question accessing file thru server

seem to have an issue with a 30 MB excel file stored on a file server running svr 2008. a few are able to open the file without issue, others open the file as a read only is very very slow. Not sure what is going on. the users trying to open the file are running XP svs pk 3 and this is something that has started in the last 20 days
columbiaGAsked:
Who is Participating?
 
SirjacksinurboxConnect With a Mentor Commented:
Well it's good that your desktop can handle this. The local test ruled out local issues.

I looked a little harder than I normally do and read a few more articles involving your issue, and I was wondering if you could go into your AV and tell me whether or not Norton has network drive scanning enabled. If it does, disable it and tell me whether or not that helps.

The reason I'm asking about the above is because Norton's ability to scan files coming to a local computer from the network may still interfere with this file, regardless of whether or not the file type is ignored.

If that still does not work, try the fixes suggested in this article: Files on Network Shares

Even though you have XP SP3, these setting may still be messed up or not set correctly for computers on your network.

Let me if you still need help.



P.S.: Do your installations of Office on your desktops have Office File Validation Add-In enabled?
0
 
Stephen McTigueAssistant Director of Information TechnologyCommented:
Have you checked the antivirus program settings on the PCs? It's possible the file is being scanned upon opening by the antivirus program. If this is the situation, change the settings to not scan .xls or .xlsx files.

Regards...
0
 
SirjacksinurboxCommented:
Also, make sure all users that have access to that file have the same access rights in AD (assuming that you want it that way).

Also, depending on the current load on your network, the speed of your networking, as well as the specs of each PC; it could some desktops aren't capable of handling that big of a file over the network. A 30MB excel file is quite a lot of data to crunch and cache.

What are the specs on these computers and what happens when you try and download a local copy and run the file from your computer?
0
Cloud Class® Course: Certified Penetration Testing

This CPTE Certified Penetration Testing Engineer course covers everything you need to know about becoming a Certified Penetration Testing Engineer. Career Path: Professional roles include Ethical Hackers, Security Consultants, System Administrators, and Chief Security Officers.

 
columbiaGAuthor Commented:
placing a copy on a local desktop, the same one i tried to open it thru the network and it took about 5 min, it opens in about 5 seconds.....
0
 
columbiaGAuthor Commented:
using symantec enterprise protection, went in and excluded that file on the server be from scanning....no difference still takes about 5 min to open the one on the server and 5 seconds the one on the desktop. The desktop we are using has 3GB of ram so don't believe we are looking at a local resource issue.
0
 
columbiaGAuthor Commented:
also trying this at night when no one is on the network, so utilization is very low
0
 
columbiaGAuthor Commented:
ok, after a bunch of testing, it appears that what is causing the issue is the office file validation tool. As long as it is installed, problem exists (regardless of the anti-virus state) take it out...works fine...opens in ~5 sec....thanks for the hint on what to try, Something needs to be sent to Microsoft about removing that update!!!!
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.