Avatar of ryan80
ryan80 asked on

Exchange 2010 distribution list and user routing - DC selected

I was having an issue with some email being delivered to some distribution groups. I started looking into the issue and found some interesting information.

A quick rundown of the environment. We have one forest with 2 domains. We currently have a mixed 2003 and 2010 Exchange environment, one 2003 server and one 2010 server. We currently have 3 sites.

Site 1 - All machines are part of domain.com (including several DCs for domain.com), with exception of one DC that is a DC for subdomain.domain.com.
Site 2 - All machines are in domain.com, and contains 2 DCs for domain.com
Site 3 - All machines are part of subdomain.domain.com, including 2 DCs for subdomain.domain.com

Now the issue that we were having was that some emails sent to this DL were received, some were not. I looked into this issue using message tracking. I found that all of the emails sent to this DL, DL1@domain.com, were being received by the 2010 server. However not all of the emails were being received by the members of this list. I found several messages sent to DL1@domain.com that failed to expand the user correctly, because instead of using the DC that was part of domain.com, it was using the DC that was part of subdomain.domain.com.

Now I found that DL1@domain.com was not a universal DL, and that seemed to be what was causing it to fail. Changing it to a Universal group now expands correctly even when it is expanded against the DC that is part of subdomain.domain.com.

Now after seeing this, I have a few questions about how this process is handled to make sure that I dont have further issues.

1. How does Exchange 2010 decide what DC to use? From what I can tell it just takes whatever DC responds first in the site that it is located in?

2. Will this cause any issues with users that are in domain.com, if it expanding or routing against the DC from subdomain.domain.com? (I am assuming that users and groups are handled differently because I dont see any issues with the users)

3. What is the best practice here? I realize now that I should probably convert all of my DLs to Universal groups, does this sound correct?

Any other recommendations or input about things that I may be missing?
ExchangeActive DirectoryEmail Servers

Avatar of undefined
Last Comment
Adam Brown

8/22/2022 - Mon
Adam Brown

For your AD design, you should not mix Domain Controllers from Different Domains in the same site. Move the DC for subdomain.domain.com in Site 1 to a new AD site or to the other subdomain.domain.com site.

1. That's pretty much how it works. You can configure the Domain Controllers so that either one or the other handles all or most of the traffic, but there isn't really a way to define which DC is used. This is by design.
2. This shouldn't be a problem if the AD Sites are setup properly as mentioned earlier.
3. Exchange Distribution groups in 2007/2010 should be universal, yes.

Why should I not mix domains within the same site? Sites are supposed to be physical representations of the domain. I have never seen anything recommending that multiple domains not be put in the same site. Not to doubt you, but do you have any documentation on this?
Adam Brown

Log in or sign up to see answer
Become an EE member today7-DAY FREE TRIAL
Members can start a 7-Day Free trial then enjoy unlimited access to the platform
Sign up - Free for 7 days
Learn why we charge membership fees
We get it - no one likes a content blocker. Take one extra minute and find out why we block content.
See how we're fighting big data
Not exactly the question you had in mind?
Sign up for an EE membership and get your own personalized solution. With an EE membership, you can ask unlimited troubleshooting, research, or opinion questions.
ask a question
All of life is about relationships, and EE has made a viirtual community a real community. It lifts everyone's boat
William Peck