• Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 300
  • Last Modified:

Should I do an in place upgrade from Windows Server 2003 Standard to Windows Server 2008 Standard?

Hello Experts:

I have two domain controllers running Windows Server 2003 R2 standard.  I would like to upgrade them to Windows 2008 Standard.  I have read some articles that it is not advisable to do and in-place upgrade--but to do a fresh install on another server and then move the domains over.  I much more prefer to do and in-place upgrade.  Can someone tell me what is the best route to take?

3 Solutions
Jon BrelieSystem ArchitectCommented:
I would definitely NOT do an in place upgrade.  If you don't have the spare hardware, I would demote one of your DCs, remove it from the network and do a fresh install of 2008 before rejoining and re-promoting.
I never do in place upgrades.  Fresh installs is the only (somewhat) reliable method.  Do what Enphyniti advises.  If you don't have spare hardware, demote one of your current DCs, do a fresh install of 2008 and then bring it up to a DC level (make sure you know all of the steps including have a system state backup and checking your current AD health before doing so).  

Once you have your 2008 DC up you can DCPROMO your 2003 server.  Leave it offline for a few days to make sure everything is good.  If it isn't, you have the option of taking the 2008 DC down and doing a system state restore to your 2003 server to get your old AD back.
In addition, you may be running 32-bit on the 2003 server and want to use 64-bit on the 2008 server. In this case, you have no option, you need to do a fresh install.
Good point.  2008 R2 is 64 bit only, so if you are going that route you'll need 64 bit hardware.
huntersp3Author Commented:
Thanks everyone--great advice!

Featured Post

Become an Android App Developer

Ready to kick start your career in 2018? Learn how to build an Android app in January’s Course of the Month and open the door to new opportunities.

Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now