Error: Expression must have a class type

Hello Everyone,

I am creating a template for a stack class and an binaryNode class.  I want to create a stack that will hold pointers to the binaryNode objects.  When I try to declare my stack object I receive the error Expression must have a class type.  Here is main code.

 
int main()
{
	Stack<BinaryNode<char>*> ptrStack();
	
   char equation[20];
   char* tokenPtr;

   cout<<"Please Enter In A Equation"<<endl;

   cin.getline(equation, '\n');
   
   tokenPtr = strtok(equation," ");

   while( tokenPtr != NULL)
   {
	   cout<<tokenPtr<<endl;
	   

	   if(*tokenPtr == '(' || *tokenPtr == ')' || *tokenPtr == '+' || *tokenPtr=='-')
	   {

		   cout<<"This Is A Operator"<<endl;
		   BinaryNode<char> newNode(*tokenPtr);

		   
	   }

	   else
	   {
		   BinaryNode<char> newNode(*tokenPtr);
		   ptrStack.push(newNode);
		   
	   }
	   tokenPtr = strtok(NULL, " ");

   }


	
	system("PAUSE");

	return 0;
}

Open in new window



Here is my constructor for stack

 
template<>
Stack<BinaryNode<char>*>::Stack()
{
	topOfStack = NULL;

}

Open in new window



Here is my constructor for binaryNode

 
template <class Object>
BinaryNode<Object>::BinaryNode( const Object & theElement,
                                BinaryNode *lt, BinaryNode *rt )
  : element( theElement ), left( lt ), right( rt )
{ 
}

Open in new window

brich744Asked:
Who is Participating?

Improve company productivity with a Business Account.Sign Up

x
 
jkrConnect With a Mentor Commented:
Ah.... you have a

      Stack<BinaryNode<char>*> ptrStack;

and are trying to 'push()' a

         BinaryNode<char> newNode(*tokenPtr);

Shouldn't that more be like the following?
int main()
{
	Stack<BinaryNode<char> > ptrStack;
	
   char equation[20];
   char* tokenPtr;

   cout<<"Please Enter In A Equation"<<endl;

   cin.getline(equation, '\n');
   
   tokenPtr = strtok(equation," ");

   while( tokenPtr != NULL)
   {
	   cout<<tokenPtr<<endl;
	   

	   if(*tokenPtr == '(' || *tokenPtr == ')' || *tokenPtr == '+' || *tokenPtr=='-')
	   {

		   cout<<"This Is A Operator"<<endl;
		   BinaryNode<char> newNode(*tokenPtr);

		   
	   }

	   else
	   {
		   BinaryNode<char> newNode(*tokenPtr);
		   ptrStack.push(newNode);
		   
	   }
	   tokenPtr = strtok(NULL, " ");

   }


	
	system("PAUSE");

	return 0;
}

Open in new window

0
 
Infinity08Commented:
What is the exact (and complete) error message that you get ? What line does it refer to ? Can you also post the class definitions for Stack and BinaryNode ?
0
 
brich744Author Commented:
Error:       1      IntelliSense: expression must have class type      c:\users\owner\documents\visual studio 2010\projects\binarytree\binarytree\main.cpp      45      6      BinaryTree

Main Class:

 
#include<iostream>
#include<string>
#include<cstring>
#include<sstream>
#include<iterator>
#include<vector>
#include<algorithm>

using namespace std;

#include"StackLi.h"
#include"BinaryTree.h"


int main()
{
	Stack<BinaryNode<char>*> ptrStack();
	
   char equation[20];
   char* tokenPtr;

   cout<<"Please Enter In A Equation"<<endl;

   cin.getline(equation, '\n');
   
   tokenPtr = strtok(equation," ");

   while( tokenPtr != NULL)
   {
	   cout<<tokenPtr<<endl;
	   

	   if(*tokenPtr == '(' || *tokenPtr == ')' || *tokenPtr == '+' || *tokenPtr=='-')
	   {

		   cout<<"This Is A Operator"<<endl;
		   BinaryNode<char> newNode(*tokenPtr);

		   
	   }

	   else
	   {
		   BinaryNode<char> newNode(*tokenPtr);
		   ptrStack.push(newNode);
		   
