Solved

weka nnge algorithm problem

Posted on 2011-03-03
2
520 Views
Last Modified: 2012-06-27
I try to use NNGE algorithm.
When I input this data (one column per day, and range of hours 0-4 for testing just now)

@relation pattern
@attribute hour real

@attribute class {open,closed}

@data
0,closed
1,closed
2,closed
3,closed
4,closed

0,closed
1,closed
2,closed
3,closed
4,closed

I get the correct result class closed IF : 0.0<=hour<=4.0  (10)

If I input this data:

@relation pattern
@attribute hour real

@attribute class {open,closed}

@data
0,closed
1,closed
2,closed
3,closed
4,closed

0,closed
1,open
2,closed
3,closed
4,closed

I get the correct results as well

class closed IF : 2.0<=hour<=4.0  (6)
      class open IF : hour=1.0  (1)
      class closed IF : hour=0.0  (2)

But when I input this data

@relation pattern
@attribute hour real

@attribute class {open,closed}

@data
0,closed
1,open
2,closed
3,closed
4,closed

0,closed
1,closed
2,closed
3,closed
4,closed

Weka doesn't pick up the open time in day 1 it only picks up open days from the very last day.

class closed IF : 2.0<=hour<=4.0  (6)
      class closed IF : 0.0<=hour<=1.0  (3)

Why is this happening? I the layout of the data is wrong but how to sort it out.
0
Comment
Question by:chudyksg
2 Comments
 
LVL 2

Accepted Solution

by:
mtgradwell earned 500 total points
ID: 36299734
I'm not really a Weka expert, having only used it a little, but here's what I reckon is happening.

In the first example, the door was closed all the time. Based on this information, Weka using the NNGE algorithm guesses that the door will be closed all the time in the future, too. If it is tested using the same information that it was trained on then we find that Weka gets it right, ten times out of ten. So far, so good.
Correctly Classified Instances          10              100      %
Incorrectly Classified Instances         0                0      %

In the second example, the door is closed most of the time, but on day two it is open at one o'clock. Weka guesses that in future the door will be closed at 0 and 2 and 3 and 4 o'clock, for obvious reasons, but for one o'clock it faces a dilemma. It can guess "open" or "closed", but either guess is as likely to be wrong as right. It's a coin toss. Weka guesses "open", maybe because that's the most recent information, and recent information is more likely to be correct than old information.

In this case, If Weka is tested using the same information that it was trained on then we find that it gets it right nine times out of ten, which is about as good as can be hoped for:
Correctly Classified Instances           9               90      %
Incorrectly Classified Instances         1               10      %

In the third example, again the door is closed most of the time but again Weka faces a dilemma at one o'clock. This time it guesses "closed".
Correctly Classified Instances           9               90      %
Incorrectly Classified Instances         1               10      %

Weka does exactly as well in the third example as it did in the second, so why would you say that it got it right  in the second example but wrong in the third?
0

Featured Post

Maximize Your Threat Intelligence Reporting

Reporting is one of the most important and least talked about aspects of a world-class threat intelligence program. Here’s how to do it right.

Join & Write a Comment

A short article about a problem I had getting the GPS LocationListener working.
A short article about problems I had with the new location API and permissions in Marshmallow
This video teaches viewers about errors in exception handling.
This tutorial explains how to use the VisualVM tool for the Java platform application. This video goes into detail on the Threads, Sampler, and Profiler tabs.

747 members asked questions and received personalized solutions in the past 7 days.

Join the community of 500,000 technology professionals and ask your questions.

Join & Ask a Question

Need Help in Real-Time?

Connect with top rated Experts

8 Experts available now in Live!

Get 1:1 Help Now