Improve company productivity with a Business Account.Sign Up

x
  • Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 221
  • Last Modified:

Index & Match Formula

I'm trying to create a matrix where I can look up a value based on length of parts, diameter, and production hours. I've attached a sample of what I'm looking to do.

Columns M, N, & O are the variables I need to look up in the grid to the left. I need to find the match and then put that in column P.

I entered the first one in column P as an example.
Book2.xlsx
0
Lawrence Salvucci
Asked:
Lawrence Salvucci
1 Solution
 
barry houdiniCommented:
Ideally for this to work in the standard manner you need to reverse the order of the table in respect of G3:K3

I put in a new table in E16:K23 then you can use this formula in P2 copied down

=IF(N2>40,INDEX(G$22:K$23,MATCH(O2,E$22:E$23),MATCH(M2,G$16:K$16)),INDEX(G$17:K$20,MATCH(O2,E$17:E$20),MATCH(M2,G$16:K$16)))

You get #N/A error in P13 because size doesn't fall in any of the ranges

see attached

regards, barry
27323353.xlsx
0
 
kgerbChief EngineerCommented:
For a lookup like this you should really normalize your data.  You should have columns hours, min dia, max dia, min length, max length, and work center.  That's your "database".  At that point it becomes much easier to do multiple criteria searches on your data.  You can use a pivot table at that point too.  Do some googling for sumproduct lookups and you'll find a wealth if info.

Kyle
0
 
byundtCommented:
You need to watch out for pieces that are too thin or too thick for the limits in the table. The suggested formula handles the minimum constraint, but not the maximum. It needs another two rows of data in the lookup table for that feature.

Using VLOOKUP and MATCH, here is an alternative approach. You will need to refer to the sample workbook to understand the cell range references.
=IF(N2<40,VLOOKUP(O2,E$3:K$8,MATCH(M2,G$2:K$2)+2),VLOOKUP(O2,E$10:K$13,MATCH(M2,G$2:K$2)+2))

Book2Q27323353.xlsx
0
Get your problem seen by more experts

Be seen. Boost your question’s priority for more expert views and faster solutions

 
Lawrence SalvucciInformation Technology ManagerAuthor Commented:
@barryhoudini

I made a mistake on my sample file. If the production hours are greater than 40 but not in those 2 size ranges then it needs to look at the other 4 ranges and find the work center. The top 4 ranges should not be less than 40 hours. Those 4 ranges are for any amount of hours and only if the hours are greater than 40 and within those 2 ranges at the bottom should it look for the work center there. I hope this makes sense. I attached a new sample file with your formulas.
Sample-File.xls
0
 
byundtCommented:
Using the latest sample workbook, you might use a formula like:
=INDEX(G$17:K$23,IF(AND(N2>40,O2<F$23),MATCH(O2,E$22:E$23),MATCH(O2,E$17:E$20)),MATCH(M2,G$16:K$16))

I added a row for greater than 3" thickness
Sample-FileQ27323353.xls
0
 
Lawrence SalvucciInformation Technology ManagerAuthor Commented:
Thank you for the help. You have 2 formulas in your sample file, one in column P and one in Q. Which is the correct one?
0
 
Lawrence SalvucciInformation Technology ManagerAuthor Commented:
I don't believe it's working properly with either of those formulas. If you look at the one I highlighted in orange you will see why.
Copy-of-Sample-File.xls
0
 
Lawrence SalvucciInformation Technology ManagerAuthor Commented:
I figured it out. Here's the formula that I modified to fix the problem in my previous post:

INDEX(G$17:K$23,IF(AND(N13>40,O13<F$23,>E$22),MATCH(O13,E$22:E$23),MATCH(O13,E$17:E$20)),MATCH(M13,G$16:K$16))
0
 
Lawrence SalvucciInformation Technology ManagerAuthor Commented:
Thank you very much for your help!
0
 
byundtCommented:
For your problem situation, I needed to check the minimum thickness condition as well. I therefore suggest this revised formula:
=INDEX(G$17:K$23,IF(AND(N2>40,O2<=F$23,O2>=E$22),MATCH(O2,E$22:E$23)+5,MATCH(O2,E$17:E$20)),MATCH(M2,G$16:K$16))

The +5 in this formula shifts to the bottom part of the table, and I mistakenly left it out of my previously suggested formula. It is necessary, as you can see with inputs 67, 44 and .0625 (original formula returned 2051 but should have returned 2053-1).
0
 
Lawrence SalvucciInformation Technology ManagerAuthor Commented:
Can post the example file again so I can see what you mean?
0
 
byundtCommented:
Look at column R and row 15 in the sample file.
Sample-FileQ27323353.xls
0
 
Lawrence SalvucciInformation Technology ManagerAuthor Commented:
Got it, thank you. I understand your formula now. Thanks again...
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

Join & Write a Comment

Featured Post

Free Tool: Site Down Detector

Helpful to verify reports of your own downtime, or to double check a downed website you are trying to access.

One of a set of tools we are providing to everyone as a way of saying thank you for being a part of the community.

Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now