Link to home
Create AccountLog in
Avatar of tonelm54

asked on

Javascript vs PHP giving differnet answers

I'm trying to get a validation working between java script and PHP, however both calculations are pulling different answers

Input = $_GET['txtChallenge'] = "54321"
Output = 45635
    var work1;
    work1 = String($('#txtChallenge').val().substring(4, 5)) + String($('#txtChallenge').val().substring(1, 2)) + String($('#txtChallenge').val().substring(0, 1)) + String($('#txtChallenge').val().substring(2, 3)) + String($('#txtChallenge').val().substring(3, 4));
    work1 = work1 + 96321 * 42677 * 32332 / 22324;
    work1 = Math.round(work1);
    work1 = String(work1).substring(String(work1).length - 5, String(work1).length);
    work1 = String(work1.substring(4, 5)) + String(work1.substring(2, 3)) + String(work1.substring(1, 2)) + String(work1.substring(3, 4)) + String(work1.substring(0, 1));


Open in new window

Input = #txtChallenge = "54321"
Output = 20204
    $work1 = substr($_GET['txtChallenge'],4,1) . substr($_GET['txtChallenge'],1,1) . substr($_GET['txtChallenge'],0,1) . substr($_GET['txtChallenge'],2,1) . substr($_GET['txtChallenge'],3,1);
    $work1 = $work1 + 96321 * 42677 * 32332 / 22324;
    $work1 = round($work1);
    $work1 = substr($work1,strlen($work1)-5);
    $work1 = substr($work1,4,1) . substr($work1,2, 1) . substr($work1,1, 1) . substr($work1,3, 1) . substr($work1,0, 1);

Open in new window

The part the calculations seem to go adrift is at:-
work1 + 96321 * 42677 * 32332 / 22324;

Open in new window

Im a little confused why they are going adrift, can anyone see where it is going wrong????
Avatar of Dave Baldwin
Dave Baldwin
Flag of United States of America image

Link to home
Create an account to see this answer
Signing up is free. No credit card required.
Create Account
But which is the correct output that you require
Avatar of tonelm54


Your code worked fine, I don't know if the answer is right, but both PHP and JavaScript gives the same answer which is all I need.

Im trying to build a authenticator login service, so the JavaScript side works on a phone standalone, and the PHP side works on the web server.

The PHP script generates a random 5 digit number which is typed into the standalone webpage (currently installed on phone) and then the resulting number is typed into the webpage and authenticated. Finally I want the actual sum to be different for each user, so a separate install needs for each phone.

The old site (which I made previously) authenticated via an email sent via the web server to the users email account with a second part of a key generated by a random number, the issue being it took too long for the emails to be delivered.

I had looked at using SMS, but I'm a cheap skate and don't want to pay anything, plus security isn't too much of a concern, just a nice addin.
Basically you are generating a simple 'captcha' but you're going thru a lot of work to do it.