switch statement access sql

Below is a query I am trying to run that is not working properly. Even when the Gross Sales are less than the TIER 1 MINIMUM_Standard value, the query still returns "More" as the Normal Rebate Amount. The TIER 1 MINIMUM_Standard field is a double in access so I don't think it should have single quotes around it but if I don't use the quotes I get #Error for my results. The Gross Sales field is generated by another query that rounds the sum of a double field so I don't know why they are not comparing correctly. Below is the query I am using the switch statement in.
SELECT 
    qryTempSalesForCalculation.[Location Code],
    qryTempSalesForCalculation.[Group Code],
    qryTempSalesForCalculation.[Gross Sales],
	SWITCH(
		[Gross Sales] < [TIER 1 MINIMUM_Standard],
		    "Less",
		[Gross Sales] > '[TIER 1 MINIMUM_Standard]',
		    "More")
	AS [Normal Rebate Amount]
FROM 
    NA_Groups 
INNER JOIN 
    qryTempSalesForCalculation 
ON NA_Groups.[GROUP CODE] = qryTempSalesForCalculation.[Group Code];

Open in new window

LVL 1
wipnavAsked:
Who is Participating?
 
Kevin CrossChief Technology OfficerCommented:
The having to use quotes around a double value doesn't seem right at all, so I would ensure by being explicit that the value from other query is a double. Additionally, what happens if they are equal ?
SELECT 
    qryTempSalesForCalculation.[Location Code],
    qryTempSalesForCalculation.[Group Code],
    qryTempSalesForCalculation.[Gross Sales],
	SWITCH(
		CDbl([Gross Sales]) < [TIER 1 MINIMUM_Standard],
		    "Less",
		CDbl([Gross Sales]) > [TIER 1 MINIMUM_Standard],
		    "More", True, "Same")
	AS [Normal Rebate Amount]
FROM 
    NA_Groups 
INNER JOIN 
    qryTempSalesForCalculation 
ON NA_Groups.[GROUP CODE] = qryTempSalesForCalculation.[Group Code];

Open in new window

0
 
dwkorCommented:
Something like that
SELECT 
    qryTempSalesForCalculation.[Location Code],
    qryTempSalesForCalculation.[Group Code],
    qryTempSalesForCalculation.[Gross Sales],
	(CASE 
		WHEN 
			[Gross Sales] < [TIER 1 MINIMUM_Standard]
		THEN "Less"
		ELSE 
			CASE 
				WHEN[Gross Sales] > [TIER 1 MINIMUM_Standard]
				THEN "More"
				ELSE "Equal"
			END
	END)
	AS [Normal Rebate Amount]
FROM 
    NA_Groups 
INNER JOIN 
    qryTempSalesForCalculation 
ON NA_Groups.[GROUP CODE] = qryTempSalesForCalculation.[Group Code];

Open in new window

0
 
wipnavAuthor Commented:
This is an access database, I don't believe case statements are allowed.
0
Ultimate Tool Kit for Technology Solution Provider

Broken down into practical pointers and step-by-step instructions, the IT Service Excellence Tool Kit delivers expert advice for technology solution providers. Get your free copy now.

 
DatabaseMX (Joe Anderson - Microsoft Access MVP)Database ArchitectCommented:
Why do you have single quotes around this:

[Gross Sales] > '[TIER 1 MINIMUM_Standard]',


?

mx
0
 
Rey Obrero (Capricorn1)Commented:

SELECT
    qryTempSalesForCalculation.[Location Code],
    qryTempSalesForCalculation.[Group Code],
    qryTempSalesForCalculation.[Gross Sales],
      SWITCH(
            [Gross Sales] < [TIER 1 MINIMUM_Standard],
                "Less",
            [Gross Sales] > [TIER 1 MINIMUM_Standard],
                "More")
      AS [Normal Rebate Amount]
FROM
    NA_Groups
INNER JOIN
    qryTempSalesForCalculation
ON NA_Groups.[GROUP CODE] = qryTempSalesForCalculation.[Group Code];
0
 
wipnavAuthor Commented:
Sorry, I missed removing those in the example. If I have single quotes around [TIER 1 MINIMUM_Standard] for both the < and > of the switch statement, the query returns "More" for all values, but if I leave out the single quotes, every record has #Error.
0
 
wipnavAuthor Commented:
Thank you, that was exactly the problem. The [Gross Sales] field was from a seperate query that pulled from a double field BUT I had rounded it to two decimal places because I am dealing with currency which must have changed the format.

Does the value become a string after a round() function?
0
 
Rey Obrero (Capricorn1)Commented:
where do you get the values for [TIER 1 MINIMUM_Standard]

do you have the field [TIER 1 MINIMUM_Standard] in your query qryTempSalesForCalculation  or in table NA_Groups?
0
 
Kevin CrossChief Technology OfficerCommented:
Not as far as I know. Round() should equate to a number. Maybe there was something else in the query like format or something, but glad the explicit conversion to double helped.
0
 
wipnavAuthor Commented:
[TIER 1 MINIMUM_Standard0 is in the table NA_Groups
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.