Sonicwall VOIP compatibility and throughput

I'd like to connect to a new hosted VOIP provider, but I'm not sure if my SonicWall can handle it.  I currently have a TZ-190 with the Enhanced OS.

I'm planning to start with 10 users making calls.  The vendor says I need 100 Kb per call, so that should be 1 Mb bandwidth I need.  I'd eventually like to ramp this up to 80 concurrent calls, so 8-10 Mb.  I also need to mix in some light data traffic from those 80 users plus another 10 back office people who are heavy Internet users.

I'm currently running A/V and Intrusion detection on everything coming from the WAN.

Can the TZ-190 handle this type of VOIP/SIP traffic at all?  Will it work with up to 80 concurrent calls going on plus some other general Internet usage?
LVL 1
s_sykesAsked:
Who is Participating?
 
DrDamnitConnect With a Mentor Commented:
The TZ-190 appears to handle voip just fine. See this doc:

http://www.sonicwall.com/downloads/Configuring_VoIP_for_SonicOS_Enhanced.pdf

100Kb per call is a little much. You actually need 64kbps + about 11% overhead, which is 71kbs. But, for calculations, 100Kbps per call is a better calcualtion. It's better to be conservative.

Your next issue is QoS. Sure... you can fit 10 calls at 100kbps per call, but do you have good QoS? This is an ISP issue. Does the ISP do QoS for UDP / VOIP traffic?

The SonicWall can QoS the inbound and outbound traffic so that email downloads don't kill your calls, but if you don't have control over the QoS from your provider then you need a fat pipe (I have Comcast with 50Mbps down and 20Mbps up, and never have a problem) or you need a provider that guarantees QoS.

The SonicWall's processor should be able to handle 80 concurrent calls, however, if it cannot, you'll end up upgrading to one that can or going to a BSD based open source firewall like Monowall where you can use desktop grade computing power to run the firewall.
0
 
s_sykesAuthor Commented:
Yep - I was figuring a 100 kbps to try to account for my people being on a call and some light surfing. I'm a little doubtful it can handle 80 concurrent calls, but I'm not sure how you figure that out ahead of time.
0
 
DrDamnitCommented:
I think your bandwidth will run out before the SonicWall poops out. :-)
0
Managing Security & Risk at the Speed of Business

Gartner Research VP, Neil McDonald & AlgoSec CTO, Prof. Avishai Wool, discuss the business-driven approach to automated security policy management, its benefits and how to align security policy management with business processes to address today's security challenges.

 
s_sykesAuthor Commented:
HA!  Cool - thanks!
0
 
s_sykesAuthor Commented:
Oh  - meant to ask - are you running a bunch of VOIP calls through your Comcast connection?  How many?
0
 
DrDamnitCommented:
I have 8-10 concurrent calls running through Comcast. Never a problem. You just have to engineer it right.

Also... the size of my pipe is huge for VOIP calls. It's like throwing a hotdog down a hallway.
0
 
s_sykesAuthor Commented:
Cool - I'm on a 5 MB symmetrical connection with Cavalier right now, but I've got an appt with a friend at Comcast business next week.
0
 
DrDamnitCommented:
Beware: Comcast Business may or may not perform like Cavalier's 5/5 product. Get references from the Comcast Business guy from people IN YOUR AREA.

Where I am in northern Atlanta, comcast owns the market. They rule. THey rock. I bow at their awesomeness.

In midtown and the east part of Atlanta, however, they suck. Big time. Their modems make a sucking sound when illuminated. They are constantly down.

This is because comcast acquires smaller companies with sometimes inferior networks.

Cavalier, CBeyond, etc... put down all their own networks. So, quality is ensured.

Before you buy, ask around.
0
 
s_sykesAuthor Commented:
Yep - Cavalier has been rock solid the past few years.  We've got data and 10 back office phones on it and never miss a beat.  Paetech just bought them out though so changes are coming.

My Comcast contact here in Richmond, VA claims they have a ton of available fiber in our area, but I don't know anyone that is actually using it in their business.
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.