• Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 857
  • Last Modified:

Managed Switches and Degraded Ethernet Cable.

Is it true that managed Ethernet switches such as the DLink DGS-1210-24 are much more sensitive to damaged Ethernet cables than an un-managed switch would be?

I have an Ethernet network, Mostly Cat5E cabling, some Cat5 from 1997. This network works find when using 10/100 un-managed switches. I replaced the two existing Dell PowerConnect 2324 switches with two DLink DGS-1210-24 100/1000 switches. The switches have failed multiple times with broadcast storms, in one case causing a PC NIC on the LAN to fail.

Has anyone seen a similar scenario, where 10/100 switches will work fine but Gigabit Switches will fail?
0
dosmanix
Asked:
dosmanix
2 Solutions
 
Robert Sutton JrSenior Network ManagerCommented:
Can you post the errors from any of the ports in question? Spanning Tree prot? Cat5 will not cause "BROADcast storms" but port errors for simplexing mismatch or physical layer errors which is why I ask about "Spanning Tree".  Let us know.
0
 
mat1458Commented:
The only thing that comes to my mind is that older cables only were made with 4 cables instead of the 8 that fit into an RJ45 plug. That's not sufficient for gigabit, but this never leads to the symptoms you describe. Broadcast storms rather happen through misconfiguration or incorrect cabling in terms of building loops. See that you have Spanning-Tree or Rapid Spannin-Tree enabled to help to avoid switching loops.
0
 
Robert Sutton JrSenior Network ManagerCommented:
FWIW: I somewhat disagree with Mat from above in that any Cat5 rated or above will ALWAYS have 4pairs of wires equaling 8 individual wires that fit into any RJ-45 connector. The only difference may be the TIA standard of 568A or 568B. However, most devices now' a days have an auto-sensing feature on each port so this shouldn't be an issue but something to keep in mind if you have an aged or legacy device. Just wanted to add clarification to that from above reply. Furthermore, the Spanning Tree statement in my original reply is typically directly proportionate to broadcast storming.

Hope this helps.
0
How do you know if your security is working?

Protecting your business doesn’t have to mean sifting through endless alerts and notifications. With WatchGuard Total Security Suite, you can feel confident that your business is secure, meaning you can get back to the things that have been sitting on your to-do list.

 
dosmanixAuthor Commented:
All good thoughts, and I appreciate the comments. I'm pretty sure the issue is caused by a degraded cable and at some point I will test all the cables and verify. I'd like to direct us back to my original question though...

Is it true that managed Ethernet switches such as the DLink DGS-1210-24 are much more sensitive to damaged Ethernet cables than an un-managed switch would be?

Has anyone seen a similar scenario, where 10/100 switches will work fine but Gigabit Switches will fail?

The network runs fine when using 10/100 switches.
My DLink DGS-1210-24 switches fail in a broadcast storm, likely caused by a loop of some sort. I'm not trying to isolate the cause of the broadcast storm in this post though.

thanks - DosMannix
0
 
mat1458Commented:
>Is it true that managed Ethernet switches such as the DLink DGS-1210-24 are much more sensitive to damaged Ethernet cables than an un-managed switch would be?

No, it's not true. Managed and unmanaged only has to do with services that are available on the switch or not.

>Has anyone seen a similar scenario, where 10/100 switches will work fine but Gigabit Switches will fail?

I have not seen any scenario like this and I have seen the transition of 100eds of switches from 100 Mb to Gig (not all by the same manufacturers)
0
 
TimotiStDatacenter TechnicianCommented:
Managed/unmanaged is not an issue, but 10/100 versus Gig can be. Gig is more sensitive to bad cable and/or interference. You should use Cat5E for Gigabit.

While Cat5/5E/6/whatever cable has 4 pairs, some cabling contractors take the liberty to wire 2 wall jacks with 1 cable, to keep costs low... Although it's not a frequent thing, and can be spotted easily, especially on the patch panel side.

Tamas
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

Join & Write a Comment

Featured Post

Cloud Class® Course: Microsoft Azure 2017

Azure has a changed a lot since it was originally introduce by adding new services and features. Do you know everything you need to about Azure? This course will teach you about the Azure App Service, monitoring and application insights, DevOps, and Team Services.

Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now