Load CSV file with Commas within its columns into SQL server using SSIS


I have a CSV file in the following format

Name,       Tournament ,                       Code ,    Cash
"a",         "bit $1,000, express",             "f"  ,      $1000
"n",         "Tour",hold $10",                     "y" ,       $10

so here  "bit $1,000express"   and   "Tour",hold $10"  are actually in the Tournament coloumn as you can see from my illustration. This is exactly how most of the data in my file is represented.

So when I use SSIS to try to load this CSV file into my SQL 2008 database, the middle column is truncated at the commas that occur with the text of the column into separate columns .

so here "000", and "express" will be moved to next two columns and  "hold $10" will be in the next columns after its rightful column.

Does anyone know how to solve this kind of problem in SSIS .
By the way its a large CSV file with many columns .

Who is Participating?

Improve company productivity with a Business Account.Sign Up

Paul MacDonaldConnect With a Mentor Director, Information SystemsCommented:
Is this representative of all the data in the CSV file?  I ask because you could replace all the ",  (quote-comma-space) combinations with tabs, then delete the remaining quotes.  That might mess up your "Tour", hold $10" item, but maybe not.

Otherwise, if you have the original dataset, you could export it as tab-delimited and then inport it that way.
marvo2010Author Commented:
Yeah Thats the main issue really. There are commas within the columns , and the column delimiter is also comma, so where ever the SSIS see a comma, it basically separates the column into a separate column. I am wondering if anyone has econutered this kind of problem and how they were able to solve it.
marvo2010Author Commented:
If I export it as a Tab separated CSV file , will it not still insert Tabs where ever it sees commas just like SSIS is separating data into columns based on the columns.
A proven path to a career in data science

At Springboard, we know how to get you a job in data science. With Springboard’s Data Science Career Track, you’ll master data science  with a curriculum built by industry experts. You’ll work on real projects, and get 1-on-1 mentorship from a data scientist.

If you can replace the , separator with another character, say ; leaving the internal commas in each column intact when perhaps a small .NET app could perform the necessary formatting for you.  You could:

1) read the rows into arrays specifying the separation character (;)
2) find and replace the remaining commas (inside each column) to a more friendly character or even remove them
3) then write out the line as comma separated so its ready to import as CSV while having replaced the internal commas so they dont cause these issues.

If this sounds like a solution to you I can post some test code in VB.NET...
marvo2010Author Commented:
yes this certainly sounds like a solution . Lets test the VB code using a Script task in SSIS.

Paul MacDonaldDirector, Information SystemsCommented:
Yes, that was what I was driving at.  If you can replace the actual column delimiters at the export source, that would be ideal.  I was illustrating how you could change the commas to tabs if you don't have the original source data (can't export it again).  And no, when you import the data into SSIS, you should be allowed to indicate the data is tab-delimited rather than comma-delimited and SQL Server should consume it just fine.
If you can replace the column delimiters to a tab then it sounds as though paulmacd's solution would be easiest because you'll have no middlware and be able to import directly to SQL Server.  If this for some reason isnt possible and your after some VB code to do some re-formatting, then please post and I'll supply some.
marvo2010Author Commented:
yeah we have the files already and needs to load them rightly now. so if you can supply the vb code and how to apply it , that will be great
This is made up from some bits and peices and untested for your purpose but should get you started with the functionality, maybe best in a console app to quickly run the routine against the file:
Dim m_source As String()   ' create an array to read the rows
m_source = System.IO.File.ReadAllLines("C:\Input.csv")   ' array of source file lines
Dim Output As New System.IO.StreamWriter("C:\Output.csv")   ' file to output

For x = 1 To m_source.Length - 1   ' iterate down source file rows (starting from 1 - row after headers)
  Dim DataToWrite() As String = m_source(x).Split(";"c)   ' data array or current row split with a ;
  DataToWrite = DataToWrite.Replace(",", "_")   ' replace the internal comma with something
  DataToWrite = DataToWrite.Replace(";", ",")   ' now swap the ; separator back to a , for CSV compatibility
  Output.WriteLine(DataToWrite)   ' write the output back out


Open in new window

The way I have preferred getting around this issue is by loading the entire record into a single column staging table and then performing the delimited extraction using T-SQL CHARINDEX and SUBSTRING functions to reach the target table

This will at least avoid maintaining an external .net module and keep the process integrated into your DTSX package.

Just a thought
marvo2010Author Commented:
Hello Seenall,

Pls do have a step by step solution of how to implmement your suggested solution without an external .Net module like u said using T-SQL Charindex and SUBSTRING. I will appreciate to have a look.

marvo2010Author Commented:
Thanks Guys,

I have been able to potentially solve this problem.Converting the files to Tab delimited  worked perfectly. I ve  got a little solution that can actually convert the files to Tab delimited from folder to folder and then I need to Iterate through the files using SSIS and load to my staging table .
Microsoft have not got a solution for this from what I have learnt during this process but the "NEVER SAY NEVER ATTITUDE" always gets the job done no matter what. I love never to quit.

Thanks guys
Guy Hengel [angelIII / a3]Billing EngineerCommented:
This question has been classified as abandoned and is closed as part of the Cleanup Program. See the recommendation for more details.
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.