• Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 7717
  • Last Modified:

Watchguard "ICMP Policy" Denys ICMP.

I have a small network with multiple subnets connected to the Watchguard via a router.

For testing, I have created a duplicate network.

The "LAN" subnet is 10.255.20.0/24.  One machine on that subnet is @ .207.  The router interface is @ .5.

The "Firewall" subnet is 10.255.1.0/29.  The router interface is @ .2.  The XTM interface is at .1.  Another machine for testing is @ .3.

The XTM 23 has an "Internet" subnet.  The internet port for the XTM is @ .37 and the internet gateway for same is @ .33

The PC @ .3 on the firewall subnet can ping everything in both directions.

The PC @ .207 on the lan subnet can ping up to the internet @ .37 (XTM internet ip), but cannot ping .33.

The syslog shows "Process=firewall Disposition=Deny Policy=ICMP Packet Source IP=10.255.20.207 Destination IP=x.x.x.33 Source Interface=5-inside Destination Interface=0-ISP Source Port= Destination Port= Protocol=icmp"

But I can't find a firewall policy named "ICMP Packet".
Q1:  Where the heck is it?

I have tried creating firewall policies that permit everything to everywhere from everywhere and nothing works.  It always hits this "ICMP Packet" policy and presto, denied.
Q2:  Where do I place "something" to allow ICMP traffic from the other side of the router to the internet?

Rather frustrated.
-g
0
OuttaCyTE
Asked:
OuttaCyTE
  • 6
  • 3
1 Solution
 
BrianCommented:
ICMP is your Ping Policy.
The Ping Policy is usually set from Any-Trusted, Any-Optional to Any.
0
 
OuttaCyTEAuthor Commented:
In my firewall policies, I have no "policy name" with the name "ICMP Packet"

I do have one named Ping-in2out, type Ping, From Any, To Any, Port ICMP (Type:8, code: 255), PBR (blank), Application Control none

The above policy is (apparently) not getting matched and I think it should.  Instead I get a policy=ICMP Packet which is denying the packet.

-g
0
 
BrianCommented:
What do you have under Global Settings for the ICMP Error Handling. It appears it is not a Policy, but an internal setting in the Firewall that is causing it.
0
Evaluating UTMs? Here's what you need to know!

Evaluating a UTM appliance and vendor can prove to be an overwhelming exercise.  How can you make sure that you're getting the security that your organization needs without breaking the bank? Check out our UTM Buyer's Guide for more information on what you should be looking for!

 
OuttaCyTEAuthor Commented:
Washburnma,

Thank you for responding.

All of them are checked.

(unrelated but is there a way to turn off the webui timeout value?  Does the XTM 23 have an external console - I can't find a serial port but?)

-g
0
 
OuttaCyTEAuthor Commented:
More Info

I have another log entry adjacent to this one (before?) that is exactly the same except policy=Internal Policy

I'm assuming the Internal Policy is the inbuilt policy that denys everything.


I unchecked all of the Error handling options and tried again.  Failed same way.

-g
0
 
BrianCommented:
There is not a console port, but you can download the WatchGuard System Manager which is much easier to use than the web interface. I highly recommend you do. The log viewer is much better as well.

Can you post a screen shot of your log file to look through?
0
 
OuttaCyTEAuthor Commented:
Is there something that you would like to see?

The only lines in the log having something to do with this problem are the two that I have already documented.

I have set up a syslog server to capture info from the WatchGuard device.  It too only shows those two lines.  Since there isn't any other traffice going on, the log is pretty sparse except for occasional device comm and watchguard messages.

-g
0
 
OuttaCyTEAuthor Commented:
You aren't going to believe this.

The problem was because the license keys had not been installed.

I had reset the device to scratch and had not yet installed the keys because I didn't need any of the licensed services.

However it appears that, despite showing good, that some part of the device just won't work without that installed.

The WatchGuard technician (2nd level) noticed we didn't have license keys install and so tried it.  It started working for him so he had me try it from my machines and that did the trick.

Thanks for your efforts
-g
0
 
OuttaCyTEAuthor Commented:
WatchGuard supplied the answer.  See notes above
0

Featured Post

Will You Be GDPR Compliant by 5/28/2018?

GDPR? That's a regulation for the European Union. But, if you collect data from customers or employees within the EU, then you need to know about GDPR and make sure your organization is compliant by May 2018. Check out our preparation checklist to make sure you're on track today!

  • 6
  • 3
Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now