Unable to Send mail from one Exchange Server to another in same domain

I have 3 MS Exchange 2003 SP2 servers each running on Windows 2003 SP2.   They are all on the same private subnet.  None are running firewall software.

One is new.  Mailboxes on that server cannot successfully send mail to mailboxes on the other servers nor to any external mail receipients.   The messages stay in the server's SMTP queue.
Those same mailboxes can receive messages without problem.
All servers can be seen and managed from the others.

Any thoughts on why messages are stuck in queue?

Attached are log files from both the new (sending) and old (receiving server).    I'd appreciate any assistance.

Thank you.
Who is Participating?
Hypercat (Deb)Connect With a Mentor Commented:
How long has this new server been in operation? Was it ever able to send email? Have you tried restarting the SMTP services on both servers?
Are there any errors in the event logs related to SMTP? If not, you might want to turn up the SMTP diagnostics logging for the time being to see if you get any event log errors that might be helpful in diagnosing this. It looks like the two servers are communicating but that the communication is being dropped at some point due to some sort of timeout.
Also, download the Exchange Best Practices Analyzer tool, install and run it. That may also help in pointing out any configuration errors:
This sounds like an authentication issue to me.  Check your receive connectors on all servers and make sure that Exchange Server authentication is checked off on both the authentication and Permission Groups tabs.  The receive connector can be found in the Exchange Management Console under Server Configuration, Hub Transport.  Right click on the connector and select Properties to see the settings.
MegaNuk3Connect With a Mentor Commented:
hmmm, run winroute and see if the new server can see the old ones and the old ones can see the new ones...

Usage: http://support.microsoft.com/kb/281382
Download: http://www.microsoft.com/downloads/details.aspx?familyid=c5a8afbf-a4da-45e0-adea-6d44eb6c257b&displaylang=en

Other than that make sure the new server is in the "Exchange Domain Servers" group
Problems using Powershell and Active Directory?

Managing Active Directory does not always have to be complicated.  If you are spending more time trying instead of doing, then it's time to look at something else. For nearly 20 years, AD admins around the world have used one tool for day-to-day AD management: Hyena. Discover why

RichardKlineAuthor Commented:
Thank you.
1. Still Checking authentications.  Two of the three can exchange messages without an issue so I tend to think that the problem lies with the new third box.
2. No SMTP errors - but I will increase sensitivity.  The box has been in operation for about 2 weeks.   I've tried, when I have had the time, restarting all servers, uninstalling Exchange on the new box, re-applying Sp2,   The symptoms have always been the same.  Neither of the mailboxes (2 for testing purposes) can send e-mail but receiving isn't a problem.  However, the mailboxes can both send and receive when they are moved to an older server.
3. Winroute -- nothing obvious but I'm still checking.
hmmm can you telnet from the new server to the old ones and send a message?
maybe the new ones are restricted by IP address on their SMTP virtual servers so will not accept from the new server.
RichardKlineAuthor Commented:
Just an update.   I''ve not yet investigated all of the suggestions but I haven't found that "Eureka" point so far.   Hopefully by this evening.

Thank you again for the ideas!
RichardKlineAuthor Commented:
Everything is working now but 'darn' if I can figure out what one thing caused the problem.    I was working down the "Best Practices" list and a few thoughts of my own (uninstall/reinstall AV, etc) when the magic happened.      
I put akmost all of the original settings and the server is still operating.   The one left out deals with SystemPages set too high (http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/aa996786(EXCHG.80).aspx).  I roubt that's the problem though with two mailboxes.

Anywa, Thanks!  
Hypercat (Deb)Commented:
Darn - I hate when that happens! It's frustrating not to be able to identify exactly what was wrong and what fixed it. Glad you got it sorted though.
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.