Anti-Virus Recommendations

Need to secure about 125 machines, and 8 servers.

I was looking at Kaspersky and TrendMicro... cost is around 5k for a 36 month subscription.

My boss is trying to go cheap on it, which I advised against but hey..

I went to McAfee site, and there's a 50 dollar product that says it protects ALL your devices, but no information about node limitation etc.

Any ideas?
LVL 25
Ron MalmsteadInformation Services ManagerAsked:
Who is Participating?
 
Lee W, MVPTechnology and Business Process AdvisorCommented:
Security Essentials is NOT an option.  It's not licensed for business use beyond 10 seats.  You specifically state you need to cover more than 100 systems.

I agree with the VIPRE recommendation.  I use it at all my clients and don't have issues.  Kaspersky was a Pain in the neck to deal with their upgrades and support.  SEP is AWFUL.  McAfee was bloated the last time I tried it.  

I've tried close to a dozen products and I'm using VIPRE.

Just keep in mind - antivirus products are like ice cream - everyone has their favorite and there's always a flavor someone hates.  There is no right answer.
0
 
callmecheezCommented:
Look into Microsoft Forefront http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Forefront - it's the coporate version of Microsoft Security Essentials, which is best for Desktops
0
 
Thomas GrassiSystems AdministratorCommented:
We use Microsoft security Essentials on all workstations. No Problems at all.

For Servers Kaspersky is the best we have used.
0
WEBINAR: 10 Easy Ways to Lose a Password

Join us on June 27th at 8 am PDT to learn about the methods that hackers use to lift real, working credentials from even the most security-savvy employees. We'll cover the importance of multi-factor authentication and how these solutions can better protect your business!

 
Glen KrinskySystems AdministratorCommented:
This is not an area where you want to "go cheap".  There are low cost solutions though.  I use Kaspersky and have never been happier.  Also, I have used Trend in the past and it is good as well.  I do not like large programs like McAfee or Norton as they are large and VERY difficult to get rid of when you want to change.  AVG and Avast! also make some great products that are lower cost than big names.  Microsoft is essentially Giant AV.  They bought them some years back and their Windows defender product is very good.
0
 
Ron MalmsteadInformation Services ManagerAuthor Commented:
Honestly, MSE/Defender has proven unreliable in detecting most threats I've found myself.
1) It's easily disabled.
2) It doesn't update reliably
3) It boggs down the machine, unless you disable realtime scanning which of course defeats the purpose.
4) When it does detect something, it rarely removes it without some intervention on my behalf.
0
 
Thomas Zucker-ScharffSystems AnalystCommented:
My boss wanted to go cheap on this as well (which in our case was using the university site licensed SEP for free), but I convinced using bottom line/productivity arguments that in the end we would lose much more than we could possibly spend if we had even one infection we couldn't recover from.

We bought licenses for Vipre for Business from what was then GFI.  It was well worth the investment (the licenses ended up at about $10-$15 per seat - don't remember the exact amount).
0
 
Thomas GrassiSystems AdministratorCommented:
MSE does not bogg down the computer at all you do not even know it is there.

Remember antivirus is more of a User Training than it is software.

No software package is going to catch everything.

People cause all the antivirus problem. If you educate your users then you will have more success.

Norton and Mcafee do hog your computer resources stay away from them

How do you deploy your updates? With 125 plus computers I would think you use WSUS

If you use WSUS Microsoft Security Essentials updates can be processed via WSUS

Works great Windows 8 Windows 7 and Windows XP
For Windows 8 Defender has become MSE

All works very nicely.
0
 
Thomas Zucker-ScharffSystems AnalystCommented:
Leew is correct, although ou will see that many experts here will endorse Vipre or an ESET product like NOD32.

No matter what you use, a user can subvert it.  I have fantastic experiences with Vipre, but just yesterday one of my users got the System Care virus (actually rogue antivirus).  It was fairly easy to clean, but she got it by clicking on a link and accepting the defaults for an install.  So beware the human element!
0
 
Ron MalmsteadInformation Services ManagerAuthor Commented:
MSE is garbage..(you get what you pay for)

I haven't heard of VIPRE, which is why I posted this to begin with.. in case there was some options I hadn't heard of yet.

I'll check it out soon enough.
0
 
Thomas Zucker-ScharffSystems AnalystCommented:
You might also consider Malwarebytes Antimalware Pro (Business Editions).  Together with the chameleon product (comes with), MBAM Pro does the best job on the market.  I haven't used it in a corporate setting, so I don't know about  the console - which ESET has the best of and Vipre has the second best, when I tested them out a few years ago.
0
 
Glen KrinskySystems AdministratorCommented:
What it comes down to is you.  You are the one implementing and supporting it.  You listed a couple good products, if you are comfortable with them, then go with it.  If you are not sure about something, then the possibility for failure goes up.
0
 
Ron MalmsteadInformation Services ManagerAuthor Commented:
Thanks for the feedback.
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

All Courses

From novice to tech pro — start learning today.