Watch and learn how ATEN provided a total control system solution including seamless switching matrix switch, HDBaseT extenders, PDU, lighting control to build an interactive eFuture classroom.
COURSE of the MONTH
8 days, 16 hours left to enrollBecome a Premium Member and unlock a new, free course in leading technologies each month.
Solved
Any way / software to check how long laptop battery can last without waiting for it to drain
Posted on 2012-12-24
My corporate office has one Lenovo X220 but nobody knows if it's
been used for how long by the previous owner. They also offer
Dell E6230 laptops.
I'm choosing between one of the two but first I need to know
how long the battery will last (as previous owner(s) had used them
before).
Q1:
Windows 7 power meter usually doesn't give a good gauge.
Is there any tool / software that I can install to gauge for the
laptop I'm going to choose/collect, how long the battery will
last on full charge?
Q2:
Assuming it's brand new standard battery (6 cell ?) for both
X220 & the Dell E6230, which of them would last longer?
been used for how long by the previous owner. They also offer
Dell E6230 laptops.
I'm choosing between one of the two but first I need to know
how long the battery will last (as previous owner(s) had used them
before).
Q1:
Windows 7 power meter usually doesn't give a good gauge.
Is there any tool / software that I can install to gauge for the
laptop I'm going to choose/collect, how long the battery will
last on full charge?
Q2:
Assuming it's brand new standard battery (6 cell ?) for both
X220 & the Dell E6230, which of them would last longer?
[X]
Welcome to Experts Exchange
Add your voice to the tech community where 5M+ people just like you are talking about what matters.
- Help others & share knowledge
- Earn cash & points
- Learn & ask questions
-
4
3
2- +5
16 Comments
Hi sunhux,
can you try Battery Eater is a free Windows utility that can do a full load test on your battery and let you know how long it should last.
please check the link for the more information
http://www.computeractive.co.uk/ca/step-by-step/1933790/test-laptop-s-battery-life
to download go to the website
http://www.batteryeater.com/news.html
can you try Battery Eater is a free Windows utility that can do a full load test on your battery and let you know how long it should last.
please check the link for the more information
http://www.computeractive.co.uk/ca/step-by-step/1933790/test-laptop-s-battery-life
to download go to the website
http://www.batteryeater.com/news.html
Active today
Thanks. Does it take very long to run to generate the report?
Whole idea is not to fully charge the battery
Whole idea is not to fully charge the battery
Active today
Thanks. Does it take very long to run to generate the report?
Whole idea is not to fully charge the battery
Whole idea is not to fully charge the battery
There is NO METHOD to check how long a battery will last without a FULL charge and discharge. How can it? Software can NOT tell the physical condition of a battery.
And we all know how well windows "Guesses"!!!
One of my kids laptops has 3 hours remaining 10 minutes before it shuts down.
Forget any windows estimates on a battery of unknown state.
One of my kids laptops has 3 hours remaining 10 minutes before it shuts down.
Forget any windows estimates on a battery of unknown state.
i do not think that any app or program can measure it accurately for the very simple reason that there are too many variables. everything mentioned above it can give you a good guestimate of how much/long you have left.
Active today
Well, I have to choose between a Dell E6230 & a Lenovo X220 from
our corporate office & I guess they're both used before by some
other staff.
The officer in charge of the laptops only allows me about 5-10
minutes to take out the laptops from the store room to test
them, so I really don't have the luxury of fully charging up
both laptops to the full to determine which of the two has
better batteries.
It's crucial for me to have a longer battery operational hours
because I often went to places where there are no AC power
supply to charge up the batteries. Certainly I can spend my
personal money to buy spare battery but it's not worth it to
spend my own money for work purpose. It's difficult to
justify to my management to buy such things (even if it's
consumables)
our corporate office & I guess they're both used before by some
other staff.
The officer in charge of the laptops only allows me about 5-10
minutes to take out the laptops from the store room to test
them, so I really don't have the luxury of fully charging up
both laptops to the full to determine which of the two has
better batteries.
It's crucial for me to have a longer battery operational hours
because I often went to places where there are no AC power
supply to charge up the batteries. Certainly I can spend my
personal money to buy spare battery but it's not worth it to
spend my own money for work purpose. It's difficult to
justify to my management to buy such things (even if it's
consumables)
I can chime in here and say that I am particularly happy with the battery life on the Lenovo X220. It is particularly long. If you buy (or if it already has) the extended "slice" battery, you get even more life. My X220, with slice battery, gets approximately 8 hours of REAL battery life from a full charge. Without the slice, I get about 4 hours of real world battery life (still better than a lot of laptops).
