formula referencing another workbook gives #value! error when other workbook is closed

developingprogrammer used Ask the Experts™
hey guys, i've got a consolidation workbook and many child workbooks. i've linked them up using a countif formula. everything works fine when the child workbooks are open. when the childworkbooks are closed and i try to Update Values via the below, i get #value! error. why am i getting this and why is it when my child workbooks are open they update just fine?

update values
guys and what is the difference between refresh all and update values?refresh all
here are the consolidation workbook and one of the child workbooks attached
Watch Question

Do more with

Expert Office
EXPERT OFFICE® is a registered trademark of EXPERTS EXCHANGE®

I found this answer:

which basically says you want to put the full path in the file refence:


Your first screen shot makes me think this shouldnn't be neccessary, but guess it's worth a shot.  (I have not tested this myself)
Thanks korbus, it already is the full path name. If the child workbook is opened it will not show the path name. If the workbook is closed then excel will automatically show the full path name. I didn't type in the path, I used = and then clicked on the range in the child workbook. So unfortunately this doesn't solve the problem = (
Most Valuable Expert 2013

COUNTIF function doesn't work with closed workbooks -

See here for advice from microsoft - they suggest an "array formula" which is another alternative, but SUMPRODUCT doesn't need try using SUMPRODUCT like this

=SUMPRODUCT(('[Freddie-PAR Checklist.xls]STP_PTE'!$A$10:$A$65536=C$4)+0)

As you say, you can use that version without the path, if the child worbook is open (but that will still work when that workbook is closed)

regards, barry
Exploring SharePoint 2016

Explore SharePoint 2016, the web-based, collaborative platform that integrates with Microsoft Office to provide intranets, secure document management, and collaboration so you can develop your online and offline capabilities.

whao barry, the formula works like a charm! thanks so much!!

if you don't mind could you explain how the formula works? i read up on sumproduct and it being the summation of the product of the arrays, but the way you're using the formula only has 1 array and you're adding 0.

here's what i understand so far:

('[Freddie-PAR Checklist.xls]STP_PTE'!$A$10:$A$65536=C$4) ------> this part you're using a boolean comparison. since true = 1 and false = 0, we have a number for true

+ 0 --------> you're adding 0 to convert boolean to number

sumproduct(......) -------------> here's where i'm a little lost. you've only got 1 array so how come it gives the right result? could you share barry? thanks so much!!
oh, is it that sumproduct with 1 array means that array multiplied by 1 and summed?
oh and what's the difference between Refresh All and Update Values? thanks!!
Most Valuable Expert 2013
Sorry for the delay, it was my bedtime here.....

You only really need SUM, i.e. this will work

=SUM(('[Freddie-PAR Checklist.xls]STP_PTE'!$A$10:$A$65536=C$4)+0)

You compare each value against C4 which gives you an "array" of TRUE/FALSE values and +0 is a "coercer", converting TRUE/FALSE to 1/0, (you could use *1 or others) then SUM sums the 1s giving a count of cells in your range that meet the condition

......but that formula is an "array formula", i.e. it needs to be confirmed with CTRL+SHIFT+ENTER to get the correct result (and you see { and } around the formula)

using SUMPRODUCT means that you don't need CSE. As you say there is nothing to multiply here - when you use SUMPRODUCT with a single array or range SUMPRODUCT just sums the values in that array or range just like SUM, i.e. =SUMPRODUCT({2,3,4}) =9

regards, barry
fantastic, thanks so much for your help barry!!
and so sorry for my late reply too!!! you're super prompt and i really appreciate barry!! = ))) and great formula by the way!!! = ))

Do more with

Expert Office
Submit tech questions to Ask the Experts™ at any time to receive solutions, advice, and new ideas from leading industry professionals.

Start 7-Day Free Trial