Best Backup Strategy for Windows servers and NetApp Filer Data (NDMP, CIFS, etc.)

sweetseater
sweetseater used Ask the Experts™
on
I'm in the process of setting up a new FAS2020 to handle a small firm's CIFS data. Currently we have 3 W2003 servers and 1 2008 Citix server. We are running Exchange 2003, SQL Server 2005 and backing up to a Dell PowerVault 124T (LTO-3) with Symantec BackupExec 12.5d. The PowerVault 124T is connected directly to the Symantec Media Server.

I can't get Symantec BackupExec 12.5d to backup any CIFS data via a user-created shared (which isn't the best performing option, anyway). I've also recently learned that if we use NDMP I can only restore NDMP data to an identical device.

So, in the case of a real disaster, like a blown up server room or fire or building, I would need to get my hands on a FAS2020 ASAP to use the data from our off-site backup tapes.

I know need to look at other options. Is there technology to restore NDMP-backed up data to a none NDMP device? Can I emulate an NDMP device with software on a Windows server?

It looks like BakBone's NetVault: Backup is a better product for supporting the NetApp Filer. Could I confidently use it to support backing  up Exchange, active directory and system states?

We'll also be moving to Exchange 2010, SQL Server 2008 R2, VMWare vSphere (also hosted on the filer) in the coming year and we do have software assurance on BackupExec, so we could upgrade to 2010. However, before I purchase the NDMP license, I need to know how I will deal with this issue.

This is a small business with 50 users and limited financial resources.

Thoughts? I must be missing something,
Comment
Watch Question

Do more with

Expert Office
EXPERT OFFICE® is a registered trademark of EXPERTS EXCHANGE®
Senior IT Advisor
Top Expert 2008
Commented:
can't get Symantec BackupExec 12.5d to backup any CIFS data via a user-created shared (which isn't the best performing option, anyway). I've also recently learned that if we use NDMP I can only restore NDMP data to an identical device.


--This is correct, you can only restore to Netapp NDMP if backing up using Netapp NDMP, I learned the hardware.


So, in the case of a real disaster, like a blown up server room or fire or building, I would need to get my hands on a FAS2020 ASAP to use the data from our off-site backup tapes.

--With trial and error you may be able to get CIFS backup working using Windows shares.  Backing up volumes are than CIFS via NDMP may lead to backing up non quiesced data depending on how you do it

I know need to look at other options. Is there technology to restore NDMP-backed up data to a none NDMP device? Can I emulate an NDMP device with software on a Windows server?

--For volumes other than CIFS we typically backup using backup exec vmware agent, exchange agent, etc..  If we have room on tape then we use NDMP to backup the first _recent snapshot so that it's backing quiesced data (if you're using snapmanager for VI, SQL, Exchange)

It looks like BakBone's NetVault: Backup is a better product for supporting the NetApp Filer. Could I confidently use it to support backing  up Exchange, active directory and system states?

--Take a look at syncsort

http://www.netapp.com/us/solutions/infrastructure/data-protection/backup-recovery/netapp-syncsort-integrated-backup.html

We'll also be moving to Exchange 2010, SQL Server 2008 R2, VMWare vSphere (also hosted on the filer) in the coming year and we do have software assurance on BackupExec, so we could upgrade to 2010. However, before I purchase the NDMP license, I need to know how I will deal with this issue.

--Backup Exec 2010 has a VMWAre Backup Agent that is decent and Exchange as well (will reach into the VM to get data).  Try using the NDMP agent in your backup exec 12.5, you should have 60 day eval

Typically we use NDMP for CIFS and backup execc for everything else.  Some customers use quest vranger or veeam for virtual machine backups

This is a small business with 50 users and limited financial resources.

Do more with

Expert Office
Submit tech questions to Ask the Experts™ at any time to receive solutions, advice, and new ideas from leading industry professionals.

Start 7-Day Free Trial