Want to avoid the missteps to gaining all the benefits of the cloud? Learn more about the different assessment options from our Cloud Advisory team.
Solved
mailing 100,000 messages from linux to my members
Posted on 2012-12-26
Hi
I have a social network that I run on my Linux server. I have 200,000 members. 100,000 members have become fairly dormant. I've drafted an email to the 100,000 members encouraging them to return to the site or delete their account.
I've setup a routine to mail out this message via linux to these members at the rate of 1 ever 5 seconds.
I have set the pace to be slow so that I do not 'upset' yahoo and aol, etc. I want to avoid being black listed or something like that.
Should I be concerned about the pace at which I send messages?
I don't know if it matters, but I'm using exim.
Thank you.
I have a social network that I run on my Linux server. I have 200,000 members. 100,000 members have become fairly dormant. I've drafted an email to the 100,000 members encouraging them to return to the site or delete their account.
I've setup a routine to mail out this message via linux to these members at the rate of 1 ever 5 seconds.
I have set the pace to be slow so that I do not 'upset' yahoo and aol, etc. I want to avoid being black listed or something like that.
Should I be concerned about the pace at which I send messages?
I don't know if it matters, but I'm using exim.
Thank you.
[X]
Welcome to Experts Exchange
Add your voice to the tech community where 5M+ people just like you are talking about what matters.
- Help others & share knowledge
- Earn cash & points
- Learn & ask questions
5
3
2- +3
16 Comments
My initial concerns would be as follows:
1. Frequency of mailing.. 1 every 5 seconds
2. Alternate the ISP's you send to (Google, Yahoo, Comcast...)
3. Keep the content very cliean so it does not score high in spam elimination engines
4. Remove emails that bouse back to maintain a clean db.
Hope this helps!
1. Frequency of mailing.. 1 every 5 seconds
2. Alternate the ISP's you send to (Google, Yahoo, Comcast...)
3. Keep the content very cliean so it does not score high in spam elimination engines
4. Remove emails that bouse back to maintain a clean db.
Hope this helps!
Active today
Did you check to see what limits your ISP or hosting place on sending emails? Limits range from 25 per hour to 1000 per day. Almost nobody allows unlimited emails to be sent.
@Dave
If here is delivering through the isp's smarthost, you're right; however, if he is routing directly via DNS he can send as many emails as he has bandwidth.
@USA with this volume, I would consider using a service like smtpauth to send emails. It will cost a little bit butt will keep you off blacklists.
If here is delivering through the isp's smarthost, you're right; however, if he is routing directly via DNS he can send as many emails as he has bandwidth.
@USA with this volume, I would consider using a service like smtpauth to send emails. It will cost a little bit butt will keep you off blacklists.
Looks like you'll be mailing for quite a while. 100,000 messages with one message every 5 seconds will run for the better part of 6 days. Your script will get terminated and restarted, so you probably need to design in a mechanism that will allow that. Perhaps a separate DB table with the email address and a "sent" column, so you can avoid re-sending messages. You might also want to alphabetize the list and scan it visually for "honeypot" addresses, and avoid sending to those. In the past some bad actors have signed up to social networks using the known addresses of spam traps. When the services send welcome messages, they get put on blacklists. (A similar trick was performed a few years ago, when Unsubscribe messages, with return addresses on the honeypot lists were sent to thousands of mail lists. The mail lists responded with "You are not subscribed" notes, and they all got blacklisted by SpamHaus.
I have crons setup to send up to 500/hr - one cron for each hour, in case something stops.
I also keep track of what is sent out.
I'm most interested in knowing if I need to pace the messages or just send them all at once.
Any thoughts on that would be helpful.
Thank you.
I also keep track of what is sent out.
I'm most interested in knowing if I need to pace the messages or just send them all at once.
Any thoughts on that would be helpful.
Thank you.
Who is your hosting provider? Ask them if you should pace the messages. They will be the only ones who are likely to care.
If you're worried about getting nailed by an ISP blacklist, like ATT / Yahoo, they typically don't do it based on send rate alone. They are going to look at more factors. If that was the case, whitehouse.gov, Facebook, and countless other websites that send millions of emails at once would have awful deliverability rates.
Do make sure you have SPF properly setup. Make sure your domains all have the correct pointers. Make sure you are not sending the same messages to teh same accounts over and over, and make sure that you are dropping bad emails.
You basically want to avoid spam-like patterns.
As long as you do this, I am fairly sure no one will care.
...unless you hit a honey pot. and if that's the case, it doesn't matter if you sent one email or 1,000,000. You hit the honey pot, and you are going to wind up on the black list.
Being on a blacklist isn't all that bad as long as you're not making a habit of it.Most of them have forms you can fill out to get removed, and it might be a thorn in your side for a couple of days, but if you're doing it to clean up your accounts and lists, then it would be worth it in my opinion.
-DrD
Do make sure you have SPF properly setup. Make sure your domains all have the correct pointers. Make sure you are not sending the same messages to teh same accounts over and over, and make sure that you are dropping bad emails.
