robw24
asked on
Trouble adding a second DHCP scope
Using Windows 2003 active directory server. The network is 10.1.0.0/23. Existing DHCP scope is 10.1.0.1-10.1.0.254/23. Would like to add a second scope to support WIFI clients. Tried adding second scope of 10.1.1.1-10.1.1.254/23, but I keep getting a message saying it conflicts or something. How can I do this properly?
Additionally, instead of adding another scope, why not just increase the scope you have from the end IP address range being at 10.1.0.254 to being at 10.1.1.254 instead?
Hope this helps.
Hope this helps.
ASKER
"The address range and scope conflicts with an existing scope.". I am actually trying to add just 10.1.1.160-10.1.1.220/23
I would consider expanding the original scope, but really would like to know why I can't add a second scope. And if I did expand the scope, how do I get just WIFI clients to use the 10.1.1.x range?
I would consider expanding the original scope, but really would like to know why I can't add a second scope. And if I did expand the scope, how do I get just WIFI clients to use the 10.1.1.x range?
ASKER CERTIFIED SOLUTION
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
edit on that last post...
'and so therefore considers a new scope as the same as the one you are creating'
....should read:
'and so therefore considers a new scope as the same as the one you have already created'
'and so therefore considers a new scope as the same as the one you are creating'
....should read:
'and so therefore considers a new scope as the same as the one you have already created'
ASKER
Well that makes sense about the new scope being the same as the existing scope. Your partially right about DHCP not caring, however I was going to play around with optional DHCP parameters such as vendor class, which is supposed to make it discriminate.
The router is not a bad idea, but I think it will add too much complexity, especially since I will be adding multiple access points spread through the company.
What I am thinking of trying now is to setup an additional DHCP server on the Radius Server/IAS server box.. I will configure it with the 10.1.1.x scope that I want, and I will program the wireless access points to forward DHCP requests to only this server. Not sure if I will need/want to authorize it in active directory or not, as I don't want non-wireless clients to obtain ip addresses from it.
The router is not a bad idea, but I think it will add too much complexity, especially since I will be adding multiple access points spread through the company.
What I am thinking of trying now is to setup an additional DHCP server on the Radius Server/IAS server box.. I will configure it with the 10.1.1.x scope that I want, and I will program the wireless access points to forward DHCP requests to only this server. Not sure if I will need/want to authorize it in active directory or not, as I don't want non-wireless clients to obtain ip addresses from it.
Excellent news, I'm glad that my advice seems to have answered your question.
I don't know why I’m only partially right though as I think you might be mistaken about the use of vendor classes. My understanding is that this is a method used for managing DHCP options assigned to clients identified by vendor type (i.e. operating system or hardware manufacturer) rather than what IP address they use - for example you might want a DHCP assigned Windows 2000 computer or a Cisco router to use another default gateway or use a different DNS server. Assigning their IP address is not something that is done within DHCP options. However - if you can put me right on this, then please let me know.
I'm also unsure on how you can forward DHCP requests as these requests are always broadcasted on the network - and broadcasts are received by everything on the same subnet. If you have 2 DHCP servers on the same subnet (which is what you are proposing), then either server will respond to a DHCP request and provide an IP address.
Again, I might be wrong on this if you find a way round this, so if your proposed solution above works, I'd be really interested on how you achieved this.
All the best, and good luck.
I don't know why I’m only partially right though as I think you might be mistaken about the use of vendor classes. My understanding is that this is a method used for managing DHCP options assigned to clients identified by vendor type (i.e. operating system or hardware manufacturer) rather than what IP address they use - for example you might want a DHCP assigned Windows 2000 computer or a Cisco router to use another default gateway or use a different DNS server. Assigning their IP address is not something that is done within DHCP options. However - if you can put me right on this, then please let me know.
I'm also unsure on how you can forward DHCP requests as these requests are always broadcasted on the network - and broadcasts are received by everything on the same subnet. If you have 2 DHCP servers on the same subnet (which is what you are proposing), then either server will respond to a DHCP request and provide an IP address.
Again, I might be wrong on this if you find a way round this, so if your proposed solution above works, I'd be really interested on how you achieved this.
All the best, and good luck.
ASKER
You may indeed be right about the use of vendor class, I have not tinkered with that yet and I honestly don't remember some things like that learned years ago studying for MCSE.
As far as forwarding the DHCP requests, there is an option in the access point software to forward DHCP requests to whatever IP address I would like. So I imagine that instead of forwarding the DHCP broadcast from the wireless clients, the AP would drop it and forward/unicast it instead to a specific host.
I will let you know how it works out with the additional DHCP server.
As far as forwarding the DHCP requests, there is an option in the access point software to forward DHCP requests to whatever IP address I would like. So I imagine that instead of forwarding the DHCP broadcast from the wireless clients, the AP would drop it and forward/unicast it instead to a specific host.
I will let you know how it works out with the additional DHCP server.
SOLUTION
membership
This solution is only available to members.
To access this solution, you must be a member of Experts Exchange.
Are there any Static IP addresses assigned to the DHCP server that the range you are configuring conflicts with?
For example - the server IP address might be 10.1.1.1