I am having a problem where I am pulling policy results for a user accounts on different servers and getting mixed results on what gpo's are being read.
My setup is 3 domain controllers and 6 Remote Desktop servers all running windows 2k8 R2 with a 2k8 R2 Active Directory domain. The 6 TS servers are in a RD farm config. When I ran the gpresult for the same username against all 6 servers, I got half of them reading and applying the newest versions of the GPOs while the other half are using older versions and not seeing the newly created GPOs. The half that read the old GPOs are also showing GPOs that have been unlinked.
The only thing that I've found different between the servers is which DNS server they are pulling from, which I thought was the main issue, but I am not sure anymore after I did some testing to prove that.
Here's what I've done so far.
1.) Ran GPOTool - Everything came back OK
2.) Ran Repadmin /showrepl - No problems, all servers replicating to each other
3.) Cleared the GPO cache (programdata/microsoft/group policy/history/*.*)on one of the servers that is having a problem and then ran a gpupdate /force - did not fix.
4.) Rebooted other two domain controllers and left one up, then ran gpupdate /force on all 6 servers to refresh from the same Domain Controller ans still had different rsop on half of them.
5.) confirmed that loopback is off on all servers
6.) DNS servers on the single NIC are set to two of the Domain Controllers
7.) Windows firewall is off on each server and the Domain Controllers
8.) The operational log for Group Policy doesn't show any errors when I do a gpupdate /force.
9.)The only errors I get in GP event log is on boot "Group Policy dependency (Network Location Awareness) did not start. As a result, network related features of Group Policy such as bandwidth estimation and response to network changes will not work." followed by "Group policy bandwidth estimation failed. Group policy processing will continue. Assuming fast link." When I checked the service, it is running though. I'm getting this error on machines both good and bad servers.
10.) Made sure that the local profiles are all gone. We are using Roaming profiles, so the RD's are using TEMP folders (which of course I'm making sure are gone before testing)
Any idea's on what might be causing something like this to happen? It feels like a cache issue, but I don't know where any other cache could be hidden or what else is going on.
This has been going on since I installed everything, so it's never worked properly.