	   }
	   tokenPtr = strtok(NULL, " ");

   }


	
	system("PAUSE");

	return 0;
}

Open in new window


Stack Class:

 
#ifndef STACKLI_H_
#define STACKLI_H_

#include <stdlib.h>

using namespace std;

#include"BinaryTree.h"
//#include "Except.h"


// Stack class -- linked list implementation.
//
// CONSTRUCTION: with no parameters.
//
// ******************PUBLIC OPERATIONS*********************
// void push( x )        --> Insert x
// void pop( )           --> Remove most recently inserted item
// Object top( )         --> Return most recently inserted item
// Object topAndPop( )   --> Return and remove most recently inserted item
// bool isEmpty( )       --> Return true if empty; else false
// void makeEmpty( )     --> Remove all items
// ******************ERRORS********************************
// UnderflowException thrown as needed.

template <class Object>
class Stack
{
  public:
    Stack( );
    Stack( const Stack & );
	Stack();
    ~Stack( );

    bool isEmpty( ) const;
    const Object & top( ) const;

    void makeEmpty( );
    void pop( );
    void push( const Object & );
    Object topAndPop( );

    const Stack & operator=( const Stack & );

  private:
    struct ListNode
    {
        Object    element;
        ListNode *next;

        ListNode( const Object & theElement, ListNode * n = NULL )
          : element( theElement ), next( n ) { }
    };

    ListNode *topOfStack;
};

//#include "StackLi.cpp"


// Construct the stack.
template <class Object>
Stack<Object>::Stack( )
{
    topOfStack = NULL;
}

// Copy constructor.
template <class Object>
Stack<Object>::Stack( const Stack<Object> & rhs )
{
    topOfStack = NULL;
    *this = rhs;
}


template<>
Stack<BinaryNode<char>*>::Stack()
{
	topOfStack = NULL;

}

// Destructor.
template <class Object>
Stack<Object>::~Stack( )
{
    makeEmpty( );
}

// Test if the stack is logically empty.
// Return true if empty, false, otherwise.
template <class Object>
bool Stack<Object>::isEmpty( ) const
{
    return topOfStack == NULL;
}

// Make the stack logically empty.
template <class Object>
void Stack<Object>::makeEmpty( )
{
    while( !isEmpty( ) )
        pop( );
}

// Return the most recently inserted item in the stack.
// or throw an UnderflowException if empty.
template <class Object>
const Object & Stack<Object>::top( ) const
{
    if( isEmpty( ) )
        throw UnderflowException( );
    return topOfStack->element;
}

// Remove the most recently inserted item from the stack.
// Throw Underflow if the stack is empty.
template <class Object>
void Stack<Object>::pop( )
{
    if( isEmpty( ) )
        throw UnderflowException( );

    ListNode *oldTop = topOfStack;
    topOfStack = topOfStack->next;
    delete oldTop;
}

// Return and remove the most recently inserted item
// from the stack.
template <class Object>
Object Stack<Object>::topAndPop( )
{
    Object topItem = top( );
    pop( );
    return topItem;
}

// Insert x into the stack.
template <class Object>
void Stack<Object>::push( const Object & x )
{
    topOfStack = new ListNode( x, topOfStack );
}

// Deep copy.
template <class Object>
const Stack<Object> & Stack<Object>::operator=( const Stack<Object> & rhs )
{
    if( this != &rhs )
    {
        makeEmpty( );
        if( rhs.isEmpty( ) )
            return *this;

        ListNode *rptr = rhs.topOfStack;
        ListNode *ptr  = new ListNode( rptr->element );
        topOfStack = ptr;

        for( rptr = rptr->next; rptr != NULL; rptr = rptr->next )
            ptr = ptr->next = new ListNode( rptr->element );
    }
    return *this;
}



#endif

Open in new window


BinaryNode Class:

 
#ifndef BINARYTREE_H_
#define BINARYTREE_H_

#include <stdlib.h>

template <class Object>
class BinaryTree;

