• Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 696
  • Last Modified:

Storing a record in a TList with different struct

Hello,

What is the best way to identify wich kind of record is in the list?

Example

type
  TSomethingA = record //A = ANSI
    chBla: array [0..9] of AnsiChar;
  end;
  PSomethingA = ^TSomethingA;

  TSomethingW = record //W = UNICODE
    chBla: array [0..9] of WideChar;
  end;
  PSomethingW = ^TSomethingW;

//global var
var
  lsList: TList;

//the lsList is created and inside has a lot of PSomethingW and PSomethingA stored
procedure Something;
var
  SomethingA: PSomethingA;
  SomethingW: PSomethingW;
  i: Integer;
begin
  //now, walking in lsList, an item can be of type SomethingA or SomethingW
  for i := 0 to Pred(lsList.Count) do
  //what is the best method to identify, if the current item "lsList[ i ]" is a SomethingA or SomethingW?
  end;
end;
0
cebasso
Asked:
cebasso
  • 3
  • 2
1 Solution
 
epasquierCommented:
you can't with records, or it would require a complex set of records declarations that would follow a simple rule : having a Type field before (integer)

Easiest way : use class instead
type
  TSomethingA = Class //A = ANSI
    chBla: array [0..9] of AnsiChar;
  end;
//  PSomethingA = ^TSomethingA;

  TSomethingW = Class //W = UNICODE
    chBla: array [0..9] of WideChar;
  end;
//  PSomethingW = ^TSomethingW;

//global var
var
  lsList: TObjectList; // Change TList to TObjectList

//the lsList is created and inside has a lot of PSomethingW and PSomethingA stored
procedure Something;
var
  SomethingA: TSomethingA;
  SomethingW: TSomethingW;
  i: Integer;
begin
  //now, walking in lsList, an item can be of type SomethingA or SomethingW
  for i := 0 to Pred(lsList.Count) do
   if lsList[ i ] is TSomethingA Then // Use Is operator on TObject
    begin
...
    end;
end;

Open in new window

0
 
cebassoAuthor Commented:
hey epasquier!

cool!
but, the struct has more members like

chBla: array [0.9] of WideChar;
dwFlags: DWORD;
iSomething: Integer;
//and more

no problem?

and actually i'm using New() to store in TList, like

var
  SomethingA: PSomethingA;
begin
  New(SomethingA);
  FillChar(SomethingA^, SizeOf(TSomethingA), 0);
  //fill members
  lsList.Add(SomethingA);
  Dispose(SomethingA);
end;

now, with your code, i need just to change PSomethingA to TSomethingA as a class, do the same and store in a TObjectList instead TList like your example?
0
 
epasquierCommented:
no, you can't create objects with New, and do not use FillChar on them.
It's possible that your needs are not compatible with Objects... So you might have to do it the hard way, with a Type field in records.
I wont have time to explain you that alternate today, I'll think of the best thing for you and explain monday
0
Independent Software Vendors: We Want Your Opinion

We value your feedback.

Take our survey and automatically be enter to win anyone of the following:
Yeti Cooler, Amazon eGift Card, and Movie eGift Card!

 
epasquierCommented:
Alternate method with a field identifying the record. It could be an integer with some constants defined, but that is as well done with an enumerated type.

With that method, you won't have much to change from your older code. I recommend that you use these kind of techniques for API purpose only where you can't use Delphi objects. You can always create objects wrapper around these structures if you use a lot of those in your application.

type
  RecordType=(rtSomethingA,rtSomethingW);
  pRecordType=^RecordType;

  TSomethingA = record //A = ANSI
    RecType:RecordType; // = rtSomethingA
    chBla: array [0..9] of AnsiChar;
  end;
  PSomethingA = ^TSomethingA;

  TSomethingW = record //W = UNICODE
    RecType:RecordType; // = rtSomethingW
    chBla: array [0..9] of WideChar;
  end;
  PSomethingW = ^TSomethingW;

//global var
var
  lsList: TList;

//the lsList is created and inside has a lot of PSomethingW and PSomethingA stored
procedure Something;
var
  i: Integer;
begin
 for i := 0 to Pred(lsList.Count) do
  Case pRecordType(lsList[i])^ of
   rtSomethingA: With PSomethingA(lsList[i])^ do ... 
   rtSomethingW: With PSomethingW(lsList[i])^ do ... 
  end;
end;

Open in new window

0
 
GeneralTackettCommented:
How about using records with variant parts  example:
TPerson = record
  FirstName : string[40];
  LastName : string[40];
{ Fixed portion of record begins here }
  BirthDate: TDate;
  case
     Citizen: Boolean of
{ variant portion of record begins here }
      True: (BirthPlace: string[40]);
      False:
        (
        Country: string[20];
        EntryPort: string[20];
        EntryDate: TDate;
        ExitDate: TDate
        );
end;
0
 
cebassoAuthor Commented:
Thanks!
0

Featured Post

Concerto Cloud for Software Providers & ISVs

Can Concerto Cloud Services help you focus on evolving your application offerings, while delivering the best cloud experience to your customers? From DevOps to revenue models and customer support, the answer is yes!

Learn how Concerto can help you.

  • 3
  • 2
Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now