapter is hardwired to grab the IP 10.2.1.21, and on the CRM I have port 3389 forwarded to that.  that's what works like a charm.  
The BWR gives out DHCP addresses starting at 192.168.2.26

thanks
Oops.  LAN, not LAB.  Connect the output from the CRM directly to a LAN port (not the WAN port) of the BWR.  Before you do this, disable the DHCP service on the BWR.  Now, by connecting it to the LAN side, the CRM serves as the DHCP server and port forwarder.  The BWR is simply acting as a 4-port switch (one port of which is connected to the CRM, another to your RDP.  Finally, the wireless section of the BWR acts as an access point.  The "router" function of the BWR is left unused since you didn't connect to the WAN port.
Give it a try.  Since (1) works, using the BWR as an access port + switch should keep that functionality.
Avatar of hsitner

ASKER

Thanks.  the problem with this is the CRM doesn't have wireless capabilty, that the was the whole reason I bough the BWR.  Maybe I can get Comcast to supply a CRM with wireless abilities
I think you're missing the point.  If you connect the BWR on the LAN side, you can still use the wireless capabilities.  The only thing is the router functionality is bypassed since you don't really need it.  So, the config is:
cable -> CRM ----(ethernet)---> (LAN side of) BWR --(ethernet connected to LAN on BWR) --> RDP.
You have the CRM set up exactly as you had it in (1) above, with it forwarding to the RDP and serving as the DHCP server.  The BWR has it's own DHCP server turned off (you only want one per subnet) and effectively serves as a network switch (the four wired lan ports) and an access point (the wireless function).  The router functionality (WAN port) is left unused as you don't need it and it simply adds more complication.
I've set networks up this way before and it greatly simplifies the forwarding issues.  Give it a quick try.
Avatar of hsitner

ASKER

Thanks again.  we might be getting closer, but a side effect has caused me not be able to duplicate a scenario.  basically, I have everything configured as described.  my vista/thinkpad laptop is attaching wireless to the belkin.  I went to use my wife's mac to attempt the RDP with the thinkpad on the network, but her laptop wouldn't connect to the BWR.  I took it downstairs and hardwired in, it won't connect either.  Interestingly, the thinkpad laptop connects wirelessly but not via the cord (tried with two seperate ethernet cables).  both computers can connect when hardwired into the CRM.
so without a second computer to throw onto the network (one to RDP into the RDP box, and one to be on the network) I can't test the scenario.

any idea why a mac might not be able to connect wirelessly or wired to the BWR?
ASKER CERTIFIED SOLUTION
Avatar of thegof
thegof
Flag of United States of America image

Link to home
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
Start Free Trial