So if you have to pick one and your main goal is battery life and you don't have the time to properly test them, I'd say the X220 is a safer bet.
So if you have to pick one and your main goal is battery life and you don't have the time to properly test them, I'd say the X220 is a safer bet.
Also, FYI the Windows 7 Power Meter is actually pretty decent given the information it has to work with.
It has to guesstimate battery life based on the instantaneous battery discharge rate, and it takes a moving average over time, takes into account some common battery discharge characteristics (e.g. faster discharge near the end of the battery's life), and then gives you a rough extrapolation of the remaining life. Assuming healthy batteries it is usually pretty accurate.
But the biggest thing that changes the results with regards to predicting battery life is exactly what you're doing on the computer. More CPU, memory and HDD usage will drain the battery quicker and there is no way for Windows to account for that. The battery drains much quicker streaming a YouTube video than it will just sitting at the desktop.
So IMHO it is a fair test to fully charge the laptop, turn it on, close down as many unnecessary programs as possible, set the screen to not turn off, and then just leave the computer sitting at the desktop for 10 minutes. Then look at how much battery life Windows is reporting. If you do the same thing with both laptop I think you'll get a fair comparison for which one is better.
It has to guesstimate battery life based on the instantaneous battery discharge rate, and it takes a moving average over time, takes into account some common battery discharge characteristics (e.g. faster discharge near the end of the battery's life), and then gives you a rough extrapolation of the remaining life. Assuming healthy batteries it is usually pretty accurate.
But the biggest thing that changes the results with regards to predicting battery life is exactly what you're doing on the computer. More CPU, memory and HDD usage will drain the battery quicker and there is no way for Windows to account for that. The battery drains much quicker streaming a YouTube video than it will just sitting at the desktop.
So IMHO it is a fair test to fully charge the laptop, turn it on, close down as many unnecessary programs as possible, set the screen to not turn off, and then just leave the computer sitting at the desktop for 10 minutes. Then look at how much battery life Windows is reporting. If you do the same thing with both laptop I think you'll get a fair comparison for which one is better.
Active today
Both the X220 & E6230 comes with 6 cell battery.
The E6230's battery is 58Wh Type J79X4 ; not too
sure about the X220's.
What I like about X220 is the keys & the edge of
the laptop are rounded (not too piercing on the
palms) while E6230's keys are rather hard to type
on with sharp edges.
However E6230 comes with two USB 3 ports while
I doubt the X220 which our corporate buys has
any USB 3 port (wanted USB 3 for faster backups
& when I map an external USB 3 HDDs to other
server, it's faster)
Both comes with 7200rpm HDDs:
X220 has Hitachi HTS725032A9A364 while
E6230 has Seagate ST320LT007-9ZV142
The E6230's battery is 58Wh Type J79X4 ; not too
sure about the X220's.
What I like about X220 is the keys & the edge of
the laptop are rounded (not too piercing on the
palms) while E6230's keys are rather hard to type
on with sharp edges.
However E6230 comes with two USB 3 ports while
I doubt the X220 which our corporate buys has
any USB 3 port (wanted USB 3 for faster backups
& when I map an external USB 3 HDDs to other
server, it's faster)
Both comes with 7200rpm HDDs:
X220 has Hitachi HTS725032A9A364 while
E6230 has Seagate ST320LT007-9ZV142
Once again.......
If you have no way of knowing the actual state of the battery, and you wont do in ten minutes, then you have a lucky dip. Either battery could be dead in a week, you have no way of knowing in a five/ten min window.
If you have no way of knowing the actual state of the battery, and you wont do in ten minutes, then you have a lucky dip. Either battery could be dead in a week, you have no way of knowing in a five/ten min window.
On the Lenovo there is a 'Power Manager' utility that is part of the Thinkvantage stuff (unless its been removed, its in the original setup though). The utility will tell you the battery info including the date, what the last full charge was AND what the batteries original spec was. It also shows battery estimated life. So you can get a view of roughly how worn the battery is compared to the 'new' state.
Dell has a utility that is part of the support software on an original setup to get battery info. It will give you similar info, including what the battery fully charges up to currently.
