Improve company productivity with a Business Account.Sign Up

x
  • Status: Solved
  • Priority: Medium
  • Security: Public
  • Views: 388
  • Last Modified:

Display data based on a sql count statement

I have a SQL statement counting the number of records based on certain criteria.

My SQL statement is:


      sqlCountChartID ="SELECT tblVirtualRef.ChartID, tblGeneral.City, Count(tblVirtualRef.VRID) AS CountChartID " & _
    "FROM tblVirtualRef INNER JOIN tblGeneral ON tblGeneral.ChartID= tblVirtualRef.ChartID " & _
      "WHERE tblVirtualRef.VRNotEligible LIKE 'Y' " & _
    "GROUP BY tblGeneral.City, tblVirtualRef.ChartID;"

      Set objCountChartID = Server.CreateObject("ADODB.Recordset")
      objCountChartID.Open sqlCountChartID, objConn

When I add tblGeneral.State to the SQL statement (right after tblGeneral.City) I get the following error.

         Microsoft JET Database Engine error '80040e21'
         You tried to execute a query that does not include the specified expression 'State' as part of an aggregate function.
0
Malloy1446
Asked:
Malloy1446
  • 3
  • 2
1 Solution
 
mds-cosCommented:
The easy way is to put tblGeneral.State into your GROUP BY clause...assuming your data set is such that this will not affect your count values. (yes, I understand you are not trying to group by State).  So you would have:

...GROUP BY tblGeneral.City, tblVirtualRef.ChartID, tblGeneral.State

The more difficult approach, and arguably better, is to use a temp table to isolate what you actually want to group by from what you only want to select.  This will be necessary if your data set will cause count values to change with the added group by.  So the approach would be:

SELECT t1.ChartID, t1.City, t1.CountChartID, tblGeneral.State FROM
tblGeneral INNER JOIN
(SELECT tblVirtualRef.ChartID, tblGeneral.City, Count(tblVirtualRef.VRID) AS CountChartID
FROM tblVirtualRef INNER JOIN tblGeneral ON tblGeneral.ChartID= tblVirtualRef.ChartID WHERE tblVirtualRef.VRNotEligible LIKE 'Y'
GROUP BY tblGeneral.City, tblVirtualRef.ChartID) t1


My brain is mush right now, so I hope I didn't flubber the syntax.
0
 
Malloy1446Author Commented:
I have never use two FROM statements in the same SQL clause. I have tried to add the following, but cannot get the right syntax...

      sqlCountChartID ="SELECT tblGeneral.ChartID, t1.City, tblGeneral.CountChartID, tblGeneral.State " & _
      "FROM tblGeneral INNER JOIN (SELECT tblVirtualRef.ChartID, tblGeneral.City, Count(tblVirtualRef.VRID) AS CountChartID " & _
      "FROM tblVirtualRef INNER JOIN tblGeneral ON tblGeneral.ChartID= tblVirtualRef.ChartID WHERE tblVirtualRef.VRNotEligible LIKE 'Y' " & _
      "GROUP BY tblGeneral.City, tblVirtualRef.ChartID)"
      
      Set objCountChartID = Server.CreateObject("ADODB.Recordset")
      objCountChartID.Open sqlCountChartID, objConn

Which generates the "Website cannot display the page" error
0
 
mds-cosCommented:
You are actually not using two FROM statements in the same query (that would be illegal).  You are creating a temporary table (t1) out of your aggregate SELECT statement.  You are then joining the results of that temporary table in your main query to pull all of the fields you want.

And I apologize for my brain right now.  Just back from a late flight and little sleep...I totally left out the ON condition for join statement to the temp table.  Duh...!!!!

...) t1 ON tblGeneral.ChartID = t1.ChartID
0
 
mds-cosCommented:
Oh man...scratch that all....I must be on drugs.  I'm trying to give you a solution to the wrong problem and also bringing in some theoretical arguments about how a GROUP BY should be used that really has little bearing on your question.  Sorry so confusing.

So hear is the deal.  You are selecting the count of records...thus an aggregate.  If you want to add in tblGeneral.State then all you have to do is put tblGeneral.State into your GROUP BY as I suggested.  Microsoft is picky about aggregates, demanding that every field selected outside an aggregate function (like COUNT) be included somewhere in the grouping.  So your entire VBA text string that you are building for the query would be:

sqlCountChartID ="SELECT tblVirtualRef.ChartID, tblGeneral.City, tblGeneral.State, Count(tblVirtualRef.VRID) AS CountChartID " & _
    "FROM tblVirtualRef INNER JOIN tblGeneral ON tblGeneral.ChartID= tblVirtualRef.ChartID " & _
      "WHERE tblVirtualRef.VRNotEligible LIKE 'Y' " & _
    "GROUP BY tblGeneral.City,  tblGeneral.State, tblVirtualRef.ChartID;"


This will of course change your count value if your data set has unique City / State pairings (Paris, TX, Paris, CA).  That may be what you want though.
0
 
Malloy1446Author Commented:
Thanks. The solution to add the fields to the group by making adding any extra fields real easy!
0
Question has a verified solution.

Are you are experiencing a similar issue? Get a personalized answer when you ask a related question.

Have a better answer? Share it in a comment.

Join & Write a Comment

Featured Post

What Kind of Coding Program is Right for You?

There are many ways to learn to code these days. From coding bootcamps like Flatiron School to online courses to totally free beginner resources. The best way to learn to code depends on many factors, but the most important one is you. See what course is best for you.

  • 3
  • 2
Tackle projects and never again get stuck behind a technical roadblock.
Join Now