Microsoft Security Essentials v Others

Does Microsoft Security Essentials do as well as non-free commercial products?  I think I just had some malware corrupt my machine and I need to prevent that.
Bob SchneiderCo-OwnerAsked:
Who is Participating?

Improve company productivity with a Business Account.Sign Up

DarinTCHConnect With a Mentor Senior CyberSecurity EngineerCommented:
so to summarize
Free has its limits
you can mitigate some of the shortcomings by having 3-4 apps
a Firewall - Comodo is the most popular free one
an A/V like those mentioned AVG, AVAST, MS Essential
a malware program -Malware Bytes
other cleanup utilities - CCLeaner

the full paid suites will accomplish this with less apps and manual running...
but they cost...your choice
tpitch-ssemcConnect With a Mentor Commented:
I personally use AVG Free but would also recommend Avast. MS Security Essentials has been in the news lately and I wouldn't rely on it as my sole source for protection.
AlexiosConnect With a Mentor Commented:
unfortunately Free Antivirus (Avast, AVG etc.) and  MS Essentials as well are not good enough in compare with paid security software especially for malware prevention and clean.

For a firewall a free and good solution is COMODO.

Further on that, free online tools like this
are having positive results in cleaning infected systems
Improved Protection from Phishing Attacks

WatchGuard DNSWatch reduces malware infections by detecting and blocking malicious DNS requests, improving your ability to protect employees from phishing attacks. Learn more about our newest service included in Total Security Suite today!

JohnConnect With a Mentor Business Consultant (Owner)Commented:
Microsoft Security Essentials is one of the best free applications. However, none of the free applications are as good or reliable as the paid ones. I only use paid antivirus for myself and my clients.

In addition to the above, Symantec Endpoint Protection is also very good. I have heard good things about paid Kaspersky.

.... Thinkpads_User
Jeff PerkinsConnect With a Mentor OwnerCommented:
60% of what I do is cleaning up Malware infected systems.  Today you need two types of protection.
AV for 1, and I don't recommend any of the free ones for various reasons. I've cleaned up plenty of infections from MSSE. MS should probably stick to O/S and not security.  I'm preferential to ESET Nod32 AV or Sec. Suite.  They are not a resource hog like many of the top AV, and they catch everything going.

Second you need an antimalware.  I suggest the Pro Version of Malwarebytes. It's a one time purchase for personal users and really cuts down on what gets thru.
lancecurwensvilleConnect With a Mentor Commented:
MSE is a good product in its own right.  Choosing between it and a "paid" version depends upon your usage and level of protection.  I usually recommend MSE for home users unless they are constantly doing obscure downloads from questionable sites.  Whiles MSE is permitted to be used for business use (up to 10 machines), I usually push them towards a paid service.

In my opinion, Kaspersky is the best, however, if one is cost conscious and wants solid protection, I would also look at Vipre Internet Security 2013 or Vipre Anti-Virus 2013.  You can find 10 pack bundles of both of these for a 1 year subscription for around $50 on Amazon.

One of the most experienced security experts here on Exchange highly touts Vipre (can't remember who it is, sorry), and I have used it with great success in several organizations.
TolomirConnect With a Mentor AdministratorCommented:
One of the best antivirus solutions today is bitdefender.

see the results of a current test.
TolomirConnect With a Mentor AdministratorCommented:
here is the detailed microsoft test results for mse:

in comparison bitdefender:
Bob SchneiderCo-OwnerAuthor Commented:
I went with nod32 and malwarebytes pro.  From what I hear I should be about as protected as I can be, correct?
Bob SchneiderCo-OwnerAuthor Commented:
Incredibly good discussion
Jeff PerkinsOwnerCommented:
There is nothing that will protect you from everything, but those two give you about as much protection as is possible without causing severe problems.  
Stay away from porn sites, avoid the freebies, and take the proper precautions in not clicking on links or attachments in email unless you are absolutely positive where they came from, and that DOES NOT mean you recognize the email address.
Bob SchneiderCo-OwnerAuthor Commented:
I am pretty careful with that stuff but I wonder if I got hit when I clicked on a twitter link???
here comes bitdefender in play, btw. nod32 does not perform so well, see for yourself:

bitdefender in contrast scans every link for possible / reported malware, see attached screenshot. bitefender weblink scan. The green ok signs are from bitdefender.

Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.