[2 days left] What’s wrong with your cloud strategy? Learn why multicloud solutions matter with Nimble Storage.Register Now

x
Solved

# Looking for alternative formula for a SUMPRODUCT(OFFSET function

Posted on 2010-11-24
Medium Priority
718 Views
Hi
I have the following formula in Excel 2007 posted in cell M199:
``````SUMPRODUCT(OFFSET(\$GJ\$197,0,-M\$192+1,1,M\$192),COHORT!\$V12:V12))
``````

....whereby Row197 represents a flipped input, and Row 192 equals the month in my timeline.

The formula works successfully and does what it is supposed to do.  However because of the length of the sumproduct (i.e from column M to GJ) and the number of rows (this goes down a few '000 rows) my spreadsheet is enormous (100mb).  Also it takes some time to recalculate.

I was wondering if anyone could think of an alternative formula, perhaps using dynamic range names, which would eliminate the need for so many SUMPRODUCTS, or at least speed up my spreadsheet?

Brian
0
Question by:boru8482
[X]
###### Welcome to Experts Exchange

Add your voice to the tech community where 5M+ people just like you are talking about what matters.

• Help others & share knowledge
• Earn cash & points
• 2
• 2
• 2

LVL 50

Expert Comment

ID: 34208681
Is that the complete formula, you have 2 open brackets and three closed so it won't work as is, is part of the formula missing?

As COHORT!V12:V12 is a single cell the result of the OFFSET must also be a single cell, is that guaranteed?

Could you explain a little more, what's in M192 exactly, are you copy the formula down or across or both?

regards, barry
0

Expert Comment

ID: 34208759
Hi Barry

Well spotted.  There is an IF formula just before it which basically looks at a switch as to whether to bother with this calculation or not - you can forget it about for now.  This is the TRUE part of that IF statement.

Cohort V\$12:V12 is dynamic in that if you drag the cells to the right, it will extend all the way to V\$12:GT12.  This range is then multiplied within the SUMPRODUCT by the OFFSET part of the formula.

This formula is also dragged down a few thousand rows so as you can see I have got a lot of SUMPRODUCTs going on causing my s'sheet to run very slowly and get very large.

I was thinking it could be done by having a dynamic range for the COHORT part and the OFFSET part by I'm not sure whether this can a) be done or b) how one goes about it if one can?

As for M192, this is just the number of the month that my timeline refers to.  I.E M192 is month 1, M193 is month 2 (although "month" isn't actually written, just the number).  Hope that helps a little....I appreciate it is hard to explain what I'm trying to do...

Thanks
Brian
0

LVL 50

Accepted Solution

barry houdini earned 2000 total points
ID: 34209137
OFFSET function is volatile (meaning it re-calculates every time the worksheet is re-calculated - even if none of the inputs have changed)

You could try replacing OFFSET with an INDEX formula

It looks longer but it should be more efficient, try this in place of the OFFSET

=INDEX(\$A\$197:\$GJ\$197,COLUMNS(\$A\$197:\$GJ\$197)+1-M\$192):\$GJ\$197

regards, barry

0

Expert Comment

ID: 34209706
Hi Barry

Thanks for this - I will give it a shot first thing in the morning and let you know how I get on.

Cheers
Brian
0

Author Comment

ID: 34212310
Hi Barry

The formula worked!  Many thanks for that...

However, the file size hasn't reduced mainly because of the range of the SUMPRODUCT (i.e. the range it is looking at is stretching from A to GJ).

One of the pieces of information that I omitted to tell you was that this formula is actually copied down in blocks of three (i.e. same formula for c.1000 lines down, then a new block with the same formula 1000 lines down etc).  The only difference between the three blocks is that they refer to different periods of time - i.e  Periods A is 10 months long, B 50 months and C, 24 months).  The length of these periods is changeable though depending on what is input.

What I'm wondering is, would it be possible to get the SUMPRODUCT to work with a range that only goes as far as is needed depending on the length of the period set?  This way, my SUMPRODUCT would only look at a range of 10 months in Period A and not the full 84 periods (which would hopefully reduce my file size?).  I imagine it will need an OFFSET formula within the SUMPRODUCT, which whilst it would increase volatility, would bring file size/calculation speed down which is what I'm hoping ultimately to acheive.

If you were able to write a formula that does all that I would be very grateful, however I realise you answered the question I originally asked so happy to award the points on that basis.

Here's what the formula currently looks like:
``````SUMPRODUCT(INDEX(\$A\$197:\$GJ\$197,COLUMNS(\$A\$197:\$GJ\$197)+1-M\$192):\$GJ\$197,COHORT!\$V12:V12)
``````

Many thanks
Brian
0

Author Closing Comment

ID: 34212316
Reduced volatility, not quite file size, but happy that this is an improvement on my original formula
0

## Featured Post

Question has a verified solution.

If you are experiencing a similar issue, please ask a related question

Do you use a spreadsheet like Microsoft's Excel?  Have you ever wanted to link out to a non excel file on your computer or network drive?  This is the way I found to do it!
This article describes how you can use Custom Document Properties to store settings and other information in your workbook so that they will be available the next time you open the workbook.