Outside of the current max charge levels on the batteries, I would probably also check the date's on the batteries (shown through the utilities as well). Even if it a battery has not been used heavily it also does lose capacity over time. If there is a big age difference you might want the newer battery even if the battery power levels are similar.
It is possible to test batteries without running them through a full charge/discharge, I just don't know that the hardware on a laptop can do it accurate enough. My company uses a stand alone unit that gives very accurate results in about 10 seconds. It essentially loads the battery and looks at the how fast the voltage drops under load, adjusts for temperature and gives you a result based on known decay rates for the battery type. The unit probably see's much finer changes in voltage than the sensors on a laptop in order to do it so fast.
I'd probably go with a heavier test than Frosty's suggestion and stress the computer for a few minutes and check the battery before and after. This is not about a time estimate but about seeing which battery is in better shape. In the long run the battery in the best condition will serve you better. Obviously not as good as our battery tester but would probably give a result sufficient to compare the systems.
Here's a example freeware stress tester,
http://www.jam-software.com/heavyload/
Just do the same test on each. This will give you an idea of how well each battery holds up. Could turn up other issues as well.
To be honest I think the information from the manufacturer battery utilities about how much a full charge is on the batteries currently will tell the tale without having to do any more testing. This is based off of the charging history.
Dell has a utility that is part of the support software on an original setup to get battery info. It will give you similar info, including what the battery fully charges up to currently.
Outside of the current max charge levels on the batteries, I would probably also check the date's on the batteries (shown through the utilities as well). Even if it a battery has not been used heavily it also does lose capacity over time. If there is a big age difference you might want the newer battery even if the battery power levels are similar.
It is possible to test batteries without running them through a full charge/discharge, I just don't know that the hardware on a laptop can do it accurate enough. My company uses a stand alone unit that gives very accurate results in about 10 seconds. It essentially loads the battery and looks at the how fast the voltage drops under load, adjusts for temperature and gives you a result based on known decay rates for the battery type. The unit probably see's much finer changes in voltage than the sensors on a laptop in order to do it so fast.
I'd probably go with a heavier test than Frosty's suggestion and stress the computer for a few minutes and check the battery before and after. This is not about a time estimate but about seeing which battery is in better shape. In the long run the battery in the best condition will serve you better. Obviously not as good as our battery tester but would probably give a result sufficient to compare the systems.
Here's a example freeware stress tester,
http://www.jam-software.com/heavyload/
Just do the same test on each. This will give you an idea of how well each battery holds up. Could turn up other issues as well.
To be honest I think the information from the manufacturer battery utilities about how much a full charge is on the batteries currently will tell the tale without having to do any more testing. This is based off of the charging history.
Featured Post
Disaster Recovery as a Service is one go-to solution that revolutionizes DR planning. Implementing DRaaS could be an efficient process, easily accessible to non-DR experts. Learn about monitoring, testing, executing failovers and failbacks to ensure a "healthy" DR environment.
Question has a verified solution.
If you are experiencing a similar issue, please ask a related question
In this article you will get to know about pros and cons of storage drives HDD, SSD and SSHD.
It’s been over a month into 2017, and there is already a sophisticated Gmail phishing email making it rounds. New techniques and tactics, have given hackers a way to authentically impersonate your contacts.How it Works
The attack works by targeti…
- The Email Laundry
- Email Servers
- Cybersecurity
- Email Protocols
- Network Security
- Security, *Phishing
Windows 8 comes with a dramatically different user interface known as Metro. Notably missing from the new interface is a Start button and Start Menu. Many users do not like it, much preferring the interface of earlier versions — Windows 7, Windows X…
- Microsoft Legacy OS
- Windows 10
- Windows 8
- Windows OS
- Windows 7
- Windows Vista, Windows XP, Windows 2000, *Windows Explorer, *Internet Explorer (IE)
With the advent of Windows 10, Microsoft is pushing a Get Windows 10 icon into the notification area (system tray) of qualifying computers. There are many reasons for wanting to remove this icon. This two-part Experts Exchange video Micro Tutorial s…
- Windows 10
- Microsoft Legacy OS
- Windows 8
- Windows OS
- Windows 7
- Windows Vista, Windows XP, *windows update, *Windows Updates
Suggested Courses
Course of the Month8 days, 16 hours left to enroll
765 members asked questions and received personalized solutions in the past 7 days.
Join the community of 500,000 technology professionals and ask your questions.