SBS 2008 Backup - Best USB Drives?

I have a client that has a Dell PE T310 that has been running great for a few years now, but I need to update their backup solution.
They purchased 2x 1TB Toshiba USB 3.0 drives, but the built-in backup has issues accessing them. there is a CDFS partition on each drive that can't seem to be removed.
Backup Assist does work OK, but I would prefer just using the built-in backup.

I would like to get a couple 2TB drives, USB 3.0 preferred, but I wanted to know what is a good Make/Model for compatibility and reliability?  WD? Seagate?

I know the server doesn't have onboard USB 3.0, and I was thinking about getting something like this:

is that a good idea?

Thank you for your input!
Who is Participating?
Rob WilliamsConnect With a Mentor Commented:
There is an SBS USB backup drive compatibility list/wiki to which you may want to refer:
Cliff GaliherConnect With a Mentor Commented:
Look for drives that describe themselves as "expansion" instead of "backup" and you'll usually be safe. I was a big fan of the GoFlex system from Seagate because it meant that I could outfit it with eSata, USB, or ...if servers ever started shipping with Thunderbolt...that too. Sadly Seagate has been stepping away from that system. Their backup pro drives still have interchangeable connectors, but I have not yet tested any of them with SBS and they may have the same issue with the CDFS partition.

Seagate does still have an expansion drive available and it is USB3 so that is what I've been using. I will buy a backup pro drive one of these days for testing, but haven't felt a driving need to yet.
bcruse32347Connect With a Mentor Commented:
Another option:

Have you considered online backup? A service like CrashPlan is inexpensive and backs up changed files as they change limiting the amount of time to complete a backup.

Go to for details. It can be backed up for less than $10.00 a month
Free Tool: IP Lookup

Get more info about an IP address or domain name, such as organization, abuse contacts and geolocation.

One of a set of tools we are providing to everyone as a way of saying thank you for being a part of the community.

BadPandaConnect With a Mentor Commented:
I would stay away from any USB backup device that has a platform where the backup device sits on, such as the case with Seagates 1 or 2TB drives.  We've had multiple failures with both ourselves and some of our clients due to that connector failing.  Wasn't worth it.
As for bcruse32347's comments, I wholeheartedly agree; online backups are a great option.  However, be careful which plan you consider.  I checked on crashplan and didn't see anything regarding AD and Exchange's backups.  We have been using these guys backups.
They don't throttle, don't charge for extra downloads or restores, had great support, and best of all when I needed to do a restore it worked!  I destroyed my AD and had to recover, and all my SBS 2011 stuff was there.  They have a free trial (15-days I think.)
Whoever you use, if you use an online backup, make sure they have free support.
redheadtechAuthor Commented:
Thanks for the comments - I am waiting to hear back from CrashPlan to see what all their "Pro" backup includes for SBS 2008. <br />I still really like the idea of a USB drive that is available on hand in need of recovery :)
Rob WilliamsCommented:
The problem with an on-line backup if you need a full restore is it can take days or even weeks to download everything.   Also databases with plans like Crashplan are not practical or even possible because of the size of the file.

We usually use both USB for full system backup, and on-line for a second copy of critical, non-data base data.

The top on-line backups like those offered by Iron Mountain, do bit level backup so databases are possible, and also in a disaster recovery situation they ship you by courier a server preloaded with your data so that you can copy it over.  Of course the cost is about 10 times that of folk like CrashPlan.
Again, check with Online Backup USA.  Their backup software backs up online and to a local drive or network location.  We backup our SBS 2011 server online and to a share across the network on our file server.  
When we used Iron Mountain they were great...but pricey.  They took our tapes offsite weekly and rotated out our tapes.  It cost a pretty penny, but there were never any problems.
Let us know what you find!
redheadtechAuthor Commented:
I will defiantly check out OnlineBackupUSA as I am just located about 15 minutes north of their Bellingham location!
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.