Link to home
Avatar of mlagrange
mlagrangeFlag for United States of America

asked on

When to import data from Excel into Access, rather than link Access to Excel spreadsheet?

Hello - I am taking over an Access 2010 app that links to an Excel 2010 spreadsheet that is currently at 52,000 rows.

I have a gut feeling that it would better to just import this data into the back end accdb (it's the typical split db implementation), but I'd like to have something to hang my hat on if/when questioned.

Has anybody seen any white paper-type articles about when it makes sense to import, rather than link?

Thanks
Avatar of Dale Fye
Dale Fye
Flag of United States of America image

There are a number of reasons to link vs import.

What is the purpose of the Excel file?  How often does it change or have records added

Does your Access application need real time updates or near real time via your Access application.
Ditto what Dale said; there are pro's and con's to each and which you use depends on your needs.

If it comes down to either would suffice, then go with the simplest and simply link.

And of course the 3rd way is to work with Automation and read/write the spreadsheet directly with Excel.

Jim.
Avatar of mlagrange

ASKER

Great points - the spreadsheet is a SAP database query of expenditure transactions for fixed asset construction and maintenance projects. It is only run once a month, after the monthly close process. As such, there are no updates to it; it is display-only on the Access forms & reports.

I am re-working how the data is used in the application; the original developer had it rigged up so that the relevant fields of the query output was copied to another xls, linked to the Access front end, and a series of update queries were run to summarize and update the spend amount fields in the project records for prior & current year totals, monthly totals, etc.  I'm replacing all that with a single SELECT query that does all that roll-up hoo-hah, and just JOIN it to the project table when needed.  

I'm thinking, for 50K+ rows, indexes would be helpful.
ASKER CERTIFIED SOLUTION
Avatar of Dale Fye
Dale Fye
Flag of United States of America image

Blurred text
THIS SOLUTION IS ONLY AVAILABLE TO MEMBERS.
View this solution by signing up for a free trial.
Members can start a 7-Day free trial and enjoy unlimited access to the platform.
See Pricing Options
Start Free Trial
SOLUTION
THIS SOLUTION IS ONLY AVAILABLE TO MEMBERS.
View this solution by signing up for a free trial.
Members can start a 7-Day free trial and enjoy unlimited access to the platform.
Here is my take.

If there is some special functionality with the spreadsheet (Links to another sheet, Custom Functions, special data entry processes, ...etc)
Then it may be best to keep the data in Excel.
(Many member here also site that it is easier to Graph/Chart/Pivot in Excel)

There is always something to be said for keeping everything under one roof.
So if this is just a "list" (Customers, Orders, ...etc), ...then consider moving this to Access.

As you know, the ability to update Excel from Access has been removed for a while now.
Also note that you typically cannot link an .xlsx (XL 2007/2010)  file into a .mdb  format database.

"My users like Excel"
...A valid point...
IMHO, Access offers may advantages over Excel.
You can create an interface that feels and looks similar to the Excel "experience"

Finally consider what might happen if you had to upgrade the Back end to SQL Server...
I have seen all sorts of posts stating that you can "Link" Excel into SQL, but I have never tried any.

JeffCoachman
Thanks, guys