Random IP errors


I have a Domain with 1 DC (also the only DNS server), 5 member servers and approx 30 workstations.
Mix of windows 2008 R2 enterprise, Win 7 pro and Win 7 Ultimate.

At random points I get a "Bad IP". I can not Ping between the device and the DC or log onto it.

I can not ping or connect to the DC until the IP address is changed to one that is free.
After a while, about a day or so the "Bad IP" become OK again.

Whilst the IP is "bad" any device with this IP address can not connect to the DC.

All the servers and workstations have static IP addresses.

Q, How can I see if the DNS is at fault. I ask this due to, the reverse is not updating or creating some entries.

Who is Participating?
trevor1940Connect With a Mentor Author Commented:
Very strange.....

There was a rouge PTR entry that could not be deleted on its own.
I deleted and recreated the entire reverse range which allowed me to ping again!
Why are you using static IP addressing? The DHCP server that comes with Windows servers is very capable and saves a lot of network administration. If some computers need to have the same IP address all the time, set up DHCP reservations for them to make sure that they always receive the same address.

DHCP also takes care of gateway address and DNS server address provision, as well as some more esoteric options that I've rarely had to use.

In a scenario such as yours, the DC would usually be the DHCP server and would be the only computer on the network that actually needed a static IP. Routers and network printers often are configured with static IP addresses that are well clear of the DHCP scope, to avoid conflicts.

Is a DHCP server active on your DC, or for that matter on a router or switch on your network having that capability? If so, it might be trying to assign addresses that overlap the static IP address range that you are using and so cause the conflicts and errors that you are seeing.
trevor1940Author Commented:

Thanks, However.

We are talking DNS and static IP addresses. Sorry.

Due to network configuration (I have no control over this) I can not use DHCP. The servers and workstations will only be static.
Making Bulk Changes to Active Directory

Watch this video to see how easy it is to make mass changes to Active Directory from an external text file without using complicated scripts.

That must be frustrating - having the responsibility for the network but incomplete control over it...

However, the point about a DHCP server possibly being active on the network seems to me to be still worth checking out.

Also, do you have wireless on your LAN? If so, could the access point be picking up DHCP broadcasts from a different network, and upsetting the apple cart that way?
trevor1940Author Commented:

The DHCP client services is running on the servers and the client.
Adding the DHCP roll was tried however this did not help.

No not wireless at all.
trevor1940Author Commented:
From running DCDIGAG /test:DNS.

I get "Failed to delete test record dcdiag..."
trevor1940Author Commented:
Right another update

I can MSTSC from the "BAD" IP to the DC
I can not MSTSC from the DC to the "BAD" IP

I have cleared both arp cashes.
trevor1940Author Commented:
Very strange fix i found myself
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.