You basically want to avoid spam-like patterns.
As long as you do this, I am fairly sure no one will care.
...unless you hit a honey pot. and if that's the case, it doesn't matter if you sent one email or 1,000,000. You hit the honey pot, and you are going to wind up on the black list.
Being on a blacklist isn't all that bad as long as you're not making a habit of it.Most of them have forms you can fill out to get removed, and it might be a thorn in your side for a couple of days, but if you're doing it to clean up your accounts and lists, then it would be worth it in my opinion.
-DrD
Active today
whitehouse.gov, Facebook, and others do not have to worry about one little client causing them to be blacklisted. They have their own servers (many of them) and their own connections to the internet that are better than most local ISPs. Gmail and Godaddy and my local ISP all have limits on email sent thru their servers.
Still, the main thing is to ask. All those with limits typically just drop your emails when you reach their limits without any warning message.
Still, the main thing is to ask. All those with limits typically just drop your emails when you reach their limits without any warning message.
Ray:
Re: Facebook / Whitehouse - I was exaggerating to make a point :-)
From a mail standpoint, it doesn't matter if you are sending from multiple IPs (multiple servers) if the content and return paths trigger the spam buttons, they are spam.
There are limits ONLY if you are relaying via a smart host. (Godaddy, Gmail, your ISP are smarthosts). If you have a mailserver that sends mail directly, there are no limits.
With 200,000 users, I would assume he is running a dedicated server (or at least should be), and that he would not be routing via a smarthost.
@USA: Is this a dedicated server or a shared service? Is exim configured to route mail using DNS or a smarthost?
Re: Facebook / Whitehouse - I was exaggerating to make a point :-)
From a mail standpoint, it doesn't matter if you are sending from multiple IPs (multiple servers) if the content and return paths trigger the spam buttons, they are spam.
There are limits ONLY if you are relaying via a smart host. (Godaddy, Gmail, your ISP are smarthosts). If you have a mailserver that sends mail directly, there are no limits.
With 200,000 users, I would assume he is running a dedicated server (or at least should be), and that he would not be routing via a smarthost.
@USA: Is this a dedicated server or a shared service? Is exim configured to route mail using DNS or a smarthost?
This is a dedicated server.
I do have DKIM setup -- not sure that SPFcomes into play when I have DKIM setup. Do I need to be concerned with SPFin my case ?
Also, the explanations I'm hearing about speed is encouraging. I agree that I suspected that pace of email should not be factored and would hold up tons and tons of messages if major sites were concerned about getting their mail out in a timely fashion.
I don't like pacing the mail cause it's taking foreverrrrrrrrrrrrr
I do have DKIM setup -- not sure that SPFcomes into play when I have DKIM setup. Do I need to be concerned with SPFin my case ?
Also, the explanations I'm hearing about speed is encouraging. I agree that I suspected that pace of email should not be factored and would hold up tons and tons of messages if major sites were concerned about getting their mail out in a timely fashion.
I don't like pacing the mail cause it's taking foreverrrrrrrrrrrrr
SPF just tells the world, "This server is authorized to send email from this domain name." It's the closest thing to accountability that exists in email. I would say it's mandatory for any email system that wants to preserve, protect and defend reputation.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sender_Policy_Framework
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sender_Policy_Framework
You need to configure DKIM and SPF on your server.
Also I recomend you to read this guideline
http://urbanmarketingnetwork.com/blog/index.php/2009/03/13/improve-mass-email-deliverablity-the-long-way/
https://support.google.com/mail/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=81126
http://postmaster.aol.com/Postmaster.Guidelines.php
https://dub114.mail.live.com/mail/postmaster.aspx
Also I recomend you to read this guideline
http://urbanmarketingnetwork.com/blog/index.php/2009/03/13/improve-mass-email-deliverablity-the-long-way/
https://support.google.com/mail/bin/answer.py?hl=en&answer=81126
http://postmaster.aol.com/Postmaster.Guidelines.php
https://dub114.mail.live.com/mail/postmaster.aspx
Also you can play with throttling roles
http://wiki.spry.com/Throttling_exim
http://wiki.spry.com/Throttling_exim
Featured Post
New feature! Upgrade and increase expert visibility of your issues with Priority Questions.
Question has a verified solution.
If you are experiencing a similar issue, please ask a related question
Phishing attempts can come in all forms, shapes and sizes. No matter how familiar you think you are with them, always remember to take extra precaution when opening an email with attachments or links.
This article discusses how to implement server side field validation and display customized error messages to the client.
Explain concepts important to validation of email addresses with regular expressions. Applies to most languages/tools that uses regular expressions.
Consider email address RFCs:
Look at HTML5 form input element (with type=email) regex pattern:
T…
The video tutorial explains the basics of the Exchange server Database Availability groups.
The components of this video include:
1. Automatic Failover
2. Failover Clustering
3. Active Manager
Suggested Courses
Course of the Month15 days, 4 hours left to enroll
649 members asked questions and received personalized solutions in the past 7 days.
Join the community of 500,000 technology professionals and ask your questions.