// BinaryNode class; stores a node in a tree.
//
// CONSTRUCTION: with (a) no parameters, or (b) an Object,
//     or (c) an Object, left pointer, and right pointer.
//
// *******************PUBLIC OPERATIONS**********************
// int size( )            --> Return size of subtree at node
// int height( )          --> Return height of subtree at node
// void printPostOrder( ) --> Print a postorder tree traversal
// void printInOrder( )   --> Print an inorder tree traversal
// void printPreOrder( )  --> Print a preorder tree traversal
// BinaryNode * duplicate( )    --> Return a duplicate tree
// *******************ERRORS*********************************
// None.

template <class Object>
class BinaryNode
{
  public:
    BinaryNode( const Object & theElement = Object( ),
                BinaryNode *lt = NULL, BinaryNode *rt = NULL );

    static int size( BinaryNode *t );
    static int height( BinaryNode *t );

    void printPreOrder( ) const;
    void printPostOrder( ) const;
    void printInOrder( ) const;

    BinaryNode *duplicate( ) const;

  public:   // To keep things simple
    Object      element;
    BinaryNode *left;
    BinaryNode *right;
};

template <class Object>
class TreeIterator;


// BinaryTree class; stores a binary tree.
//
// CONSTRUCTION: with (a) no parameters or (b) an object to
//    be placed in the root of a one-element tree.
//
// *******************PUBLIC OPERATIONS**********************
// Various tree traversals, size, height, isEmpty, makeEmpty.
// Also, the following tricky method:
// void merge( Object root, BinaryTree t1, BinaryTree t2 )
//                        --> Construct a new tree
// *******************ERRORS*********************************
// Error message printed for illegal merges.

template <class Object>
class BinaryTree
{
  public:
    BinaryTree( ) : root( NULL ) { }
    BinaryTree( const Object & rootItem )
      : root( new Node( rootItem ) ) { }
    BinaryTree( const BinaryTree & rhs )
      : root( NULL ) { *this = rhs; }

    ~BinaryTree( )
      { makeEmpty( ); }

    const BinaryTree & operator= ( const BinaryTree & rhs );

      // Recursive traversals, with printing
    void printPreOrder( ) const
      { if( root != NULL ) root->printPreOrder( ); }    
    void printInOrder( ) const
      { if( root != NULL ) root->printInOrder( ); }    
    void printPostOrder( ) const
      { if( root != NULL ) root->printPostOrder( ); }    
     
    void makeEmpty( )
      { makeEmpty( root ); } 
    bool isEmpty( ) const
      { return root == NULL; }

      // Combine t1 and t2
    void merge( const Object & rootItem, BinaryTree & t1, BinaryTree & t2 );

    int size( ) const
      { return Node::size( root ); }
    int height( ) const
      { return Node::height( root ); }
    
  private:
    typedef BinaryNode<Object> Node;
    Node *root;

    friend class TreeIterator<Object>;
    void makeEmpty( BinaryNode<Object> * & t );
};

// Constructor.
template <class Object>
BinaryNode<Object>::BinaryNode( const Object & theElement,
                                BinaryNode *lt, BinaryNode *rt )
  : element( theElement ), left( lt ), right( rt )
{ 
}

// Return size of tree rooted at t.
template <class Object>
int BinaryNode<Object>::size( BinaryNode<Object> * t )
{
    if( t == NULL )
        return 0;
    else
        return 1 + size( t->left ) + size( t->right );
}

#define max MAX

template <class Comparable>
Comparable max( const Comparable & a, const Comparable & b )
{
    return a > b ? a : b;
}

// Return height of tree rooted at t.
template <class Object>
int BinaryNode<Object>::height( BinaryNode<Object> * t )
{
    if( t == NULL )
        return -1;
    else
        return 1 + max( height( t->left ), height( t->right ) );
}

#undef max

// Print the tree rooted at current node using preorder traversal.
template <class Object>
void BinaryNode<Object>::printPreOrder( ) const
{
    cout << element << endl;                  // Node
    if( left != NULL )
        left->printPreOrder( );               // Left
    if( right != NULL )
        right->printPreOrder( );              // Right
}

