I have a website with a contact email address of email@example.com that goes to two address on our exchange server, firstname.lastname@example.org and email@example.com. The website is hosted outside and there is no login for the info@abc account, it's just a simple forward.
When Terry or Heather hit reply then their Outlook addresses are sent rather then the @info address.
I looked into web forwarding from the Internet but it requires a login field for example forwarding from a Gmail account. But this is a different scenario. We are using Outlook 2007.