• Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 907
  • Last Modified:

Exchange and PTR records - Question

We run Exchange 2007 at our company.  One Exchange Oganization, with each division having at least a Hub/CA Exchange server at thier site. Our site is the primary location with MX records pointing to the A records that resolves to our mail gateway here. At the remote sites, they each route outbound mail through their Exchange server, but internal and received mail is all routed internally through our location here at the hub site.

We are moving to a MPLS WAN from our current VPN / multi IPS based WAN. We have had to work with each ISP to register PTR records to allow for reverse lookup's from those recipients who require this PTR record to be something other than blank or the generic arpa response.

With this migration we also acquired several large blocks of public IP's. We have our new provider advertising these IP's for us. However they say that they cannot create the pointer records because they do not own the IP's. They just advertise them for us.

Here is the question..  because we own the IP's but our MPLS provider advertises them, does this mean we need to set up a public DNS server and create our own PRT records? Or do they STILL NEED to be set up on the ISP's end ???

OR is there any way to do this with Exchange? How does a reverse lookup determine what FQDN is associated to that IP? Does it get this by looking up who owns the IP or by who advertises the IP?







0
munisee
Asked:
munisee
2 Solutions
 
rnicolausCommented:
The ISP must setup the reverse DNS for you.  They technically "own" the IP.
0
 
muniseeAuthor Commented:
Ok, that is what I was struggling with. Sprint is saying that because we own the IP's, they can't set the PTR records for us.

Can I ask you do you have anything I can present as evidence to back this up? I have been in these back and forth struggles with providers before and I need to find something other than 'I was told' to back me up. Perhaps an RFC?






0
 
MichaelVHCommented:
Munisee;

where did you buy these IP's from? Normally the seller should be able to create the rDNS's for you.

Michael
0
Concerto Cloud for Software Providers & ISVs

Can Concerto Cloud Services help you focus on evolving your application offerings, while delivering the best cloud experience to your customers? From DevOps to revenue models and customer support, the answer is yes!

Learn how Concerto can help you.

 
Jon BrelieSystem ArchitectCommented:
Are you sure you don't have a PTR for your IP?

Have you tried a "ping -a xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx" for your public IP?  If there is any type of PTR record setup for the IP it will say

"Pinging <your PTR record here>"

Otherwise ask to be escalated or to speak to a DNS administrator.  If it's an ISP then *someone* there has to understand how DNS works.
0
 
rnicolausCommented:
The pertinent question might be then, who hosts your DNS?  If it's not Sprint, they could play that game.  But the ISP is the one who provisioned the IP block, correct? (Is that Sprint?) If so then they are responsible for the PTR records
0
 
muniseeAuthor Commented:
Turns out, and thank you for helping, that we are stuck in limbo with Arin with the tranfer of ownership for these new IP's we own. It's tricky in the sense that we had about 20,000 of them and since we are keeping just a small portion and gave the rest back to Arin, they need to re-allocate the new, smaller block to us and with all paperwork in line we should be able to register whatever NS we want with Sprint. Or even Sprint for that matter.

So, thank you for helping. I have to close this and move on. I learned quite a bit about DNS function at the IPS/Arin level through this project. What a great experience.
0
 
muniseeAuthor Commented:
You are were correct, however the two I accepted helped the most. It all came down to Arin and getting the IP's registered as belonging to my company, not the previous owner. However, the previous owner still had a couple name servers that the IP's were registered with through Arin. So we just fired them up and are using those until the red tape crap is done. Thanks!
0

Featured Post

Hire Technology Freelancers with Gigs

Work with freelancers specializing in everything from database administration to programming, who have proven themselves as experts in their field. Hire the best, collaborate easily, pay securely, and get projects done right.

Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now