Will tape BULK ERASER erase a dead HD?

I have an unusable / dead hard drive. It is under warranty. I must return the defective drive. I do not want to leave my data on it naturally. I have a HEAVY DUTY a.c. operated bulk tape eraser that will completely wipe clean any audio tape or any video tape. I am wondering if I apply it to the exterior of my defective hard drive if it will erase the data? PLEASE ONLY ANSWER this question if you are 95% or more SURE that your answer is correct. I have my own opinion, but it is not based on fact. I need to be sure on this as most people would also be.
Who is Participating?
Lee W, MVPConnect With a Mentor Technology and Business Process AdvisorCommented:
Most of the third paragraph from http://www.pcworld.com/article/116572/busting_the_biggest_pc_myths.html
"The only magnets powerful enough to scrub data from a drive platter are laboratory degaussers or those used by government agencies to wipe bits off media. "In the real world, people are not losing data from magnets," says Bill Rudock, a tech-support engineer with hard-drive maker Seagate. "In every disk," notes Rudock, "there's one heck of a magnet that swings the head.""

If the data is that sensitive you can't afford to have it even looked at accidentally, to heck with your warranty.  Hard Drives are $40-80 for most sizes up to 1 TB.  Just get a new one.
Dave BaldwinConnect With a Mentor Fixer of ProblemsCommented:
Here's an article that says it won't work: http://www.zdnet.com/blog/hardware/erasing-hard-drives/386  And here's a company that makes machine that will do it: http://www.datadev.com/degausser-hard-drive-data-security-erase.html  You don't want one of those in your house.  There is a reason that the 'remote control' is usable from 45 feet away...

rindiConnect With a Mentor Commented:
If it is strong enough and the magnetic field can pass the metal case of the drive, then yes, but since tapes usually only have plastic cases you don't need a very strong degausser for them, so it is possible that it isn't strong enough for an HD.
Free Tool: IP Lookup

Get more info about an IP address or domain name, such as organization, abuse contacts and geolocation.

One of a set of tools we are providing to everyone as a way of saying thank you for being a part of the community.

Need-a-ClueRESEARCHERAuthor Commented:
THANKS EVERYONE! Looks like I'll have to dig up another solution. Your research is appreciated. I WOULD buy  a new one BUT Dell wants their OWN drive back OR they charge incredibly inflated prices.
Lee W, MVPTechnology and Business Process AdvisorCommented:
Soo... tell Dell forget it.  And go to newegg.com and buy a new drive.  They won't replace the existing one, but you won't have to worry about problems.
Or bore holes into the drive, or open it and scratch the surfaces of the platters, then send them back.
Lee W, MVPTechnology and Business Process AdvisorCommented:
No, then they'll claim the drive was ruined by you and then charge you for it.
The Sage is 100% correct (>95%). Physical destruction is the only way and is also the norm for regulated industries and the fact there are commercial entities that offer, at a price,  physical destruction of hard drives, tapes etc. is a testimonial to the above. You cannot count on anything else. Nothing.
All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.