// Print the tree rooted at current node using postorder traversal.
template <class Object>
void BinaryNode<Object>::printPostOrder( ) const
{
    if( left != NULL )                        // Left
        left->printPostOrder( );
    if( right != NULL )                       // Right
        right->printPostOrder( );
    cout << element << endl;                  // Node
}

// Print the tree rooted at current node using inorder traversal.
template <class Object>
void BinaryNode<Object>::printInOrder( ) const
{
    if( left != NULL )                        // Left
        left->printInOrder( );
    cout << element << endl;                  // Node
    if( right != NULL )
        right->printInOrder( );               // Right
}

// Return a pointer to a node that is the root of a
// duplicate of the tree rooted at the current node.
template <class Object>
BinaryNode<Object> * BinaryNode<Object>::duplicate( ) const
{
    BinaryNode<Object> *root =
                         new BinaryNode<Object>( element );

    if( left != NULL )            // If there's a left subtree
        root->left = left->duplicate( );   // Duplicate; attach
    if( right != NULL )           // If there's a right subtree
        root->right = right->duplicate( ); // Duplicate; attach

    return root;                     // Return resulting tree
}

// Deep copy.
template <class Object>
const BinaryTree<Object> &
BinaryTree<Object>::operator= ( const BinaryTree<Object> & rhs )
{
    if( this != &rhs )
    {
        makeEmpty( );
        if( rhs.root != NULL )
            root = rhs.root->duplicate( );
    }

    return *this;
}

// Merge routine for BinaryTree class.
// Forms a new tree from rootItem, t1 and t2.
// Does not allow t1 and t2 to be the same.
// Correctly handles other aliasing conditions.
template <class Object>
void BinaryTree<Object>::merge( const Object &  rootItem,
                         BinaryTree<Object> & t1, BinaryTree<Object> & t2 )
{
    if( t1.root == t2.root && t1.root != NULL )
    { 
        cerr << "Cannot merge a tree with itself; merge aborted." << endl;
        return;
    }

    Node *oldRoot = root;   // Save old root

      // Allocate new node
    root = new Node( rootItem, t1.root, t2.root );

      // Deallocate nodes in the original tree
    if( this != &t1 && this != &t2 )
        makeEmpty( oldRoot );

      // Ensure that every node is in one tree
    if( this != &t1 )
        t1.root = NULL;
    if( this != &t2 )
        t2.root = NULL;
}

// Make tree rooted at t empty, freeing nodes, and setting t to NULL.
template <class Object>
void BinaryTree<Object>::makeEmpty( BinaryNode<Object> * & t )
{
    if( t != NULL )
    {
        makeEmpty( t->left );
        makeEmpty( t->right );
        delete t;
        t = NULL;
    }
}
#endif

Open in new window

0
What Kind of Coding Program is Right for You?

There are many ways to learn to code these days. From coding bootcamps like Flatiron School to online courses to totally free beginner resources. The best way to learn to code depends on many factors, but the most important one is you. See what course is best for you.

 
Infinity08Commented:
>> Error:       1      IntelliSense: expression must have class type      c:\users\owner\documents\visual studio 2010\projects\binarytree\binarytree\main.cpp      45      6      BinaryTree

And which line does that error refer to ?
0
 
brich744Author Commented:
Line 45: In Main Class

 ptrStack.push(newNode);
0
 
jkrCommented:
To address that, change

      Stack<BinaryNode<char>*> ptrStack();

to

      Stack<BinaryNode<char>*> ptrStack;

Then you will face the next error, which is

error C2664: 'Stack<Object>::push' : cannot convert parameter
1 from 'BinaryNode<Object>' to 'BinaryNode<Object> &'

(scratching my head regarding this one at the moment ;o)
0
 
Infinity08Connect With a Mentor Commented:
Ah, I see. The mention of BinaryTree in the error message was a bit confusing, because BinaryTree was never used in main.

But the problem is that :

>>       Stack<BinaryNode<char>*> ptrStack();

defines ptrStack as a function that takes no arguments, and returns a Stack<BinaryNode<char>*>.

Use this instead in order not to confuse the compiler :

        Stack<BinaryNode<char>*> ptrStack = Stack<BinaryNode<char>*>();

or just :

        Stack<BinaryNode<char>*> ptrStack;
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.