• Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 236
  • Last Modified:

AD on Fileserver?

Hi All,
We've got a medium sized domain (approx 200 users) and already have 2 AD servers on Win2008R2.  However, both are virtuals.  I'd like to add a physical DC into the mix.

The problem is, the only machine I have on hand is a 2U with a ton of HDD space.  We also need a new fileserver.  So my question is, how bad an idea is it to run both the DC and fileserver roles on the same server?

Your input is greatly appreciated.

P.S. I do have one other, 1U, less powerful system on hand, but it only has one power supply.  I figured that's not what I want to put our only physical DC on.
0
Schandor
Asked:
Schandor
3 Solutions
 
Mike KlineCommented:
So the issue comes in is what if you have to do maintenance to files, and have to take the server down (AD goes dows).

What if your file server admin (if separate) needs access to the system.  Having said that I have personally been at places where a DC/File server were combined.  That is going away a bit these days but sometimes it was also done for economic reasons...just not a best practice.

The one with the one power supply would work fine.   If it goes down you still have those two other DCs.

Thanks

Mike
0
 
BillBondoCommented:
Since you have 2 DC, I see no problems adding a 3rd combined w/ file services.
0
 
Sarang TinguriaSr EngineerCommented:
I would have preffered to use a good config desktop or a low config server class machine rather putting it on a file server
DC makes significant changes to tighten the security on itself if you are using other roles too along with DC then you are compromising the security of you DC environment

I said Using desktop is because DC role will not need a great performing machine coz uless PDC role holder only authentication and GP processing are generaly done by DC ..there are other process too but that can be processed by a Good desktop (I3 or equivalent processor 2 or 3GB's of RAM)

In nowadays you may also configure RAID and mirroring on desktop for redundancy
Still of desktop crashes you may recover AD as you already have two more desktops
0

Featured Post

Creating Active Directory Users from a Text File

If your organization has a need to mass-create AD user accounts, watch this video to see how its done without the need for scripting or other unnecessary complexities.

Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now